Playing the saxophone Do offset tone holes and ergonomics improve your speed?

Woodpad

Senior Member
Messages
1,637
Location
Roosendaal
Most saxophones are made with offset tone holes on the main stack. It was introduced on the SBA with some other changes as a means to play faster.
For fast action in your hands it is advised to keep your fingers and wrist in an arched shape to make it easy for the tendons and muscles to move fast.
When playing you can see the muscles move in you lower arm.
Now I am a bit puzzled how this works on an alto. When I play with offset tone holes my right arm arm is closer to the body and my hand and wrist lose the arch shape. So this should affect the ergonomics in a negative way. Another ergonomic effect of offset tone holes is that you have more wriggle room for your fingers, but this will not make them wriggle faster.

Does anyone know how offset tone holes improve finger speed?
 
Solution
There are many of us who don't think anything WAS wrong with the old layout (Conn, Martin, Buescher up to the 400, and King up to about halfway through the Super 20 run).

The THEORY (and the French are great ones for doing things according to theory) is that because all your other LH fingers close the keys by clamping in (like squeezing a ball), the little finger should do the same. Unfortunately designing the LH keywork according to this theory leads to some issues.

For one thing, Sax assigned to the LH little finger some of the heaviest work on the horn. We can argue that it should be a stronger more flexible finger that does those bell keys (like, say, the right thumb), but that decision's made. In the original Sax design...
I see a marketing opportunity here but, as with the MkVI, I fear the countless offset owners would poo-poo something better as a retrograde step.
Let's have inline and of course left hand bell keys too, much easier.
Not sure Selmer would ever concede though?
If I could ever get involved in a retro-modern sax design/endeavor, I'd bring back opposite-side bell keys.

Not joking,
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
If I could ever get involved in a retro-modern sax design/endeavor, I'd bring back opposite-side bell keys.

Not joking,
Wel, lets look at engineering details of the opposite side bell keys construction.

The C# looks like the the design of the 6M. The B and Bb key share a long rod and the Bb keys action is brought to the other side with a construction comparable to the C# of the Mk6.

The long rod is a small risk but can be replaced by separating the B and Bb key. now two out of three keys have a direct action, just as with the Mk6. While the 6M has a direct action on all three left pinkie keys.

In leverage length the double sided constructgion is a bit worse when combined with a Eb thrill key on the left side of the body. This shifts the post for the C# axis to a position with a smaller leverage length making the C# hard to press.

So if you ditch the long rod and the Eb thrill the left pinky set up of a double sided bell construction can be as good as that of the Mk6.

Still you have to give a good explanation why you want this construction. Is it because its a looker?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The biggest issue for me on left side bell keys is not the pinky table layout, but the leverage difficulty with low C#. Moving that key to the right side and using a linkage as on Selmer saxophones solves that. Which side low B and Bb are on is then irrelevant - to me at least.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The linkages involved in split-bell keys were pretty good back in the 20's-30's, I actually think, like the offset stack keys argument....it was a marketing thing disguised as 'ergonomic improvement' when there was in fact no 'problem' that needed addressing to be solved.

Good splitbell models...Conn NW, Buescher TT for example...when dialed in nicely in the keywork adjustments, are as fluid and responsive as any good same-side-bellkey models are, IMHO.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The biggest issue for me on left side bell keys is not the pinky table layout, but the leverage difficulty with low C#. Moving that key to the right side and using a linkage as on Selmer saxophones solves that. Which side low B and Bb are on is then irrelevant - to me at least.
The action of the low C# on the Conn baritone is pretty good; it uses a linkage. The Buescher 400s also had a linkage, but I've not tried one of those. I think, but am not sure, that the King Zephyr baritones also used a linkage for low C#.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The action of the low C# on the Conn baritone is pretty good; it uses a linkage. The Buescher 400s also had a linkage, but I've not tried one of those. I think, but am not sure, that the King Zephyr baritones also used a linkage for low C#.
My very strong memory of the Holton alto I had as a teenager, and the Vito/Beaugnier model 37 alto I have now, reinforce my thoughts on this. I played a Buescher tenor as a teen also, and don’t remember any issues. And a Conn bari briefly in college (it wasn’t mine), no issues there. Or rather, most of the issues were things other than low C#…

I suspect that alto may be the worst offender in this story. Because of the overall larger size, tenor would have more leverage advantage. Even a couple of mm longer on my Vito low C# key touch arm would be a significant help.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The action of the low C# on the Conn baritone is pretty good; it uses a linkage. The Buescher 400s also had a linkage, but I've not tried one of those. I think, but am not sure, that the King Zephyr baritones also used a linkage for low C#.
Correct, a linkage same place as the Conn.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The linkages involved in split-bell keys were pretty good back in the 20's-30's, I actually think, like the offset stack keys argument....it was a marketing thing disguised as 'ergonomic improvement' when there was in fact no 'problem' that needed addressing to be solved.

Good splitbell models...Conn NW, Buescher TT for example...when dialed in nicely in the keywork adjustments, are as fluid and responsive as any good same-side-bellkey models are, IMHO.

Interestingly, my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito bari has in-line holes on the front with bell pads on the opposite side. Ergonomically it is comfortable and the bell keywork is easy to press, don't notice any awkwardness. It is a very easy to play bari.

Also my Antigua Winds BS3220LQ bari that I bought new a couple years ago has in-line pad holes cut. It also plays comfortably.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Interestingly, my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito bari has in-line holes on the front with bell pads on the opposite side. Ergonomically it is comfortable and the bell keywork is easy to press, don't notice any awkwardness. It is a very easy to play bari.

Also my Antigua Winds BS3220LQ bari that I bought new a couple years ago has in-line pad holes cut. It also plays comfortably.
Wow that's news, I figured by now in-line was not produced by any major mfr. I wonder if it's different on baritones, IOW the tendency was to stay in-line ? (I gotta admit I have not played a Baritone newer than around 1990 models).
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
All stories I have read on offset toneholes are on alto and tenor saxophones. The only in line model I found in this categorie is the vibratosax. Checking the Selmer iii straight soprano from pictures it is visible that it is in line. For the bari it is difficult to see so I will visit someone with a recent bari to check.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Wow that's news, I figured by now in-line was not produced by any major mfr. I wonder if it's different on baritones, IOW the tendency was to stay in-line ? (I gotta admit I have not played a Baritone newer than around 1990 models).

Here's a factory photo of the Antigua Winds:
BS3220.webp


This model is from around 2014. Interestingly, it seems Antigua Winds brand has disappeared as I no longer see new listings on the 'net. Yet, they are decent horns, built stout.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
So, would we prefer in-line or offset in future?

Could we add a poll to the thread? @Woodpad @Pete Thomas
A straght poll on preference wouldn't give much information. You have to seperate between people who used both systems and people who used one system. Also you have to distinguish between people with and without ergonomical issues. I am open to good ideas how to phrase such a poll..
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
A straght poll on preference wouldn't give much information. You have to seperate between people who used both systems and people who used one system. Also you have to distinguish between people with and without ergonomical issues. I am open to good ideas how to phrase such a poll..
It could really only be answered by people who have played both and had a reasonable time to evaluate. Someone who has only ever played offset for years will no doubt find straight a bit odd at first. It could take quite a long time to get used to the difference to the point where a fair evaluation is possible.

As someone who plays both, all I can say is I have no real preference
Could we add a poll to the thread?
It's not possible to add a poll to a question-type thread as the point of using a question-type thread is to look for the one definitive answer. It would need to be a new thread.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Everyone's hands and length of fingers are different. Also strength differs. Among a multitude of other reasons, I think most if given a choice select a sax on comfort of feel when playing, like when trying a couple models in a music store. So, exacting location of tone holes has little to do with the process.

Other factors, such as ease on fully closing or opening pads, the spring tensions, etc. may come into play.

For me, I'm not too picky and have made use of whatever I've had, within reason.

Perhaps it should be called the art of selection rather than the science of selection.

A poll IMO (or in this case a straw poll) would most likely not be useful, as successful sax models to include the vintage are still being played today on both sides of the spectrum, and those who play love them not because of straight holes versus ergonomically located, but rather they perform.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,251
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom