Saxophones Forestone unlacquered tenor saxophone

Forest-tone. This is a frequently asked question:

FORESTONE Saxophone | FAQ
I have often asked "how do you pronounce Forestone"? Indeed, we used to ponder on this very subject for hours of a Friday evening in my local pub!! Just joking!!! The reeds are great but I am not sure about the hype behind the saxophone. I have had no experience so I am just typing my thoughts. Have you tried them?

It is good to have new horn manufacturers come into the market. Let's hope they are as good as the documentation states.
 
Last edited:
I played some of these horns last year. I was in the market for a new tenor. I also tried the alto at some length and was considering buying both, partly because at last year's prices I could have paid for them pretty much with the insurance money from my damaged Selmer S3 tenor.

They were good horns for the price at the time, but if memory serves, they seem to have gone up a bit in the last 12 months. After a day's rehearsal with the alto I liked the tuning and response but felt thoroughly un-engaged by the instrument, bored by it in fact, and gladly went back to my Selmer alto. Actually I think I would definitely rather play a Yani or a Yamaha before a Forestone, and price-wise they are closer than they used to be.

There was also a mechanical issue with the alto; the bottom C# to B linkage was not set up correctly - when I slid from C# to B my little finger got trapped in between the two keys (ouch!). Evidently this issue has now been resolved, but it made me a little cynical about the set-up hype.

Concerning the cryo-treatment, I heard the interesting statement that Selmer had actually tried it, but rejected the idea since it made every treated horn sound exactly the same! One difference between Europe and Asia in a nutshell.

As an intermediate horn, they are excellent: as a professional one, there are better choices even in a similar price bracket. IMO.
 
"Cryogenic treatment puts the brass through a deep stress cycle, which relieves residual stress from manufacturing at the crystalline level and makes the body more resonant."

I too was intrigued by this description and asked my son, who is an experienced academic and industrial metallurgist, what he thought it meant. This his reply:

I can't imagine how stress relief can be enhanced at lower temperatures and "crystalline level" sounds like nonsense to me and immediately makes me sceptical.
I can't find anything online that rationalises the process. Rather, I kept coming across properly researched studies that show it to be bo---cks.

This isn't any reflection on the quality of the instrument, which of course has been admired by several players, and that's what really matters. However, regarding the sales literature, is it:
a) a description of an new process previously unknown in the metals field;
b) a mis-translation of a description of a process which is well-known;
c) over-enthusiastic description by a marketing person of a process that he/she doesn't really understand.
d) some other reason which I'm not cynical enough to think of!
 
@Jeanette or other admins: Would it be possible to split off posts #24, 26, 29, 30 & 31 to a new thread called something like "Selmer Serie III altos & their intonation tendencies" ?

They are Off Topic really for a thread entitled Forestone Unlacquered Tenor Saxophone.

Thanks

Rhys
 
@Jeanette or other admins: Would it be possible to split off posts #24, 26, 29, 30 & 31 to a new thread called something like "Selmer Serie III altos & their intonation tendencies" ?

They are Off Topic really for a thread entitled Forestone Unlacquered Tenor Saxophone.

Thanks

Rhys

Done:

NB: Anyone who posted those will need to resubscribe (aka "watch") to the new thread to get alerts
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom