Mouthpieces Chinese metal mouthpieces

Thanks Paul, my only reservation is that the gold plating is already dissappearing and what is underneath does not look like brass. I remember in a previous thread somewhere it was mentioned that it was suspected that they are made of an alloy containing lead!

I dont know if someone can verify if this rumour is true or not. at present because I am very happy with the performance I am tempted just to have it replated (nice and thick!) which may also be an opportunity to have it hand refaced as a tweak.
 
I remember in a previous thread somewhere it was mentioned that it was suspected that they are made of an alloy containing lead!

Are you sure about this? It's the sort of rumour which often gets spread about on a certain US web site, in my view more due to prejudice than any basis in fact. Why on earth would anyone make a mouthpiece out of an alloy containing lead? Lead is both soft and expensive. This sort of rumour can ruin a perfectly good business, whether based in fact or not.

Just imagine if, instead of talking about some obscure and new to market Chinese manufacturer, you referred to a Babbitt product (Babbitt are makers of Otto Link and others). Claiming, unfounded, that there is lead in their products would lead to immediate legal action from them.

I can't absolutely rule out this rumour (and I have no personal interest in ruling it in or out) but I'd like to suggest that it's not really a good idea to spread business-threatening rumour without a basis in fact.

Jon
 
Jon

I agree, the lead stories seem to be rumours from a certain US site, turning into 'fact'.

But do you remember the melamine powder in milk problem a year or two ago? And there was the problem of lead in paint on kids toys not so long ago as well.

Although there are some good things coming out of China, they have some unscrupulous businessmen - and if led is cheap and makes it easier to machine.....

Up until recently, most of the mixer taps with the ceramic cartridges had quite a bit of lead in them because it made the handle move more smoothly. First cup or two of water from those after they've been turned off for a while has so much lead in it you can taste it. We always run a few litres of water before using the taps for drinking water.

I was also donig some research into b=what goes into brass, apart from the usual copper & zinc. Came up with the fact that lead was also often added in the past. Looked as if it was to make it move easier, and seemed to be popular in brass fo cartidge cases. New what famous sax was supposed to have been made from melted down cartridge cases after WWII, and part way though production they changed the brass source? Could it be that the web lore that says that the earlier versions sound better because of the better metal, is in fact true because of the lead that was in the brass? I'm merely speculating, but I've never seen an analysis of the metal in those saxes. And would it matter?

So it's not such a ridiculous idea after all.

Would be really interesting for someone to take a sample from a chinese mouthpiece and get it analysed. And from one of those old pot-war brass saxes...
 
I was bought up in an area where all the internal water pipes were lead.

What do you mean, that explains everything?

Me too - and no-one thought anything about it. I loved the taste of the leaded water staight from the tap, it lost a lot once the tap had been running for a while. Neve realised that it was the lead dissolving into the water.

The Romans used lead water pipes - does it explain their problems as well? - Nero for instance.
 
Hi Kev

I'm not sure I'm with you on this. I've always regarded the tale about saxes being made out of cartridge cases as being an urban myth, just a modern version of 'beating swords into ploughshares' legend. I just don't think it'svery likely that lead would be alloyed into Chinese mouthpieces, it just feels too much like an internet-driven scare story. Until someone produces some real evidence I'd remain very sceptical.

True, there have been incidences of contamination of the supply chain in China, which are serious and tragic. But it's also happened in other countries too, and in a massive economy like China I don't think we can assume all products are contaminated because some have been. It would be a bit like assuming that all US corporations are negligent in their manufacturing just because Union Carbide was shown to have been.

Jon
 
Jon, all I'm saying is that we shouldn't just dismiss it as internet myths - there may be some truth in it. So I think of it as being unlikely, unproven, but not to be dismissed.

And as I think a bit more, there's the issue of whether it matters if there's a bit of lead there or not.... Pewter used to contain a lot of lead.... And plumbers (amongst others) have worked with open, molten lead for years without effects. And professional drivers were exposed to lead over long periods before lead was removed from petrol. I remember as a kid watching some workmen repairing an underground cable in front of our house. After sealing the lot in pitch, they cut a sheet of lead to size, wraped and hammered it around the join, then poured molten lead over the lot to seal the seams. First time I'd seen liquid metal, I was fascinated.

But it would be wrong of me to play down the dangers. But I sometimes wonder if we get into the realms of over-protectionism.
 
Everything, with the sole exception of cucumber sandwiches, is poisonous to homo sapiens if consumed in sufficient quantity, even oxygen. Not referring to the LP/CD, just try breathing it using re-breathing gear at a depth of three atmospheres. Funeral will only be necessary if you are recovered.

Very wise words in a song, "If whisky don't kill me, I'll live till I die."
 
.

Very wise words in a song, "If whisky don't kill me, I'll live till I die."

Or as Joe Jackson said, "Everything gives you cancer"

Hey Kev, I agree with what you say and like your phrase "unlikely, unproven but not to be dismissed". I just get concerned that lots of users of t'internet don't have your rational analysis. They read something and assume it's true, and then it spreads in a viral form until it's become some sort of received wisdom. Internet fallacies are the urban myths of the 21st century. The only difference is they spread so much faster.
 
Pete, thanks for posting the link. I read the first 8 pages of the thread and gave up. Too much opinionated speculation and unwillingness to listen to proper argument.

However I'd recommend that anyone concerned read the first post in the thread, and at least pages 4-6, paying attention to posts by Canadiain.

My verdict based on what I read so far is "Low risk, don't waste any time getting hung up about it."
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom