Saxophones Can we talk about GAS?

As far as the Yamaha 25's go, I bought tenor and alto used. Both needed a tweak, clean, a couple of pads and a bit of cork. They play great. They do everything I need to do and they're easy to regulate.

As far as a used pro horn goes, there's a refurbished Yani in Curly Woodwind at a very reasonable £2k asking price.

If my car didn't need tyres and a timing belt and the front door wasn't falling to bits it'd be here with me 🤗
Get trimmy to deliver it in his van, it was the transport not the money that's the problem?
 
I have a further view: the more progress you make, the more likely your choice of “perfect horn” might change.
Hmmm I'm quite boring though. As long as the sax suits my needs is unlikely I would look elsewhere. I don't want a flashy expensive sax, just a good reliable instrument that I can build a good relationship with (like my husband) 😍
 
Hmmm I'm quite boring though. As long as the sax suits my needs is unlikely I would look elsewhere. I don't want a flashy expensive sax, just a good reliable instrument that I can build a good relationship with (like my husband) 😍
A new sax can be a "booster". Maybe the boring scales-, embouchure-, intonation exercises can be more joyful with a new sax. We all need some changes?
 
A Trevor James student level horn to a Yamaha student level horn is more of a change rather than an upgrade. I had my Trevor James The Horn alto for over 20 years and it was perfectly serviceable throughout that time. I’d say if you’re going to switch to go for a pro level horn, but try before you buy.
 
I have a further view: the more progress you make, the more likely your choice of “perfect horn” might change.
Certainly possible, it hasn't happened with me but doesn't mean it wouldn't happen to anyone. And tbh I was very disappointed with the Selmer Signature and Supremes I tried (especially for the price). May have been the notorious poor setup from Selmer of course.
 
A Trevor James student level horn to a Yamaha student level horn is more of a change rather than an upgrade. I had my Trevor James The Horn alto for over 20 years and it was perfectly serviceable throughout that time. I’d say if you’re going to switch to go for a pro level horn, but try before you buy.
Yes I can see it would just be a lateral change for novelty value, then I would have two saxes I don't want!
 
Hmmm I'm quite boring though. As long as the sax suits my needs is unlikely I would look elsewhere. I don't want a flashy expensive sax, just a good reliable instrument that I can build a good relationship with (like my husband) 😍
You misunderstand, it would be about how you put air into the instrument and probably about have a more open embouchure / sound. In turn, everything will vibrate more freely and the difference between saxes might be more evident.
 
Certainly possible, it hasn't happened with me but doesn't mean it wouldn't happen to anyone. And tbh I was very disappointed with the Selmer Signature and Supremes I tried (especially for the price). May have been the notorious poor setup from Selmer of course.
But you have enough colour in your sound to get something a bit different from a Martin to a Mk6 to a Yam Custom?
 
You misunderstand, it would be about how you put air into the instrument and probably about have a more open embouchure / sound. In turn, everything will vibrate more freely and the difference between saxes might be more evident.
I get you. In that case my resolve to change to a different sax for right now still seems valid.
 
But you have enough colour in your sound to get something a bit different from a Martin to a Mk6 to a Yam Custom?
I started on Jupiter 500 in 2012, then tried the Jericho passaround. Not much difference. Then a Buffet 400, bit better, not much as a beginner. Yamaha 62 PL next which I had lessons with for a good while. All this in my first year or so.
Got addicted to GAS and all sorts passed through but the 62 was unbeaten.
But then, after maybe 2/3 years the first SA80II was spotted cheap. Full Carrington overhaul and this one really stood out and made me smile due to it's prowess above anything else I'd tried. Far better than a 62, for me.
As an everlasting beginner I agree with you Pete that a good horn can make a difference as you progress. It can also encourage you when you start realising what you can do with a great pro horn which you couldn't before. I dare say you would sound geat on either a 62 or 80II but perhaps there can be more differential in a beginner's hands? That was my experience.
 
As an everlasting beginner I agree with you Pete that a good horn can make a difference as you progress. It can also encourage you when you start realising what you can do with a great pro horn which you couldn't before. I dare say you would sound geat on either a 62 or 80II but perhaps there can be more differential in a beginner's hands? That was my experience.
I’m saying that it makes less difference in “earlier years” as long as the cheaper sax hasn’t got problems. This goes for all instruments. You learn to look for things that you can “eke out” and on some instruments it’s easier than others. It doesn’t always follow that the “pro” horn will be the one that allows it more.
I once played a cheap Dearman alto that gave Sanborn breakup really easily. In fact, it was hard to shut it off, but if those type of gigs were the only gigs I did then it would have outgunned every other horn I’ve played.
Basically, whatever you’re trying to do, you need a horn that doesn’t make things harder than they need to be - it’s hard enough.
 
But you have enough colour in your sound to get something a bit different from a Martin to a Mk6 to a Yam Custom?
I think that mouthpieces and reeds can make that change much more than the horn itself. I've never played a Martin, but have tried Conn 10Ms, Beuscher Top Hat and Canes, BAs (my choice), MkVIs, VIIs, SA80s, ref36/54, signatures, Supremes, Keilwerth SX90s, Yanagasawas, Yamahas and yes there are differences, but nothing has persuaded me away from my BA. A 10M came closest and considered it as a second horn.... but I still don't know if when I was sitting down to play I'd have picked it up ahead of the BA.

So I do think that a forever horn is more than possible, and I can shape it for what I need, especially when throwing a change of reed and mouthpiece into the equation.
 
If you have only been playing seriously for two years, then I am afraid to say it is a vanity project. Consider lessons or an upgrade in mouthpiece (and suitable reed) before a new instrument.
 
If you have only been playing seriously for two years, then I am afraid to say it is a vanity project. Consider lessons or an upgrade in mouthpiece (and suitable reed) before a new instrument.
I have to say, I disagree with that definition. While someone who's been playing for five years (and studying seriously for two) will probably not be at a stage where they will really need a better quality sax, if they choose to spend their hard earned cash on something they want, that's quite different to vanity. If someone has a passtime they really enjoy, they have some cash and they want to spend it on something they want for that passtime, I think that's fair enough. As an analogy, I am a keen amateur photographer. I can take a decent picture but I have no specialist training or advanced skills. I recently bought myself an expensive full frame mirrorless camera to replace a DSLR. I don't need it to take pictures, but I wanted it, I enjoy using it and I like the results I get with it. I am perfectly happy that I have spent a couple of thousand of my pounds on something for me. Same with saxophones.
 
A new sax can be a "booster". Maybe the boring scales-, embouchure-, intonation exercises can be more joyful with a new sax. We all need some changes?

Exactly this!

It's just like what we say with bicycles -- a new bike may not necessarily make you any faster, but if it makes you want to go out and ride more, and you can afford it, then go for it!
 
A new sax can be a "booster". Maybe the boring scales-, embouchure-, intonation exercises can be more joyful with a new sax. We all need some changes?
But there are lots of ways to do that.

For example, I found (yvmv) playing exercises to a drone backing or iReal or something a real boost and enjoyable.
£€¥0.0
 
🙂🙂 Yes let's talk about it...I have been GASing for quite a while and although I have (sort of) stopped, lately I am still hankering for a good Conn 26m.. I bought my horns quite a while ago and actually still have most of them. They still bring a smile to my lips when I play them and admire their quality, workmanship and history. As my pal said when he played my 34xxx SBA tenor "This horn has every tune ever played inside it and wants me to play them!) After 45 minuties he put it down with a satisfied smile. Of course this is certainly not logical but it is rather romantic don't you think? So what price can you put on that? Keep your horns if you can and bask in the romance!! Regards..🙂🙂
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,379
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom