Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Who cares about sight reading? I have no intention of playing in an orchestra so I might get by playing by ear.

What's your thoughts?

Your Sax, your playing, your experience. Enjoy 🙂

You don't though,have to be an expert at reading music, or an expert at understanding theory, to benefit from it. I'm certainly neither, I prefer to learn and play stuff by ear, but it's nice to know a bit of theory and read a bit of music. Certainly doesn't do any harm.
 
As others have indicated its a useful skill. Some musical greats have not read music at all, not even chord charts but if one is going to be on that road one has to have a really good ear for what is going on in the music if you really want to be part of what is going on.

Having said that I have played with lots of people over the years that haven't a clue what is going on harmonically though I admit most of what they play has left me wishing I was somewhere else LOL
 
Sorry maybe I have misled you guys, As I said in my post in the doorbell forum, I can read music, I just find it very taxing and certainly not enjoyable. I'm mostly concentrating on the paper and not listening to my music. Very restrictive for me.
Playing by ear let's me open up and play what I hear. Copying the greats must be the way forward.
 
I find that if all my attention is on listening to what is going on and I am "in the zone" it works well.

In the big R & B band that I play in (for fun) I know most of the charts and the chart require little attention to keep my place so can use most of my attention to be listening. to the music. In my solo's I dont look at the chart at all.
 
The thread appears to have missed a distinction between “reading” and “sight reading”. I interpret the latter as the ability to play a previously unseen piece in a fluent manner - not necessarily at the written tempo. What other interpretation could there be?
 
I think reading is like typing. Many get by with two finger hunt and peck. I can decipher written music, but I'll never be a sight reader. I have no desire to be in a band that requires reading. At most, I'll be the leader giving others charts. But if I could wave a magic wand, I'd be happy to read to learn new tunes.
 
To be able to sight read in a fluent fashion must take loads of practice?
I can read, albeit very slowly. Would it not make more sense for me to continue playing by ear? Eventually I might be able to nail all simple melodies first time.
 
Have a read of this 🙂


Personal choice and should be driven by your ambitions but I would have thought ideal to aim for both. You might be better at one than the other...

Jx
 
As a child I learned to read by painstakingly deciphering words letter by letter, and then suddenly became able to recognise whole words. As an adult in my late twenties I went through the exact same process when I learned Russian. However, when reading music, I am stuck at the letter by letter, or rather note by note level. I don’t know whether I am musically dyslexic, or whether it is a function of ageing ( I did not take up music till my early thirties). Whatever the cause, it’s damn frustrating!
 
Ultimately, it's whatever you wish to do.

But. Being able to read music and sight-reading are not quite the same thing as noted above. The similarity is both require practice. You didn't learn to read fluently in 5 minutes and reading music is not dissimilar.

Sight-reading is something which improves the more you do it. Maybe I'm a masochist, but I enjoy sight-reading. That's probably because when I started singing lessons in my 30s, I started going to choral workshops and you get music at those which you've never seen before and spend the day getting round them and performing them. Over time, you get better at it.

When I started playing cello and sax in my early 50s, I immediately joined community groups (a lesson I learnt from singing) to play in.

Last Sunday, 8 years later, I went to a play day with my orchestra and sight-read for 3 solid hours: Weber's overture to Die Freischutz, Elgar's Sea Pictures, Dvorak Symphony No. 9, 1st movement of Prokofiev violin concerto no. 3, a Rondo for bassoon and orchestra by Weber, and a medley of cartoon music....

Did I get every note? No. Did I get some notes? Yes. Did I get lost / lose my place? No (because I've got to be quite decent at reading and staying in the right place). Was it fun / enjoyable? Yes.

If you play with a band / group that rehearses, you don't necessarily need to be able to "play at sight" part of the purpose of the rehearsal is to address that (the main part is for you to hear your part in the context of the other parts...).

Reading from notation provides you with a lot of opportunities. Being a 'good sight reader' is a bonus, but not essential. Like other skills, it improves with practice.
 
I compare it to only being able to know a story if someone tells or reads it to you, rather than being able to read stories yourself any time you wanted to. […]
Only meaningful difference is that no-one learns to read before they hear and tell stories by ear.
I know quite a few people who are ‘trapped on the page’ - if asked to pick up a song by ear they think it impossible. But learning to read is simple in principle - easier than finding where to put your fingers on the sax.
50 years ago you could still meet people who wouldn’t learn to read (words, I mean) because their parents didn’t see the need, so why should they…
 
We're all different. Do what suits you.
Since I like to play all sorts of music I do both reading and not reading.
Gigs are (these days) not reading. 95% improvised and the rest memory (when it works).
Tomorrow I'll be spending the morning reading stuff like this accompanied by a very good piano playing friend.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TH9WoJ2XC-s

This is not something I would care to try without being able to read.
I also gig occasionally with a function band as part of a horn section. All the parts are charted - improvising is not an option.
 
Sight reading can be fun. I struggle even on practised pieces, but when the Cafe7 meet @tenorviol regularly tries out some thing new that none of us have ever seen or even heard before, sometimes it works great. Other times ....
If any of us could not sight read we would never be able to do that.
Thanks to @tenorviol for helping with this.:thumb:
 
I would have to say, you do what you can to make the best music you can. It is always better that you know how to do more things with your instrument(s), as long as it isn't at the expense of a particular goal. For example, if you want to play free all the time and you find that somehow reading interferes with that process (which I doubt), then follow the path to the goal. The little reading I am capable of definitely helps me in some situations. If there was a magic wand, I'd use it to be able to sight read, but I won't put in the time necessary to do it. That would have needed to happen much earlier in my life and career.
PS, good reading skills are a huge part of getting paid work.
 
Who cares about sight reading? I have no intention of playing in an orchestra so I might get by playing by ear.

What's your thoughts?
Well, you don’t need it until you need it. If you then get asked to do a gig which involves lots of reading for many $$$$ then you you’re sunk.
But, seeing as music is so vast, if you don’t think you’re going to use it, spend the extra time elsewhere.
 
As a child I learned to read by painstakingly deciphering words letter by letter, and then suddenly became able to recognise whole words. As an adult in my late twenties I went through the exact same process when I learned Russian. However, when reading music, I am stuck at the letter by letter, or rather note by note level. I don’t know whether I am musically dyslexic, or whether it is a function of ageing ( I did not take up music till my early thirties). Whatever the cause, it’s damn frustrating!
Presumably your instrument fluency isn’t at the same level as your speaking voice? There’s your main answer.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,565
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom