Saxophones Laquer n sound

YC, thanks. I've read the links, had seen some before. Interesting about the 37/48dB gap between normal and body sound. But it's still within the range of normal hearing... Which leads to the 'negligible' comments usually made. I measured my tenor at over 110dB. So assuming the 37dB figure applies we're talking body sounds in the 70dB range- easily audbile.

Benade is quoted as saying the tube must be rigid - presumably Benade said this because he knew that if the body tube vibrates, it's goign to emit sounds and affect the vibration of the air column inside the sax....

Maybe it's because the effects are small that not everyone hears them. And maybe the scientists are wrong to dismiss these differences as negligible. But I'm being selective, cos Butkus also had some interesting experiments designed to test whether people could reilably identify differences. And found no evidnece to say they could.

It's not an argument that's going to go away, not for a long time...
But enough.
 
You're right Kev, it's not going to go away. I just thought I might have found an analogy that would help it explain it in part.
Bill - yes the analogy may be even more solid with microwave freqs where waveguides and horns are used. However, remember your electronics - the magnetic field effect recedes with higher frequency and the electrical field predominates more and more. At microwave it's almost all electrical.Space may be curved, but I think it's over a larger distance than the length of a sax.

Davey - my brother is from daan sarf Lunnun like me, but he's lived near Seaham for 30 years and he talks like you too. No idea what he's on about.:w00t:
YC
 
Last edited by a moderator:
yes, and how about solar explosions and sun spots? Inversion of the magnetic field? Different aural (from aura) projection through the hands of different players? Different salinity of the air depending one lives close by the sea or far away?


Or, to stay down to earth, how about good ole traditional acoustics?


Sun-Explosion-8.jpg
 
Ah, I wondered when we'd get the first 'some people cannot hear it' suggestion 🙂

I am rather more of the 'some people hear it because they believe it is there' school of thought ;}

(no offence intended ....the power of the mind is very strong ...placebo effect and all that)
 
Ah, I wondered when we'd get the first 'some people cannot hear it' suggestion 🙂

I am rather more of the 'some people hear it because they believe it is there' school of thought ;}

(no offence intended ....the power of the mind is very strong ...placebo effect and all that)

No offence taken.

You say that, but... On a slightly different, but related topic, my daughter's cello has a high pitched buzz that only she and my wife can hear. Her music teacher, and the head of strings at the music school can't hear it. I can't hear it. But they can... And it's driving them mad. So something needs to be done, but how do you go about fixing something that many people can't hear?

Same with saxes and materials....
 
No offence taken.

You say that, but... On a slightly different, but related topic, my daughter's cello has a high pitched buzz that only she and my wife can hear. Her music teacher, and the head of strings at the music school can't hear it. I can't hear it. But they can... And it's driving them mad. So something needs to be done, but how do you go about fixing something that many people can't hear?

Same with saxes and materials....

A bit of petrol and a match should do it >:)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom