Playing the saxophone Improvisational Approach

The other day I turned up this exercise method I had bookmarked a while ago and would appreciate Nick's and anyone else's opinion on it.

http://forum.saxontheweb.net/showthread.php?5396-spoon-fed-music-lesson&highlight=scales

I regret my ear is hopeless at finding the notes played on a recording, I can hum or whistle the tune but am unable to find the note or interval and that is most frustrating. I guess it's the age old answer practice, practice and more practice.

To the link you posted: Personally I hate the angle that guy is coming from. There is nothing incorrect about the information in his post and if you followed it you would learn all major, minor, diminished, whole tone, and modes. - So what don't I like about that then?

Personally, I hate learning these things from the maths and in a highly structured way. I say this because scales are boring to play and when you're bored you don't learn as well and playing the sax is about having fun.

I prefer to learn scales by playing them with articulation, rhythm and dynamic, albeit to a metronome to make sure I'm playing them evenly. - just make them sound as musical as you can.

It's also extremely important to play them with your best tone possible! This is something I never used to do, didn't even think about, for me I saw them as a means to get the notes under the fingers, they're more than that.

Play patterns with the scales e.g 1 3 5 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
or 1 3 2 4 3 5 etc.

I think it's better to start with the majors and minors, not the whole tone and diminished too. You encounter them in music a lot more and recognising the patterns and theory in music is half the battle to learning them.

-------------------------
As regards your aural skills. I was exactly the same. I can sing along to tunes, solos, my piano playing. But actually finding what note was being played/sung etc. I found really quite hard and consciously working out the interval was tough too.

I've improved what I feel is a lot, but I'm no where near as good as I'd like to be.

What I've been doing is:

  • More singing
    Singing harmonies to myself playing chords on piano
    Transposing short riffs/licks/II-V-Is to different keys by ear
    Transcribing easy tunes
    Memorising simple tunes and their key intervals

It takes a lot of discipline to focus in on the notes, their relationships and the harmony. Closing my eyes really helps.
It's just a matter of more practice now.
 
The other day I turned up this exercise method I had bookmarked a while ago and would appreciate Nick's and anyone else's opinion on it.

http://forum.saxontheweb.net/showthread.php?5396-spoon-fed-music-lesson&highlight=scales

I regret my ear is hopeless at finding the notes played on a recording, I can hum or whistle the tune but am unable to find the note or interval and that is most frustrating. I guess it's the age old answer practice, practice and more practice.

To the link you posted: Personally I hate the angle that guy is coming from. There is nothing incorrect about the information in his post and if you followed it you would learn all major, minor, diminished, whole tone, and modes. - So what don't I like about that then?

Personally, I hate learning these things from the maths and in a highly structured way. I say this because scales are boring to play and when you're bored you don't learn as well and playing the sax is about having fun.

I prefer to learn scales by playing them with articulation, rhythm and dynamic, albeit to a metronome to make sure I'm playing them evenly. - just make them sound as musical as you can.

It's also extremely important to play them with your best tone possible! This is something I never used to do, didn't even think about, for me I saw them as a means to get the notes under the fingers, they're more than that.

Play patterns with the scales e.g 1 3 5 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
or 1 3 2 4 3 5 etc.

I think it's better to start with the majors and minors, not the whole tone and diminished too. You encounter them in music a lot more and recognising the patterns and theory in music is half the battle to learning them.

-------------------------
As regards your aural skills. I was exactly the same. I can sing along to tunes, solos, my piano playing. But actually finding what note was being played/sung etc. I found really quite hard and consciously working out the interval was tough too.

I've improved what I feel is a lot, but I'm no where near as good as I'd like to be.

What I've been doing is:

  • More singing
    Singing harmonies to myself playing chords on piano
    Transposing short riffs/licks/II-V-Is to different keys by ear
    Transcribing easy tunes
    Memorising simple tunes and their key intervals

It takes a lot of discipline to focus in on the notes, their relationships and the harmony. Closing my eyes really helps.
It's just a matter of more practice now.

Nice one, Linky Lee, I agree completely.
The 'Spoon-feeder' teaches music in a way that only makes sense if you're a genius scientist who's never heard any music before! It's all correct, but your average mortal isn't going to be able to learn like that.

The only thing I'd add to your list is the following exercise:

Get a backing track to a standard like 'All the Things You Are', which shifts key-centre a lot, and practice hitting tonics, thirds, fifths and sevenths, then playing arpeggios, along to the track.
Write them out if you need to. In fact write them out even if you don't.
Then write patterns up and down the range of the sax using the arpeggios on the chords and learn to play this with the track. I always had a reasonably good ear, but this is what taught me to 'hear' the changes.

Example (look away now):

Four bars, chords Gmaj7, Am7, D7, G6:
Bar one - Gmaj7:
Start at low B, then ascend in quavers(8ths) - B/D/F#/G/B/D/F#G
Bar two - chord changes to Am7:
We're up to G on top of the stave, keep ascending - /A/C/E(**we're now as high as we can reasonably play on the sax, so turn around and descend now**)\C\A\G\E\C
Bar three - chord changes to D7:
We're now at C in the middle of the stave, keep descending - \A\F#\D\C(**turn around and ascend again**)/D/F#/A/C
Bar four - chord changes to G6:
We're now back to C in the stave, keep ascending - /D/E/G/B/D/E(**now descend again**)\D\B

...keep going for the whole chorus, or better still a couple of choruses. You'll soon see how 3rds and 7ths lead onto each other (as well as other chord tones) over the chord changes (and therefore on the strong beats of the bar). Practicing this will mean that you start to hear it too. You start to spot it in the tunes too!

Good luck with it all...

Nick
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom