Playing the saxophone Do offset tone holes and ergonomics improve your speed?

Woodpad

Senior Member
Messages
1,637
Location
Roosendaal
Most saxophones are made with offset tone holes on the main stack. It was introduced on the SBA with some other changes as a means to play faster.
For fast action in your hands it is advised to keep your fingers and wrist in an arched shape to make it easy for the tendons and muscles to move fast.
When playing you can see the muscles move in you lower arm.
Now I am a bit puzzled how this works on an alto. When I play with offset tone holes my right arm arm is closer to the body and my hand and wrist lose the arch shape. So this should affect the ergonomics in a negative way. Another ergonomic effect of offset tone holes is that you have more wriggle room for your fingers, but this will not make them wriggle faster.

Does anyone know how offset tone holes improve finger speed?
 
Solution
There are many of us who don't think anything WAS wrong with the old layout (Conn, Martin, Buescher up to the 400, and King up to about halfway through the Super 20 run).

The THEORY (and the French are great ones for doing things according to theory) is that because all your other LH fingers close the keys by clamping in (like squeezing a ball), the little finger should do the same. Unfortunately designing the LH keywork according to this theory leads to some issues.

For one thing, Sax assigned to the LH little finger some of the heaviest work on the horn. We can argue that it should be a stronger more flexible finger that does those bell keys (like, say, the right thumb), but that decision's made. In the original Sax design...
At the moment we see that there are people who can live with in line and offset keys and there are people who prefere in line above offset because of ergonomical issues, No people with ergonomical issues came forward that prefered offset above inline

The fact that it is one sided means that offset is worse, but most people have no issue with this, so it is only slightly worse.

The change from in line to offset favors people with large hands. As long as there are more saxophone players with large hands than players with ergonomical issues it is commercial viable to do this.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
At the moment we see that there are people who can live with in line and offset keys and there are people who prefere in line above offset because of ergonomical issues, No people with ergonomical issues came forward that prefered offset above inline

The fact that it is one sided means that offset is worse, but most people have no issue with this, so it is only slightly worse.

The change from in line to offset favors people with large hands. As long as there are more saxophone players with large hands than players with ergonomical issues it is commercial viable to do this.
I have large hands but like my Martin Alto since it doesn’t have the tilting Bb spatula, and the action is low and fast.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,251
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom