Saxophones Laquer n sound

if the air in the horn is vibrating, then simple laws of physics i.e. action and reaction, dictate that the horn must be vibrating too. I can feel the vibration in my hands and with my lip. Even if the vibration comes only from the reed, that is attached to the body of the sax so the body of the sax must resonate with the reed. Either way, the sax itself is vibrating. Whether the lacquer makes a noticeable difference to the sound is a moot point, but IMHO something does. Pete
 
I can feel the sax vibrating through my fingers(but not all the time). And one of the reasons I play with a double lip embouchure is that I can't stand the vibration through my teeth.

But remember, the sound waves in a sax vibrate along the length, not from side to side, and that on a single note there are simply high and low pressure points inside the sax. Is there enpough pressure to distort the tube? Unlikely, otherwise the keyss wouldn't be closable (and the ones that are sprung shut would have such strong springs you wouldn't be able to open them). Anyway, as soon as the sax starts vibrating, the surfaces inside are moving, which will affect sound to some extent. And layers of lacquer will affect the vibrations. Is the effect significant? Ears are very sensitive, and sensitivity differs from one person to another.

Personally I don't care. I like a nice shiny sax, preferably in Silver. And dull brown, with spots of green and red isn't my thing.
 
Lacquer or plating main function is proctect the brass from corrosion. So a clear lacquer is just fine as protection. And it's just the outside of the sax that is laquered so I can't see how it can affect the tone. It's different with plated saxes. The inside is plated as well. And the thickness is depending how long the "silver bath" is. I don't know how silver or goldplating affect the tone. I think silver or goldplate gives the sax soft/smooth keyaction (less noise).

I don't think lacquer affect the tone!

Thomas
 
Addendum to my suggestions above.
In the true spirit of scientific research there would be at least two teams of researchers working over several years on large budgets and who would produce conflicting results.

Not too sure where you get your ideas about research from.....

What's actually needed is a double blind, placebo controlled trial. And yes, you could actually do it in a way that would be meaningful and produce reliable valid results. But where would the fun in that be?
 
I wonder if there would be a notable difference in tone If the sax were being played by a player in a pair of"Concrete Wellies" or even emersed up to ones neck in a VAT of Quick setting stuff . Surely the concrete would have some type of sympathetic harmonic?

I bet someone has even deleloped a Mpce made from Concrete . The Romans Invented it I believe
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is one of those "Everybody knows..." threads, where most assertions are completely lacking in any supporting scientific evidence. "My unlacquered XXUL sounds quite different from my XXL"

I think most experienced sax players would agree, however, that it is virtually impossible to build two identical saxes, consecutively, which will feel and sound the same.....you might, I suppose, find two in a large batch, but even that is not certain.
Given this, it appears that two unlaquered saxes are as likely to be as different from one another as a lacquered and unlaquered (or plated/unplated, bronze/brass/silver) of exactly the same design.
This means it is quite impossible to distinguish between any difference due to lacquer/plating/metal from the horn-to-horn variations on a production line of identically specified saxes.

And I'd bet a pound to a penny that an audience would not not be able to pick ....by sound alone... one from from another with any degree of statististical significance.

They may 'feel' different to the players....a very subjectve thing ....but that is not evidence that they actually sound different.


So it is virtually impossible to say with any real certainty that lacquer/plating/material affects the sound of two otherwise identical saxes(if such things actually exist) ...... but, hey, why let facts and evidence affect our prejudices and pre-conceptions (not to mention all the previous pontifications on the subject)? That's no fun at all. 🙂
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like the sound more on silver plated and unlacquered horns,yes i like the look also but i hear a difference and thats all i care about ,ME,ME, ME, people can start talking about the science but it is in 1 ear and oot the next.If i think i can thats all that matters,its my cash i spend and not theres.Same with ligatures,i find big differences between ligs,more so on response than sound but i still hear the sound factor.So it as always comes to personal choice,GET WHAT YOU LIKE AND WANT, I DO.
 
Davey

You're not looking very well in your picture....

I got took in the night by the BORG gas man,when he brought me back i had a new Borgani horn,i do look atad pale now though,get me arse on the sun beds the mora.Do you think the black latex and eye patch suit me sir !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
the reality is that " intuition" is a very bad thing when it comes to judging things which require science to evaluate, for the very simple reason that one might easily think that one is observing one thing while he is in fact observing another.

So , many have observed that while playing they can feel a vibration coming from the saxophone as in other instances they could have observed that a (church) bell vibrates and therefore they could be erroneously drawn to conclude that they are witnessing a similar phenomenon but they would be wrong.

A saxophone is made of similar metal of certain bells (big bells are made of bronze but you have smaller ones made of brass too ), and the endbit of the saxophone being a conical instrument resembles a bell and it is called a bell...........but it is not a bell.

In fact , as Pete says, if you ring a bell and you place an hand on the bell, the bell stops vibrating hence the sound stops .

This shows that the sound of a bell is produced by the vibration of its walls and amplified by the shape and the air inside which vibrates passively as the walls of the bell vibrate.


But now let's take a saxophone (your saxophone! ). Hit the saxophone softly with a mallet. Does it ring? NO! Why is that? It doesn't (in reality it vibrates very shortly because you hear a " thud" sound) because it is made of many and not well connected pieces of metal, leather and felt and , like a bell, if you dampen the vibration by sawing a bell and placing you hand on it, it won't resound.

Now make another experiment take a cloth, better if soaked with water or a piece of thin rubber . Play your saxophone , now play your saxophone wit a pice of rubber or a wet cloth tied around the bell , is the saxophone still playing? yes it is. I Propose that the sound is the same. Do this , if you can, with a double blind experiment. (you don't know and the audience don' t know), triple if possible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_experiment

Go back to your (church) bell, do the same with the bell. Is the bell still playing. No it isn't.


Go back to your saxophone and go to play you saxophone in a room where there is a drum (not a snare drum), play the saxophone. Does the drum vibrate? Yes it does. Does it actually produce an audible sound? No it doesn't or a very faint one (but a drum is not a saxophone)

Your saxophone vibrates and it does vibrate like everything vibrates when exposed to sound, passively, regardless whether the sound is produced within or without itself , of course you hear a piano resonating or a guitar because the sound boards of these instruments are amplifying even the minute passive vibrations of their strings but that is not the case of a saxophone.


The reed of a saxophone vibrates creating its sound within the mouthpiece which shapes and initiate the air column which vibrates in the saxophone. Yes of course bits and pieces of the saxophone would passively vibrate but with a much , much lower energy compared to the air column. As we have experimented before hitting the saxophone bell (your saxophone not mine!) with a mallet just produces a " thud" sound and no other vibration.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think milandro is spot on. I have certainly felt my sax vibrating when playing, but of course I would, having a large column of air vibrating powerfully inside it. The difference, imo, is that the sax is simply vibrating passively and with low energy as milandro says, whereas the (church) bell is resonating actively. And of course the bell only sounds one note (albeit with complex harmonics). The sax plays different notes primarily because it can change the size of the air column. If the sax itself were resonating (as opposed to vibrating passively), it would do so only at its own resonant frequency (and overtones).
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom