Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I saw a concert by Al Di Meola with a couple of otherr guitarists. The whole concert was played from the notes, not by ear. He's probably a better jazz musician than most.

You need to read what I say more carefully kev.
 
You need to read what I say more carefully Chris. I'm not saying people shouldn't read music or that there are no advantages to reading music, I'm saying that reading music isn't essential, but the ability to play by ear is.
Reading the above carefully I understand that you believe that you can't be a good musician if you can't play by ear. I suppose that works if you define "good musician" as someone who can play by ear. However, I know and have known many people who I would call "good musicians" who cannot play by ear but can interpret the dots on a page very well.
 
Reading the above carefully I understand that you believe that you can't be a good musician if you can't play by ear. I suppose that works if you define "good musician" as someone who can play by ear. However, I know and have known many people who I would call "good musicians" who cannot play by ear but can interpret the dots on a page very well.

Still not careful enough reading Nick. I am saying you can't be a good jazz musician if you can't play by ear.
 
Can't we just have a forthright and rational discussion?
We can but try 🙂

I have been following this thread with some personal interest. My story fwiw. I decided 4 years ago at the ripe old age of 47 I needed a hobby, decided learning to play an instrument would be fun. Took me a good few months to decide what but eventually settled on sop.

Knowing nothing about music or saxophones I booked a lesson and decided to hire a sax. My lessons started straight away with being told to buy a book and we worked through it learning note names, length and fingering.

So whilst learning how to play the notes I was learning to read music.

I changed teachers and continued in the same vein. During all this time I was conscious that I couldn't play anything without a piece of music to follow. I joined an orchestra which in some ways helped and others hindered but I couldn't have contemplated this if I couldn't read music ( knowing what you are supposed to play and actually playing it are in my opinion two very distinct skills)

Being aware that I couldn't name a note just by hearing it or that I couldn't knock a tune out by ear I know I still have a long way to go. Because of that I think I get what Bernie is saying and I need to do more without a sheet of music in front of me, hence my feeble attempts at IOTM.

But even if I had started without learning to read music I would now be sat here thinking that was the next step as I love playing with others and some of those opportunities involve a formal orchestra so the ability to read is required.

It is an individuals choice, it depends what musical direction you want to take. It is a journey for us all and we are all at different points on that journey. The guy that Bernie thought didn't play the head well is on his journey and unless you know him well cannot know at what point he is at.

It is a personal thing no right or wrong way to learn. Just enjoy it 🙂

Jx
 
I'm saying that reading music isn't essential, but the ability to play by ear is.

Not for the tenor in a BigBand as all the parts are written out beforehand, only thing needed the ability to read.

Then you have something interesting and new to learn about music.

How with out a sheet do you know what to play when the someone says "Hey guys, 6th chord of the bridge lets make it ?????.. " If you only know tunes by ear??
 
Not for the tenor in a BigBand as all the parts are written out beforehand, only thing needed the ability to read.



How with out a sheet do you know what to play when the someone says "Hey guys, 6th chord of the bridge lets make it ?????.. " If you only know tunes by ear??

How about at big band rehearsal when the conductor says, "Let's start on bar 27. A one, two, three, four." There are valid arguments on both sides of the "reading music" fence. Anyway, this is like beating a dead horse at this point. I'm out.
 
Last edited:
You need to read what I say more carefully kev.

I don't think so. You're starting with the premise that playing by ear is a pre-requisite for jazz musicians. It's certainly an important part of jazz. But not all of jazz. For instance most, if not all of the great jazz solos from the big band era were rehearsed until note perfect.

If we're really talking about improvisation, then probably yes, but not essential in all circumstances. But improvisation isn't limited to jazz. It's a feature of rock, folk, classical - many genres... But now we have to change the definition to good improvisor, not good jazz musician. And as soon as we talk about improvisation, knowledge and understanding of theory and harmony as well as feeling amnd hearing are fundamental. Whether taught or assimilated. And as the examples above showed there's a good place for both ear playing and written music.

Your decision to reject written music is yours, not ours. I'm not going to attempt to change you. Please do us the courtesy of accepting that we can find it useful and still be good musicians - jazz or otherwise.
 
I believe it would take a phenomenal talent bordering on genius to become successful in the music field without some knowledge of notation and theory.

The piano is the only instrument I can think of where you don't have to pitch the note. Having said that I've read and heard tales of pianists turning up to a gig where the piano is a semitone flat and they have to take it up, to play with the band.

Most people who say they don't read mean they don't sight read.
 
I don't think so.

If you want to understand what I'm saying, you'll have to read it more carefully and think about it more carefully.

If we're really talking about improvisation, then probably yes, but not essential in all circumstances. But improvisation isn't limited to jazz. It's a feature of rock, folk, classical - many genres... But now we have to change the definition to good improvisor, not good jazz musician.

You're getting yourself in a muddle here.

And as soon as we talk about improvisation, knowledge and understanding of theory and harmony as well as feeling and hearing are fundamental.

Nope. You don't need to know any theory at all to do that, any more than you need theory to improvise singing.

Your decision to reject written music is yours, not ours.

There's the in-group/out-group thing again.

Please do us the courtesy of accepting that we can find it useful and still be good musicians - jazz or otherwise.

Do me the courtesy of reading what I am saying more carefully, and think about it before responding again.
 
I believe it would take a phenomenal talent bordering on genius to become successful in the music field without some knowledge of notation and theory.

You're simply mistaken.

The piano is the only instrument I can think of where you don't have to pitch the note.

You don't need to know any theory to pitch a note. You don't need to know any theory to sing pop songs or hymns, in tune, in time. You don't need to know any theory or notation to work out chords on a guitar, write pop songs, record them and make millions, if that's what you call success.
 
While reading the notes you're also playing by ear.

That's exactly what the people I have in mind are not doing. For example that guy at the jam session I went to. He was reading the music without playing by ear, which is why he kept making the same mistake.
 
Not for the tenor in a BigBand as all the parts are written out beforehand, only thing needed the ability to read.
While reading the notes you're also playing by ear. Dots are just the reminder of how it goes.

Or your ear knows what to expect looking at the dots.
An example of magnanimous bandleader: we went through the chart once, because I've never seen it before. Lights off. Go.

I know what I missed and where, but the goal is making it sound as musical as possible. Dots or not.
In case you are wondering, on the charts there are dots to be plaid "as is", dots to be interpreted, chords.
And tempo changes....
But Beautiful
 
Now I think that you got allot of good points Bernie, and i think that allot of people are undervalue'ing the ability of playing by ear, and the ability's gained in the process of playing by ear.

However...
Having been in the same train of thought as you for about a 1 year, i set out to play music directly from the soul, rather than from paper.
Now, i achieved allot of things while just improvising along with the old classics, Lester Young, Billie Holiday, Louis Armstrong & so on.
I can now do so many things over theese kind of changes, and perfectly harmonize where i need to. Wich means, i learned some actual music theory, improvising, however... At the speed you learn while improvising, you have to categorize and name/define allot of musical-phenomenons you encounter along the way. And while some of this is straight forward, you get to a point where it's like re-inventing the wheel, why bother when there's litterature available wich allready has the categories & definitions of the basic things your trying to define, to create your music...

I agree, if you wanna just play jazz standards, you're probably not gonna need much theoretical knowlegde, if any, and what you might need, you can probably get through improvising and analysing.

But even so, I'd consider it counter productive, not to atleast study the very basics of musical theory. But only after the player has played for a year or so, untill then i agree it will only confuse the player. Atleast thats my experience.

About the out/in group-think.

I think the main reason people are skeptical to your opinions is that "jazz" is such a controversial word, and i bet many of us has different ideas of what jazz is to us.

Another reason could be that you're being kinda rude'ish, it's a thin line that i can't quite define, but you're defonately not playing all of this as nice as you probably could.. Not to say that everyone else does, but i hope you get my point! 🙂

I don't think it's group-think, thats the reason behind any of this.. While I've been on this forum (not an awfull long time btw), I've encountered individuality everywhere and naturally allot of healthy disagreements. That being said, i think most of the cafe members are too considerate, to fall victim to that kind of mentality.
 
It's my opinion that playing by ear comes naturally to some, playing the dots to others. If reading had been essential to playing sax, I would have given up long ago. By contrast, recently I lent my spare alto to a lady who wanted to learn to play and tried to help her to make a start. When she'd mastered the basic two handfuls of notes and was happily playing the exercises in a beginner's book, I suggested that she should have a go at "When the Saints Come Marching In" purely by "ear", ie memory. When I next saw her she'd learned to play it, but from sheet music. I've realised that this lady is the complete opposite to me - she'll never be happy without dots to play.
Incidentally this same lady surprised me by being able to sound the very low notes early-on, but she still struggles with the upper register - again, the complete opposite to me!
I doubt whether I shall ever be able to sight-read to a useful level but I'm getting better at deciphering sheet music. I use sheet music to check whether the things I play by ear are right. So often my memory of a tune differs from what it should be or the version that I've remembered is someone's improvisation.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom