Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

she'll never be happy without dots to play.
And this is the big issue.

I think you should be stuck to neither one nor the other. Learn both.

Reading music is a skill that involves not just reading music, but by osmosis you can also write it. that is a big plus because it means you can communicate stuff to other players who can read, and often more efficiently than playing it and having them learn it by ear. Saves a lot of rehearsal time.
 
And this is the big issue.

I think you should be stuck to neither one nor the other. Learn both.

Reading music is a skill that involves not just reading music, but by osmosis you can also write it. that is a big plus because it means you can communicate stuff to other players who can read, and often more efficiently than playing it and having them learn it by ear. Saves a lot of rehearsal time.
I agree: being able to sight-read, play by ear and improvise is the ideal, but it's something that not all of us are going to achieve. As for rehearsal time, I get the impression that although they practice, the local jazzers don't rehearse at all. They know most of the tunes and if there's on that's unfamiliar, they listen as it's being played then join in when they've got the hang of it. If I could do that I'd be a happy chappie.
 
All true. But the original question that this arose from was from a beginner. That's where the mistake is being made. Beginners are given the impression that the way you play music is by reading dots, or as you put it, their education is too biased towards the "on paper" aspect.

I take exception to this comment having taught beginning and intermediate students how to play musical instruments for over 30 years. "Playing by ear" is what is called "rote learning". Another term for that is parroting. It involves hearing something over and over and then repeating it back. There is nothing wrong with this way of learning. It is the way children learn to speak and understand language.

However there is a higher level of learning which follows in developed countries all over the world. In those countries, children taught early in their school experience that words are made up of sounds which can be represented by the characters in the alphabet which makes up their native language. They are taught the names of those symbols, the sounds they make, and how they are combined to make words. Eventually they are taught how words are put together to represent thoughts and ideas. They can then read the thoughts and ideas of others, and share their own thoughts and ideas in writing.

Just as children are given the gift of literacy in their spoken language, music teachers teach literacy in the language of music. Learning to read the language of music opens the doors to playing music more challenging than simple folk tunes, playing music with others in large and small ensembles, and to the ability to create one's own music and share it with others. Anyone who has set foot in a beginning music classroom knows that teachers encourage students to try to play other melodies they have heard besides those in the music book with the notes (fingerings) they have learned so far. They are also given assignments to make up their own original songs using those notes. It is absurd to suggest that professionals in music education have a bias against students developing their "ear" or using their creativity. Of course some children go faster and farther than others based upon their background and natural abilities, but the goal is to give every student the best positive musical experience possible.

Musical illiteracy may be a reasonable individual choice for those starting later in life, but should never be a recommendation for young people at the beginning of their musical exploration and experience.
 
Thread re opened.

Please keep the discussion civil

Another reason could be that you're being kinda rude'ish, it's a thin line that i can't quite define, but you're defonately not playing all of this as nice as you probably could.. Not to say that everyone else does, but i hope you get my point! 🙂
.

I think Bolding managed to put it very well. There is a hard to define thin line and we do all read things differently just be aware of that. If a post upsets you report it rather than respond on the forum and/or take it up with the member concerned by PC.

Thank-you

Jx
 
I don't think that anyone is going to disagree with the proposition that it's best to be able both to sight-read and play by ear. How can being unable to do one of these be an advantage?
However, each of us has different abilities and plays saxophone with his/her own level of commitment. Some musicians don't even want to play by ear and others find reading music so difficult that the only way to play at all is to do without. The unwillingness to learn to do one or the other shouldn't be characterised as "laziness". For most of us, music is about pleasure. Each of us makes his/her own decisions about the amount of effort to apply to this end.
I can understand why a teacher will regard reading music as a vital skill, for how otherwise can he/she set exercises, pieces to practice, etc? I suspect that most non-readers are self-taught.
 
I take exception to this comment having taught beginning and intermediate students how to play musical instruments for over 30 years.

I don't see why you should take exception. You may be an excellent teacher, I believe you probably are, but that doesn't mean that all music teachers are excellent.
 
However, each of us has different abilities and plays saxophone with his/her own level of commitment. Some musicians don't even want to play by ear and others find reading music so difficult that the only way to play at all is to do without. The unwillingness to learn to do one or the other shouldn't be characterised as "laziness". For most of us, music is about pleasure. Each of us makes his/her own decisions about the amount of effort to apply to this end.
There is also the pleasure of learning a new skill. In the specific, after a few years not reading big band charts I got called for a rehearsal only to find out that I was badly substandard and had to learn to play clarinet too. I was over 40 at the time. It is pretty cool learning something new as an adult. you don't have that feeling that your life finished when you turned 18.
On the other side, playing by year can be seen as "instant transcribing". If you can read, eventually you will learn to write too (OK, not that fun).

I can understand why a teacher will regard reading music as a vital skill, for how otherwise can he/she set exercises, pieces to practice, etc? I suspect that most non-readers are self-taught.
My students (aged around 12) successfully avoid reading using the meanest means, above all compulsively forgetting the book.
Great revenge is telling them how notation works and giving them a written piece to work out at home.
After a while they accept some reading in the class.
In an extreme case, a student had to be deported to Switzerland, where he is just reading, now.
 
Better guidance about the nature of written music and its relationship to actual music, about the different ways of learning. The situation is particularly clear with traditional music, where learning by listening and imitation is absolutely essential and learning from written music is unnecessary and can be extremely counterproductive. But all the sax players at that beginners' jam session I mentioned would benefit from similar advice. They were all overly dependent on the written music.

The only poss distinction between trad and whatever its opposite number in this debate may be called is that the traditional stuff is far less likely to have been written down. But if the music is written well it will be as good as, in any sense of the word, the unwritten stuff. I cannot see any situation when reading written music can possibly be counterproductive. It is like saying that being able to speak a language makes a knowledge of grammar counterproductive. Why would it? Perhaps you dont need the knowledge to chat, but how can the knowledge possibly be counterproductive? It is all a part of the subject. How can it hurt to know more about it? A bit of a hassle to learn is what I think is meant by the dot bashers. Louis Armstrong learnt to read in order to play in Fate Marable's band on the river boats. How stilted was he? Not very. Why did Fate Marable only have readers in his band? Only one reason, to make it tight. Best to be fab at reading and playing by ear. Be nice that would. There are many musicians I have met who are. To assume that these guys are any the less in the musical line because they sight read, is pretty dangerous ground and likely to lead to some serious humiliation come playtime.


What is "actual music"?

Exactly. Couldn't have put it better myself but trust you to jump in first. Go back to sleep, it is Saturday.
 
If I remember correctly somewhere in Miles' autobiography he tells a story about Hendrix (who it seems he admired) staying with him. Miles apparently had a number of scores that he thought that Hendrix should study, and it seems that he was somewhat disappointed when he didn't. Just an example of a well respected jazz musician valuing reading.
 
Without theory how do you know what a chord is ?
Well, this is one of the issues when communicating with guitarists.
Many of them think in terms of "grips" where A minor seventh is that hand shape. They often don't even realize that they are actually playing an E at the bass. Aminorseventh is just a word.

Forget asking them "just the 3rd and the 7th, please"; they will panic (based on a true story).

Not many guitarists can read big band charts.
 
Well, this is one of the issues when communicating with guitarists.
Many of them think in terms of "grips" where A minor seventh is that hand shape. They often don't even realize that they are actually playing an E at the bass. Aminorseventh is just a word.

Forget asking them "just the 3rd and the 7th, please"; they will panic (based on a true story).

Not many guitarists can read big band charts.
Luckily I know one who has heard of Freddie Green (and taken notice).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom