Now I think that you got allot of good points Bernie, and i think that allot of people are undervalue'ing the ability of playing by ear, and the ability's gained in the process of playing by ear.
However...
Having been in the same train of thought as you for about a 1 year, i set out to play music directly from the soul, rather than from paper.
Now, i achieved allot of things while just improvising along with the old classics, Lester Young, Billie Holiday, Louis Armstrong & so on.
I can now do so many things over theese kind of changes, and perfectly harmonize where i need to. Wich means, i learned some actual music theory, improvising, however... At the speed you learn while improvising, you have to categorize and name/define allot of musical-phenomenons you encounter along the way. And while some of this is straight forward, you get to a point where it's like re-inventing the wheel, why bother when there's litterature available wich allready has the categories & definitions of the basic things your trying to define, to create your music...
I agree, if you wanna just play jazz standards, you're probably not gonna need much theoretical knowlegde, if any, and what you might need, you can probably get through improvising and analysing.
But even so, I'd consider it counter productive, not to atleast study the very basics of musical theory. But only after the player has played for a year or so, untill then i agree it will only confuse the player. Atleast thats my experience.
About the out/in group-think.
I think the main reason people are skeptical to your opinions is that "jazz" is such a controversial word, and i bet many of us has different ideas of what jazz is to us.
Another reason could be that you're being kinda rude'ish, it's a thin line that i can't quite define, but you're defonately not playing all of this as nice as you probably could.. Not to say that everyone else does, but i hope you get my point! 🙂
I don't think it's group-think, thats the reason behind any of this.. While I've been on this forum (not an awfull long time btw), I've encountered individuality everywhere and naturally allot of healthy disagreements. That being said, i think most of the cafe members are too considerate, to fall victim to that kind of mentality.