You can do all that and still play like yourself too.You can of course take lessons, read books on theory and learn to play like all those other people who've taken lessons and read books on theory.
You can do all that and still play like yourself too.You can of course take lessons, read books on theory and learn to play like all those other people who've taken lessons and read books on theory.
Who cares about sight reading? I have no intention of playing in an orchestra so I might get by playing by ear.
What's your thoughts?
Give it a go. It's not really a question any of us can answer for you, is it? Lots here play by ear, lots read, or do both. It's all good.Would it not make more sense for me to continue playing by ear? Eventually I might be able to nail all simple melodies first time.
Only meaningful difference is that no-one learns to read before they hear and tell stories by ear.I compare it to only being able to know a story if someone tells or reads it to you, rather than being able to read stories yourself any time you wanted to. […]
Well, you don’t need it until you need it. If you then get asked to do a gig which involves lots of reading for many $$$$ then you you’re sunk.Who cares about sight reading? I have no intention of playing in an orchestra so I might get by playing by ear.
What's your thoughts?
Yes, this is such a strange phenomenon when you meet good players like this.I know quite a few people who are ‘trapped on the page’ - if asked to pick up a song by ear they think it impossible.
Presumably your instrument fluency isn’t at the same level as your speaking voice? There’s your main answer.As a child I learned to read by painstakingly deciphering words letter by letter, and then suddenly became able to recognise whole words. As an adult in my late twenties I went through the exact same process when I learned Russian. However, when reading music, I am stuck at the letter by letter, or rather note by note level. I don’t know whether I am musically dyslexic, or whether it is a function of ageing ( I did not take up music till my early thirties). Whatever the cause, it’s damn frustrating!
