Playing the saxophone Is it me or my saxophone?

Just play the thing. Dancing on the head of a pin and nit picking will drive you mad.

All this micro managing comes to naught when you're playing with other people.

Wondering about your tone while trying to be heard over drums, trumpet and trombone becomes becomes less important while you're finding the notes and feeling the groove.

Find some nice people, who you feel can play better than you and are willing to put up with you. Agree on a few tunes that this group likes and make the best music you can.

If you ever like your sound, give yourself a good talking to and explain to yourself it'll be a one off. 🙂
 
Just play the thing. Dancing on the head of a pin and nit picking will drive you mad.

All this micro managing comes to naught when you're playing with other people.

Wondering about your tone while trying to be heard over drums, trumpet and trombone becomes becomes less important while you're finding the notes and feeling the groove.

Find some nice people, who you feel can play better than you and are willing to put up with you. Agree on a few tunes that this group likes and make the best music you can.

If you ever like your sound, give yourself a good talking to and explain to yourself it'll be a one off. 🙂
I love this. Thank you!
 
When I was "ready" to play with others I started to play with guys that were playing music that I also wanted to play. I knew, still do, what kind of music I wanted to do. I was also ready with my tone/sound. What they heard, they had to accept. I was open for advice and constructive criticism. I didn't have a sax teacher. I save the money and had 4-5 hours playing, with a good band or individual musicians, once or twice/year.

It was fun.
I learned a lot.
Made friends with guys who shared the interest for the same music and RockSax.

One of the best comments about my sound came from a professional RockSax player. He liked the volume, "cut through", timbre .... but also told me to do better when it came to timing, attitude and listen to the other musicians. That's easier to fix instead of learning the right RockSax sound/tone. :confused2:
 
Thank you for all your helpful comments and discussion. Just a quick update. I have gone up to a 2.5 cane reed with my Rico graptonite B5 MP and I have been paying attention to my embouchure in a more mindful way, trying to notice what is happening on each breath.

I noticed that I was taking in air by moving my top teeth from the sax, instead of breathing from the sides of my mouth. I noticed that meant I was clenching my teeth in order to restore my embouchure and not lose the beat. I noticed this changed my mouth on the MP/reed. There was just too much movement - movement of my embouchure, movement of the too-soft reed vibrating too much.

So my sound now feels more stable, not 100% resolved because I now have to get used to a slightly harder reed, but closer to what I am aiming for. I could even go for a slightly harder reed, between a 2.5 and a 3 if such a thing exists. So the Legere Signature 2.5 reed, that I have just ordered should do perfectly. I prefer these reeds, mainly for convenience (and because of the "ick" factor of putting a spittle and lipstick encrusted cane reed in my mouth every day) 😱
 
Last edited:
I noticed that I was taking in air by moving my top teeth from the sax, instead of breathing from the sides of my mouth. I noticed that meant I was clenching my teeth in order to restore my embouchure and not lose the beat. I noticed this changed my mouth on the MP/reed. There was just too much movement - movement of my embouchure, movement of the too-soft reed vibrating too much.
Your teacher didn’t pick this up? I presume it’s a new habit.

The potential to develop bad habits is always present, so stopping your lessons for extended periods is not a good idea until you have a solid foundation.

If you’re working on the right things in the right way then you just have to be patient in the knowledge that everything will improve - including your tone.

We all have vast periods where we loathe our playing, and to keep moving forward we have to switch that part of our critique off and just plough on.

Some days I think my tone has deserted me, though how much it actually changes from day to day must be absolutely tiny - so I ignore myself and concentrate on fingers or something else.

Consider the pain a good thing - without it you might not have the capacity to keep learning and improving. It can be a painful, frustrating process, but maybe only 95% of it. 😉

Keep on keeping on.
 
Good for you. I bought two Metal Links (alto) and one was great, the other one pretty terrible. And it wasn't just me, the guy I sold the great one to had exactly the same experience

But I got a decent HR Tone Edge. And a few duds.
Without wishing to divert too far from tis thread (and I did start a thread a while ago on the subject) but I had dud link after dud link after dud link or glorified blank as you say. Since then I have had good link after good link after good link.
how can this be?
There is something about the way you play that is sometimes described as having 'Link Chops'.
For sure there is a lot of variation in a link, I don't think that can be denied.
 
I noticed that I was taking in air by moving my top teeth from the sax, instead of breathing from the sides of my mouth.
Yes, that sounds like a bad habit. It makes my curious how much time your teacher spend on teaching breathing and which basic breathing techniques you have learned.

Regarding mouthpieces: You have to kiss a lot of frogs before you find something decent. With most brands no two mouthpieces are equal, but some are more equal than others.
 
"Link chops" is simply that the mouthpiece suits your physiognomy and sound concept

They suit neither for me.

I've tried a few. The two I currently own play much better after a light corrective dressing, to level the table and balance the rails. Both bought used and probably sold by a disappointed player.
 
I'm genuinely interest in the "Link Chops" I've heard it said, but playing a link I don't understand what people are referring too...
It's a total myth, although one thing that I found was that in order to get smidgen of sparkle in to an otherwise dull sounding mouthpiece is to put a lot of the beak into your mouth, which makes a truly versatile sound much harder if not impossible. Not quite such an issue with Florida Links, but still there.

BTW:

 
I actually believe in “Link chops”. I disagree with Pete about the amount of mouthpiece to take in, I like my lower lip at or just in front of the break point of the facing. I actually think it’s easier to control there than further toward the tip.

But the trick with Links and similar pieces is air support and blowing through the horn. So maybe “Link chops” is a bad term, it should just be called “good chops”.
 
I disagree with Pete about the amount of mouthpiece to take in, I like my lower lip at or just in front of the break point of the facing. I actually think it’s easier to control there than further toward the tip.
I think you agree in that case in that at the "break point" is further in than I would recommend.
But the trick with Links and similar pieces is air support and blowing through the horn.
That is the trick to playing the saxophone well though. It applies to any mouthpiece.

But I'm happy to agree to disagree and I have been known to be wrong. Well, I was once (but I got divorced).
 
Last edited:
My Link has been fettled by Phil Tone.

I agree @skeller047 it certainly takes more support & air to get a reasonable sound, compared to my previous pieces, more than my V16 6L which is a similar tip opening... Perhaps not as forgiving as other pieces.

Interesting you mentioned break point, I tried taking a little more in and it seemed to give that projection I feel it lacked...

Anyway back to the OP :old:

Would your teacher be a more classical teacher, where I suspect the acceptable sound idea may be more narrow?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom