Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

Maybe I got all wrong? I wrote down the mixed F# blues and mixolydian scale on a Rock Sax workshop:
F#, G#, A, A#,B, C, C#,E (bold from the F# blues scale). And of course all the other tones that are not in blues or mixolydian scales. A trill F# to G sounds great as well. WE also learned some tricks who to get a good flow on the sax. Avoid the flip fingers ...... .
No I can see how they are smashed together. Odd scale. Strikes me as being very jazzy for a rock sound.
 
Keys were added over time, just like the clarinet and other instruments.

I don’t know why fingerings need to be contentious at all if the player makes them work and is happy.
Absolutely agree :thumb: any 'contention' is typical internet forum bickering type stuff unfortunately.
 
Was it the 5 minute argument or the full half hour ?

Screenshot 2025-08-18 17.26.01.webp
 
As far as I'm concerned the side Bb is a vestigial holdover from the original Sax design, that at present has utility mostly as a trill key. It forces you to move your hand out of position and to use large muscles instead of small muscles.
 
Was there a bis key then?
No. The original Sax design had no bis key, no connection of upper and lower stacks thus no 1 and 1 fingering, no forked F#, no forked C. C, F#, Bb were only fingered by side keys. No alternative fingerings. Double octave keys, too. And only keyed to low Bb. No front F either. Because Sax came from simple system clarinets, the typical woodwind key was a sharping key (put one more finger down, then depress the key to go up a half step).

But things have advanced since then. Nowadays (since, say, 1920) we have the bis and 1 and 1 Bb fingerings, we have the fork F#, we have the standard middle finger LH C, we have automatic octave vents.

I don't know how the side Bb got enshrined as "the one true way" to play Bb, but in my opinion it's the worst of the three common fingerings.
 
Since people are thinking about this kind of thing ... What would your preference for this triplet run be? - 120 BPM, F - so Bb...

View attachment 30000

I settled on Bis for the top Bb and side Bb for the middle...
bis key all the way, for me on that passage. Side Bb would work for the 2nd Bb, but no need to 'change horses in the middle of the stream' (or however the saying goes). In a situation like this, I find it easiest and most intuitive to stick with the bis fingering, unless there was a very good reason not to.
Funny how some people consider a conversation to be “contentious” or “bickering”.
+1. I see nothing whatsoever contentious about pointing out how & why I'd use a certain fingering. That doesn't mean I'm requiring anyone else to use it. And I've taken part in this same discussion over on SOTW. Nothing contentious or bickering at all over there on this topic; just a discussion where anyone is able to state their preference and agree or disagree as they please.
It's a good discussion but as far as I can tell has nothing to do with a mouthpiece so maybe I should change the titie?
Yeah Pete, I noticed we had somehow strayed way off the original topic (what was it? Guess I'll check the title & OP)*. Couldn't help but chime in on the bis key topic, though.

*p.s. Just checked and "long Bb" is in the thread title, so reference to that fingering got us off on Bb fingerings, forgetting about the mpc. I'm not really sure what the mpc has to do with it anyway.
 
Certainly the side Bb key has very much the impression and design of a ( sometimes wobbly! ) trill key, no doubt one of the reasons my old advisers suggested using the long Bb's on the main action of the instrument instead, plus of course the useful fingering options they provide.
Just to throw another curved ball into the mix.. how about the old forked Eb, often disconnected on old instruments and not provided on anything modern ( far as I know)
Now (again IMHO )this is an excellent option, which I was using only today on a 12M which has a proper tone hole for it ,rather than the little one round the back like a Beuscher TT or whatever.
 
*p.s. Just checked and "long Bb" is in the thread title, so reference to that fingering got us off on Bb fingerings, forgetting about the mpc. I'm not really sure what the mpc has to do with it anyway.
As the OP, with the 5C, L1R1 was fine but L1R2 was flat, with Soloist it is the other way around. I wondered if the different mpc dimensions might have an effect.

I am still trying to find the sweet spot for the mpc. I'm sound a bit flat overall but pushing on further leaves about 4mm of cork. I'm sure it is a case of user error.

Re 'best' Bb I repeat what I said originally
... argue amongst yourselves...
:rofl:
For me, bis > long > side

As Pete and others mentioned it may be a leak but I don't have other issues unless overall flatness is an indication?
 
@Pete Effamy I used a tuner a couple of days ago and I'd say when it went flat it was about 25-30%, other times I was within 10-15% and got several green smilies :rolleyes: I could get Bb1 and Bb2 in tune by adjusting the mpc.

Not a big jump from 0.071-0.085 but I think I just need to get used to the new mpc.
 
As the OP, with the 5C, L1R1 was fine but L1R2 was flat, with Soloist it is the other way around. I wondered if the different mpc dimensions might have an effect.
Ok, now I get how it ties in with the mpc. My answer to this would be to choose the mpc you like best and use bis Bb. In the rare, if not non-existent, occasion you'd use that 'long' Bb, choose the fingering (RH 1 or 2) that is not flat. Since I never use 1+1 (or 1+2) aside from a trill, it wouldn't be an issue for me.

As to pushing the mpc further on the cork, that's been answered above. Just push the mpc to where it's in tune. It doesn't matter how much cork is showing.
 
Bis is the flute equivalent of thumb Bb. The clarinet doesn’t have an equivalent on any note, unless you have a model with an articulated C# / G# (I think - been out of the clarinet world for decades).
True.

One thing that hasn't been discussed (unless I missed something) regards choices of doublers. I started on clarinet and yes, for the left hand the choices are slightly different than for sax. Thus, what others may consider as being less preferrable I find work for me.

Besides, as long as we both are able to achieve the same result musically up to tempo without undo hardship or degrading our performance, then it boils down to preferences.

Regarding drawing lines in the sand over Bb fingering choices, I hope we do not eliminate posters like in The Weakest Link TV game show. 😉

Is it time to add a poll?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,318
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom