Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

Can you do that? What happens? Can you do it on the sax?
Thanks for this reply. I've been doing this on sax for ages. My teacher says it's is all very well, but it's got to fit with what the other guys are playing. Since I have never had the experience of playing with other guys in this way, I don't know whether what I do would fit. I like to think that I might be developing enough "feel" for the music for my efforts to fit.

When I sing in Chapel (my voice is dreadful so I sing only when there are enough others to drown my efforts) I seem to get the pitch and timing instinctively and I try to devise harmonies. Maybe improvisation of the kind we're on about depends on being able to play sax equally effortlessly. I'm on my way there but I've still got miles to go!

I've been invited to sit in with a local jazz band (they know I'm learning sax but have never heard me play) and my immediate aim is to reach a standard such that I dare do so, bearing in mind that there's an audience. I hope to do this soon and if I get a second chance I'll be able to try-out bits of "embroidery".

I think there may be a difference between this kind of jazz (New Orleans style) and the more modern styles where improvisation is playing something that fits the chord structure but is otherwise unrelated to the melody from which it started. I've tried this to a limited extent but the results haven't pleased me.
 
Is there any connection between playing by ear and improvisation? I haven't learned to improvise so I have no firm opinion but I would have thought that "ear" is essential to improvisation, otherwise how can one recognise the chords as they change and know what goes with them? I repeat, I can't improvise so I don't know how it's done and I'm asking a question rather than making an assertion.

I can't improvise either! Come to think of it I can't play by ear either and my reading is coming on but only slowly!

In my simple little world playing by ear is to listen to a piece of music, work out how to replicate each note, rest etc on the sax and play the piece! For me very tricky!

Improvising is to play a piece of music, which you reading or have read and memorised or have memorised following learning it by ear, and then construct some more music which is inspired by and relates to the piece you are playing.

My understanding is that a lot (but not all) improvisation is based on the key signature and related scale - arpeggios - chords of the piece you are playing.

Which of course brings us back to knowing how to read music, which I understand is not necessary to master playing by ear or improvisation!!!

Since taking up the sax I spend a lot of time in a state of confusion!!
 
Is there any connection between playing by ear and improvisation? I haven't learned to improvise so I have no firm opinion but I would have thought that "ear" is essential to improvisation, otherwise how can one recognise the chords as they change and know what goes with them? I repeat, I can't improvise so I don't know how it's done and I'm asking a question rather than making an assertion.

Normally you know what the chords are and when they change in advance so in theory you only need your ears if you get lost. 🙂 In practice I think the two are related and probably doing one helps the other.
 
Is there any connection between playing by ear and improvisation?
Yes, yes and yes again.
I haven't learned to improvise so I have no firm opinion but I would have thought that "ear" is essential to improvisation, otherwise how can one recognise the chords as they change and know what goes with them?
Not only that, but:

Playing by ear: hear a tune one or more times (probably dozens in my case) and play it.

Improvising: hear an idea (even if it's only a very short one) in your imagination (possibly while playing something else) and play it at exactly the right moment without hesitation.

If you can't do the first (like me, so far), you have no chance with the second. As the saying goes "if you can't hear it, you can't play it."
 
Thanks for this reply. I've been doing this on sax for ages.

Ah, well in that case I would say you can improvise.

I've been invited to sit in with a local jazz band

Great, hope it goes well!

I think there may be a difference between this kind of jazz (New Orleans style) and the more modern styles where improvisation is playing something that fits the chord structure but is otherwise unrelated to the melody from which it started. I've tried this to a limited extent but the results haven't pleased me.

Maybe the extremes are far apart but I'd say there is a lot of overlap between the two styles in this respect.
 
Which of course brings us back to knowing how to read music, which I understand is not necessary to master playing by ear or improvisation!!!
Not true. None of the players in the local jazz band I mentioned (except the pianist who is a very highly trained musician) can read the dots but they all improvise and it sounds great.

I think you ought to have a go at playing by ear, maybe when your head is aching after reading to many dots. Take a peek at the suggestions I made to Jeanette in this thread a few days ago.
 
This question always leads to much debate. When I taught public schools, administrators and even fellow music teachers felt it was much more important to read than learn by ear. After taking a fantastic course at Hartt by Chris Azzarra on Creativity through Improvisation, I was exposed to first learning by ear (so when you read you will have a foundation/vocabulary to draw upon), then learning to read. This process follows how we learn to read language; we don't start off reading books. Parents babble to us, we babble back. They talk to us, we start saying words, partial sentences, complete sentences, etc. I wrote some articles on my website, but you can also check out www.GIML.org to learn about Music Learning Theory, which is all about how we learn music
 
In my simple little world playing by ear is to listen to a piece of music, work out how to replicate each note, rest etc on the sax and play the piece!

My understanding is that a lot (but not all) improvisation is based on the key signature and related scale - arpeggios - chords of the piece you are playing.

Well unless you were playing "free jazz", it would have to be. The key signature and the scales/arpeggios/chords are the piece. The thing is though, you don't need to know what any of things are called, you only need to know what they sound like.

Playing by ear is just the same as what you do when you sing a pop song or a hymn. You don't need to work out how to replicate each note and rest, you don't need to know anything about key signatures or scales or arpeggios or chords to do that.
 
When I taught public schools, administrators and even fellow music teachers felt it was much more important to read than learn by ear. After taking a fantastic course at Hartt by Chris Azzarra on Creativity through Improvisation, I was exposed to first learning by ear (so when you read you will have a foundation/vocabulary to draw upon), then learning to read. This process follows how we learn to read language; we don't start off reading books. Parents babble to us, we babble back. They talk to us, we start saying words, partial sentences, complete sentences, etc. I wrote some articles on my website, but you can also check out www.GIML.org to learn about Music Learning Theory, which is all about how we learn music

I'm looking forward to that, I am very interested in how we learn but I have never read anything about it. I think one reason music teachers (and administrators) focus on reading and theory is that it is something concrete you can teach (and examine), another reason may be that it can be difficult to talk about and teach music without referring to theory and written music.
 
it can be difficult to talk about and teach music without referring to theory and written music.
I suggest that there's a huge difference between learning to improvise and teaching the same. You learn to improvise by playing it and finding what sounds right to you and what the audience likes. But how can you teach that? By analysing what popular musicians are doing when they improvise, codifying it into a set of rules then teaching those rules. A player who can apply those rules as he blows has a head-start but it doesn't necessarily mean that he will be able to improvise well. To my mind, what matters with improvisation is how it sounds, although I get the impression that some erudite musicians and critics are more concerned with musical cleverness.
If "how it sounds" is what matters, then there's scope for stretching or working outside the rules. Charlie Parker and Lester Young did this. At the time they were criticised for doing it wrong but public acclaim overcame that and no doubt the rules were re-written to include analyses of what they were doing.
For myself, although I'm beginning to understand the rules of how improvisation works, I doubt whether I'll ever be able to apply them. Therefore, if I get more than one chance with the local jazz band (maybe my lack of skill will stretch their tolerance too far!) I'm going to experiment gently and hope that I develop improvisation on an instinctive basis.
 
For myself, although I'm beginning to understand the rules of how improvisation works, I doubt whether I'll ever be able to apply them. Therefore, if I get more than one chance with the local jazz band (maybe my lack of skill will stretch their tolerance too far!) I'm going to experiment gently and hope that I develop improvisation on an instinctive basis.

I think you are underrating yourself and overrating the difficulty of applying the "rules".

My suggestion with the local jazz band is, say very little if anything, cultivate an air of mystery, and when it comes to your time to play, play very few notes but play them with TOTAL CONVICTION.
 
Playing by ear? I wish I could!
Playing off the notes? I wish I could!
Improvising from theory? I wish I could!
Improvising by instinct? I wish I could!

Seriously, I suppose that each of these things I can do to some degree. Some less than others: for me, with no musical education/training to speak of before age 50, the "from ear" side of things is hardest, furthest from my comfort zone. The reading and theory side of things is something I can approach intellectually and trust to the rules that what I produce will not be too awful (In fact I think it's never enough to approach it intellectually, there has to be some element of playing by ear to provide the feedback needed - bit like a cook who follows a recipe: it's probably going to work, but will be much better with some cook's instinct - tasting and adjusting as it goes)

As I see it, there are 2 separate aspects to this playing by ear: "pre-hearing" the tune or the improvisation in your head; and then actually producing on the instrument, the musical fragment in your head. By analogy to speaking, it's "thinking of something to say", followed by "saying it".

Part I - thinking of something to say/play - can I guess be reached in many ways: from innate musical imagination, and creativity, fueled by a combination of much listening and absorbing of styles and licks and quotes, just as when speaking, thinking of something to say is a combination of what comes from within, and what you've learned, formally or casually.

Part II - being able to actually produce on the instrument what is in your head - here it seems to me that the goal (possibly unattainable) is for it to be as natural as speaking. People say, if you can hum or sing an impro, then you can improvise. Well, only if you are as much at one with your instrument as you are with your voicebox. This is I think a very hard thing to do for those of us with little musical training: it really is about building connections in the brain that forge strong links between the musical imagination/memory with the fingers/tongue/throat, all guided in a feedback loop using the ears.

I am encouraged by the feeling that I do keep making slow progress towards all of these goals. Anyhow even if I am deluding myself, at least I'm having fun doing it!

Apologies for the ramble..
 
As I see it, there are 2 separate aspects to this playing by ear: "pre-hearing" the tune or the improvisation in your head; and then actually producing on the instrument, the musical fragment in your head. By analogy to speaking, it's "thinking of something to say", followed by "saying it".

Is that what it feels like to you when you speak? To me, it feels like I just say something, without the step of "thinking of something to say". And it's the same with playing by ear. Or singing.

Anyhow even if I am deluding myself, at least I'm having fun doing it!

That's actually my mission statement.
 
Is that what it feels like to you when you speak? To me, it feels like I just say something, without the step of "thinking of something to say". And it's the same with playing by ear. Or singing.

I take your point, but actually yes: some of the time I do think before I speak, and often that works out better for me! 😀

And there are definitely times when I am tongue-tied, when I know in my head exactly what I want to say but I can't express it. The same when I am improvising, I hear beautiful phrases in my head that come out a bit rubbish ...

But to be fair I could have expressed that better. I was really trying to say that a good improvisation needs both content (what to play) and delivery (actually playing), and of course one doesn't cleanly separate these as distinct stages, but I do think they are distinct aspects.
 
I take your point, but actually yes: some of the time I do think before I speak, and often that works out better for me! 😀

Yeah, me too, but for me that is less usual, not the default position. You've probably heard musicians say that it can feel like the instrument is playing itself? I think Charlie Parker said that is something you should aim for.
 
here it seems to me that the goal (possibly unattainable) is for it to be as natural as speaking
I don't think this is unattainable. It comes with playing by "ear" - I find that I can play simple melodies in easy keys straight off without prior practice. It comes to me naturally. I struggle with more difficult melodies in awkward keys but I'm improving slowly. It's the result of years of years of tootling to myself, not "practice" in the conventional sense, just playing anything that comes into my head for fun. Don't get the impression that I'm much good yet, but I think that if I can bring together all the stuff that I've learned in a random manner and improve on it I'll be on my way to becoming a master of my instrument.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom