Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

When I started this thread it was to find out what odd "quirky" things people do to help them learn to play a few bars that keep tripping them up.

I did not mean it to turn in to a discussion of the merits of playing by ear verses reading.
It does seems to be taking on somewhat opinionated tone. Surely a well rounded musician can do both to a greater or lesser extent.

However any chance of getting back to the original topic? (Knowing this forum I might just as well ask for the moon)
 
But all the sax players at that beginners' jam session I mentioned would benefit from similar advice. They were all overly dependent on the written music.
Maybe they haven't got the brain capacity (like me) to take the songs in (yet)
I know repetition is the key to it sticking but that means hours upon hours of practice, which some haven't got the time.
I do admire musicians who can decide together on a tune and just play it !
I'm a long long way from doing that but hope to achieve it....One day

Ps. Having musical knowledge before picking up a sax helps enormously !
 
When I started this thread it was to find out what odd "quirky" things people do to help them learn to play a few bars that keep tripping them up.

I did not mean it to turn in to a discussion of the merits of playing by ear verses reading.
It does seems to be taking on somewhat opinionated tone. Surely a well rounded musician can do both to a greater or lesser extent.

However any chance of getting back to the original topic? (Knowing this forum I might just as well ask for the moon)

Rob I can move the ear v reading posts to a new thread if you prefer?

Jx
 
Maybe they haven't got the brain capacity (like me) to take the songs in (yet).

I don't believe you don't have the brain capacity to take songs in. I think it's very unlikely that you can't sing some pop songs or hymns. If you can do that, you have taken those songs in.

Ps. Having musical knowledge before picking up a sax helps enormously !

If you can sing pop songs or hymns you have all the musical knowledge you need to play the sax. You don't need to know the names of the notes, you don't need to know about major and minor, or time signatures, or semibreves and minims.

I'm not saying that stuff isn't useful: it's essential if you want to play classical and certain other types of music, it's very useful if you want to talk about music with others, it's necessary if you want to learn by reading written music.

But it's not necessary if you just want to pick up an instrument and play it, and it doesn't help enormously, in fact it's pretty irrelevant, just as it's irrelevant when you learn to sing pop songs or hymns.
 
Speaking of playing backwards, we all practice scale patterns up and down.

I don't. Can't be bothered, don't see the point, life's too short. I don't want to play scales, I want to play tunes, so I just play tunes.

Why not back and forth too? It amounts to the same thing in my opinion.

I'm really struggling to understand how you would play a scale back and forth, if it doesn't mean exactly the same as up and down. One intriguing possibility however is that you are operating in a whole different dimension to normal humans, but if so I would urge extreme caution as modern physics predicts that if too much of you gets into another dimension you could easily find yourself sucked into a chronosynclastic infundibulum. And we all know what that means.
 
Some of the more complicated tunes I want to play, elude my ear. Looking at the tune written down explains things. Then I can hear it. If an improvisation I'm working is struggling, referencing the chord sequence can give it direction. Playing the bass line on baritone while the bass player sings, is easier and tighter if I read the chords from his book. Harmonising a tune you've never heard, in a performance, will become possible with it written down.

A lot of the aural tradition as I understand it, depends on playing it how it goes and handing this on. Jazz is very different.

We all have different aims and capabilities, but thinking of the saxophone as a one note at a time, melody instrument, is missing most of its potential. The point of learning scales is the same as learning the shapes of chords on a guitar. I like to strum the saxophone. It takes a lot of practice to make the fingers flow. If they've come to see you, it better be worth the price of the raffle ticket.

We are all built differently, with different life experiences, which colour our expectations. A person making the assumption, any one can do it because I can, is misguided.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom