Saxophones Can we talk about GAS?

Exactly this!
That‘s only valid until the honey moon wears off. Visit a shop with a decent selection and test every horn that is of interest to you. After that decide if you want to go new or give yourself a bit of time until your dream horn shows up on the used market.
The last horn I bought was a tenor: Visited 3 shops plus 3 horns shipped from online shops to nail it down. Top of the list Selmer supreme (11 k€, way to expensive), second place YTS-875EX (5,4 k€) and third place Yanagisawa T-WO1 (3,7 k €). I finally picked the Yani as the small difference to the Yamaha didn‘t justify the mark-up. Waited for a few weeks before I bought and by chance got one lightly used for 2.9 k€.
There are lots of choices out there and you may save a few quid if you take considerate decisions. The least considerate would be to select your horn for life based on youtube videos.
 
But there are lots of ways to do that.

For example, I found (yvmv) playing exercises to a drone backing or iReal or something a real boost and enjoyable.
£€¥0.0
But we are only humans!?!?! The best days, back the 70's, for selling saxes were when the state paid back the "surplus tax". Most of the saxplayers didn't need new saxes. They just needed to empty their wallets. But it's beeter to buy a new sax ......
 
As an analogy, I am a keen amateur photographer. I can take a decent picture but I have no specialist training or advanced skills. I recently bought myself an expensive full frame mirrorless camera to replace a DSLR. I don't need it to take pictures, but I wanted it, I enjoy using it and I like the results I get with it. I am perfectly happy that I have spent a couple of thousand of my pounds on something for me. Same with saxophones.
I too am an amateur 'tog and have recently traded in my crop sensor DSLR for a full frame mirrorless. I got what I could afford at this time, with an adaptor for my existing lenses. Now I can do the type of photography I want to do, better on this camera using the exact same lenses I had before.
So I agree it could be the same with saxophones and you only realise this the more you use it and get better!
 
Last edited:
There are lots of choices out there and you may save a few quid if you take considerate decisions. The least considerate would be to select your horn for life based on youtube videos.
Thank you. Although I feel my choice of saxophone is influenced by what I can realistically afford for a brand new sax,£3000 max, not You Tube, I take your point that I could get a higher value sax second hand.
 
Last edited:
I tried to read most of this thread: so want to add my two-bits worth for vintage Buescher alto saxophones: from the types 3 & 4 so-called "TrueTones" made from 1926-1931 and the subsequent Bueschers from the rest of the 1930s whose actions were refinements on the TrueTone though similar.

People tout many of the later Bueschers than that as especially desireable too; however personally I'm only experienced with TrueTones. The beauty of an older Buescher, the hand craftsmanship or another era, that bespeaks quality on an organic level, and saxophone of choice for the late classical saxophonist John-Edward Kelly whom had played a silver-plated 1928 TrueTone alto and advocated all his students play similar Bueschers, himself a student of the great Sigurd Rascher who played a model Buescher their New Aristocrat introduced just after the TrueTones with improved ergonomics though similar. The just a little later Art Deco Bueschers of the late 1930s seem especially nice.

And gosh Bueschers are a good bargain and played by lots of other musicians in other idioms too. George of www.2ndendings.com likes to sell old TrueTones, who likely could suggest where to scout for a TrueTone or other Bueschers in the U. K. too.
 
Wow!!! And, what about the venerable Conn 6M or that's phenomenal though rarer younger sibling the 26M?

The 6M were about one of the most produced alto saxophones, their 26M was a more refined version of, the second world war truncated production of. Stephen Howard recommends a "minty" 6m over a 26M a renowned expert.

Both saxes are often judged as arguably the best saxophone ever built; whose action is head and shoulders better than any other saxophones. I have owned a bargain King Super20 a pawn shop find, and an equally a bargain Selmer Mark VI #83038 and had a 1967 Buffet Dynaction alto in high school making payments on that, to difficult to continue: but just handling a recently overhauled Conn 6M put all those altos to shame. Charlie Parker's favorite saxophone!
 
As an analogy, I am a keen amateur photographer. I can take a decent picture but I have no specialist training or advanced skills. I recently bought myself an expensive full frame mirrorless camera to replace a DSLR. I don't need it to take pictures, but I wanted it, I enjoy using it and I like the results I get with it. I am perfectly happy that I have spent a couple of thousand of my pounds on something for me. Same with saxophones.
10 years ago I bought a certified refurbished FUJIFILM FinePix S9150 Bridge Digital Camera on Amazon for $110 US. It was in new condition with 16.2 Megapixels and 50x Optical Zoom, with image stabilisation and built in pop up flash. New, they went for a little more than twice that.

It essentially replaced my Yashica 35mm camera system with Contax mount system, had all sorts of nice lenses, filters, flashes, and etc. The Fuji does all I need, takes excellent photos, has been my all around camera since.
taken over a half dozen wedding photos, good at outdoor portrature, used multiflash setup for group photos, and etc. (Got excellent results from drugstore darkrooms. Walgreens' lab in Albuquerque, if they got a decent set of negatives, I got back pro results for 5x7 ($1), 8x10 ($2), 11x14 ($5) in 1990's, at standard processing costs. Did as a favour for friends, they reimbursed me, gave them my negatives with the reprints. One, a poor Navajo couple ordered $400 worth. I was glad to help because if they hired a professional, they could have easily expended over $2,000 then, which they could not afford. They had a large extended family, thus they and all family members got supplied with photos.

Was conversing with a professional photographer, he thought my idea was great because he spent quite a bit of money that had to be passed onto his customers because professional photo labs are expensive. He could have saved them a little plus make a good profit.
But, the Fuji has sufficient zoom, sufficient shutter speed, excellent contrast, image stabilisation, pop-up flash is convenient, very easy to tool around with and being digital, I get results right away. (No, I haven't done any wedding photos since save one on an older lower resolution bridge camera about 11 years ago. It was an informal one for a senior couple, which as church musician I also did the music.)

I kind of compare this to a well playing but underdog instrument that I have purchased inexpensively. I am not afraid to take it places, plus it produces good results. My now 13 year old Venus straight Soprano Sax I bought for $219 back then is such an instrument, still plays well.
 
Have you been to a shop with a large selection to try yet? It’s a must, and will clarify a few things at least.
To try a saxophone (beginner/student or a professional sax) you need to play/blow it for several hours ... mayby days. A large selections of saxes is maybe not helping..... ??. When I was selling saxes most of the guys who came to my place went home with a used beginner student sax that they could play on trail. I was not selling saxes I sold Rock & Roll Saxophone concept. I didn't put down more reeds, better straps, silk swabs .... I put down some CD's with Rock & Roll Saxophone players.
 
To try a saxophone (beginner/student or a professional sax) you need to play/blow it for several hours ... mayby days. A large selections of saxes is maybe not helping..... ??. When I was selling saxes most of the guys who came to my place went home with a used beginner student sax that they could play on trail. I was not selling saxes I sold Rock & Roll Saxophone concept. I didn't put down more reeds, better straps, silk swabs .... I put down some CD's with Rock & Roll Saxophone players.
Yes, playing for an extended time will give up more on a horn but if the comparison is no time at all then it’s a must imo. There will be some saxes that for some reason might not be agreeable at all. These can then be dismissed.
 
I tried to read most of this thread: so want to add my two-bits worth for vintage Buescher alto saxophones: from the types 3 & 4 so-called "TrueTones" made from 1926-1931 and the subsequent Bueschers from the rest of the 1930s whose actions were refinements on the TrueTone though similar.

People tout many of the later Bueschers than that as especially desireable too; however personally I'm only experienced with TrueTones. The beauty of an older Buescher, the hand craftsmanship or another era, that bespeaks quality on an organic level, and saxophone of choice for the late classical saxophonist John-Edward Kelly whom had played a silver-plated 1928 TrueTone alto and advocated all his students play similar Bueschers, himself a student of the great Sigurd Rascher who played a model Buescher their New Aristocrat introduced just after the TrueTones with improved ergonomics though similar. The just a little later Art Deco Bueschers of the late 1930s seem especially nice.

And gosh Bueschers are a good bargain and played by lots of other musicians in other idioms too. George of www.2ndendings.com likes to sell old TrueTones, who likely could suggest where to scout for a TrueTone or other Bueschers in the U. K. too.
Buescher True Tones are nice saxes, and generally good value. I currently have an alto and a soprano one, the soprano I've owned for about 40 years. They have a good tone, are well made and I have found them OK to pair with a range of mouthpieces. However, as I have posted elsewhere on this forum, they have significant disadvantages. The ergonomics for those of us with larger hands are very poor, with the palm keys in particular being very small and set very low. Even with tall risers, they are not comfortable to play. In terms of playability I would rank them as much worse than a modern Yanagisawa, which I also own. I play my Yanagisawas much, much more than my True Tones, and I find them to enable me to just play music, rather than getting in the way.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,379
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom