kevgermany
ex Landrover Nut
- Messages
- 19,857
- Location
- Just north of Munich
YC, thanks. I've read the links, had seen some before. Interesting about the 37/48dB gap between normal and body sound. But it's still within the range of normal hearing... Which leads to the 'negligible' comments usually made. I measured my tenor at over 110dB. So assuming the 37dB figure applies we're talking body sounds in the 70dB range- easily audbile.
Benade is quoted as saying the tube must be rigid - presumably Benade said this because he knew that if the body tube vibrates, it's goign to emit sounds and affect the vibration of the air column inside the sax....
Maybe it's because the effects are small that not everyone hears them. And maybe the scientists are wrong to dismiss these differences as negligible. But I'm being selective, cos Butkus also had some interesting experiments designed to test whether people could reilably identify differences. And found no evidnece to say they could.
It's not an argument that's going to go away, not for a long time...
But enough.
Benade is quoted as saying the tube must be rigid - presumably Benade said this because he knew that if the body tube vibrates, it's goign to emit sounds and affect the vibration of the air column inside the sax....
Maybe it's because the effects are small that not everyone hears them. And maybe the scientists are wrong to dismiss these differences as negligible. But I'm being selective, cos Butkus also had some interesting experiments designed to test whether people could reilably identify differences. And found no evidnece to say they could.
It's not an argument that's going to go away, not for a long time...
But enough.


