I've never come across any foot tapping classical music. Even the so called dances.
Nobody sits still when The Canal St. Stompers are playing. 💃🕺👯
Nobody sits still when The Canal St. Stompers are playing. 💃🕺👯
True but performance is also visual. So how you move, what you look like and behave on stage can all be relevant and important.Music is aural. Why should anyone care if you move?
Sounds great. Using my awesome powers of deduction, I can tell exactly what time you made this recording - Cold Duck Time.Had a 40 minute gig at a local fete today and it went well.
It was bit windy, quite sunny and warm and despite the grey clouds it didn't rain.
Lots of families milling around and probably about 50+ sitting on the grass listening with a few young kids bopping away which was sweet. Got applause after each tune and a big round at the end, the fete's MC roused them on.
I'm slightly embarrassed but here's a short clip; I'm the tenor at the back.
I must stop bobbing about though!
View: https://youtu.be/VpPvuLn46QE
No issues, Pete, but that presumes the music is solid. If the visuals are bad, I can at least close my eyes and listen. If the music is a fail, I don't care how well you dress and move.True but performance is also visual. So how you move, what you look like and behave on stage can all be relevant and important.
Sounds like you had fun!Had a 40 minute gig at a local fete today and it went well. [...] I'm slightly embarrassed but here's a short clip; I'm the tenor at the back. I must stop bobbing about though!
Or - heaven forbid - you'll enjoy it even more and be more free to bob as you feel like it. Oh no, the back line is bobbing in time!Sounds like you had fun!The type of music you're playing, IMO in an informal environment playing pop music, some bobbing is acceptable, appears you are getting into the music. Unless your bandleader mentions otherwise, focus on the music, intonation, etc. As you get more comfortable, I think your "bobbing" will settle down. 😉
I've had back herniations before, recovered without surgery except for the last episode, 3 years ago, which I had major back surgery. So, I know what you are referring to, @MikeMorrell . I am very familiar with the healing you went through until it resolved itself. Speaking of "lumbago", I found this interesting jazz song with a sax solo in it called, Lumbago:Two months ago, I had a back injury (lumbago). ... I decided to attend my 'Blues/Rock' band's rehearsal at the end of the 2nd week, ... I took my sax ... I could play ... (with some back support while 'sitting out'.) ... 3rd week, I decided to re-join my 'jazz improvisation workshop' on Monday and - if that went well - my Big Band rehearsal on Wednesday. My back ... would quickly stiffen up if I sat for more than 15-30 minutes (even with 'back support'). So for a couple of weeks I stood ... while all other sax (and other players) were seated.
I really enjoyed standing and 'bobbing about'. 'Movement' initially helped my back from stiffening up but I quickly enjoyed 'movement' just for its musical advantages. I found that it was a much better 'playing experience' when my whole (moving) body dynamically responded to the music than in a 'static' standing/sitting position.
So my humble advice is that you just let yourself go (without any 'internal constraints'), including 'bobbing about'. ... Having a few players 'bobbing about' adds IMHO to the audience perception of 'enthusiasm' and 'authenticity' were seated
As posted on another thread, these guys did synchronised bobbing, love the foot-workOr - heaven forbid - you'll enjoy it even more and be more free to bob as you feel like it. Oh no, the back line is bobbing in time!
Hi @cappers, thanks for this! Yes, it makes sense. Unless (IMHO) 'staying deliberately still' - while parts of your body really just want to move naturally - creates more tension than 'keeping still' is worth. I'll leave it to my betters to comment on this.Firstly I hope your back improves soon. I suffered from sciatica for years because of a twisted vertebra resulting from a herniated disc. I had an intensive course of physiotherapy a couple of years ago because I was getting numbness in my nether region (!) and was scanned for cauda equina syndrome Cauda equina syndrome. Fortunately it wasn't that and the improvement has been remarkable. Still get tweaks if I overdo it though.
Back to 'bobbing', I found a pdf of Universal Method for the Saxophone by Paul de Ville and he states:
View attachment 29435
Larry Teal also states:
1. Stand or sit erect, but relaxed.
2. Keep both feet flat on the floor
etc.
I'm just a bobber! The other tenor player stands stock still and I think he doesn't like my swaying to the music, but I don't feel, no disrespect, any emotion or passion even though he is technically a good player.
Hilarious!!It you bob people will know you are a beginner. There are, secret, advanced techniques...
View: https://youtu.be/5twANQ7S050

Reality is often even more daft than Monty P ! 😉The above clips are like a Monty Python sketch![]()
That breaks the "rule" for the classical traditionalist - "No foot movement whilst playing!" 😉...and I'll raise you, baritone on unicycle...
View: https://youtu.be/e4yuxAVZdUI?si=RkVXex_lRWAehP6R
That’s a BASS....and I'll raise you, baritone on unicycle...
View: https://youtu.be/e4yuxAVZdUI?si=RkVXex_lRWAehP6R
