Saxophones Can we talk about GAS?

Of the 100+ altos which I've owned in the past 13yrs the one I've just come back to is the SA80II.

I had one 5-6 years ago, thought I'd given up when my tutor moved away up and I sold it, then later got back into playing and found the '58 Superdynaction which I've loved for the past 5 years but always thought back to the Selmer. A chance encounter with someone who wanted to p/ex their SA80II alto against another of my horns left me with her 80II, which I've just had serviced by Paul Carrington. The SDA is a close second, but until something better turns up, this one is staying.

For me, this Selmer blows away the modern pro Yamahas and Yanis I've had (62s and 901s). The new to me 80II plays just like the previous one. It's superb. I'm no pro player, a forever beginner, but contrary to what Colin says even a beginner can appreciate ease of playabilty, good build quality and most of all the nuances they'd never discovered in a 'cheap' horn, like the SA80II's great flexibilty to bend notes I'd never encountered when playing other contenders.

A new SA80II will cost you £5,000 so you'd likely not pick one off the shelf and try it. But a nice used one will be £2,000 - £3,000. There's the opportunity you might miss by buying new.

I'm currently loving nineteen saxophones, for various reasons, but four are going, SDA included. 😳
 
you have misquoted my words,
I rather think "editorialised"

I am happy to say that I am no longer dissatisfied with my progress on the sax, hence my foray into considering new sax options. I am not currently looking for a teacher.
A much better - even, possibly, good - reason to reward yourself with a bit of gass. Unlike watching advertising.
 
Be aware that we all start off wanting just one but as soon as you have two another will turn up as an unmissable bargain or some sort of romantic contrast. It's not GAS. It's the love of saxophones.
I agree. This is already happening. Someone is offering me a YAS 25 for £400. Excellent condition. I could have it in my hands by tomorrow.... Could this be enough of a distraction for me I wonder?
 
I rather think "editorialised"


A much better - even, possibly, good - reason to reward yourself with a bit of gass. Unlike watching advertising.
@mizmar what do you think about the YAS 25? I have been offered a good one for £400. I know it isn't quite on the level of what I was looking for, but it might be enough of a distraction with a relatively small outlay......
 
Hello @Mix O Lydian
I agree. This is already happening. Someone is offering me a YAS 25 for £400. Excellent condition. I could have it in my hands by tomorrow.... Could this be enough of a distraction for me I wonder?

I'm not @mizmar but do have a YAS-25 and IMO (4 months beginner!) it is great. Well built, easy to play ergonomically and a good sound, even when I blow it. My teacher rates it highly and said it's all I need. Mine cost £200 plus £160 for some new pads and a service and was in great condition (hardly used?), so £400 for a player sounds reasonable.

Since getting a YTS-25 I barely play the alto but that is due to preference of sound rather than playability etc.

I'd say go for it!
 
@mizmar what do you think about the YAS 25? I have been offered a good one for £400. I know it isn't quite on the level of what I was looking for, but it might be enough of a distraction with a relatively small outlay......
The same applies to this horn as well as the more expensive horns, you need to try it first and check that it suits.
 
@mizmar what do you think about the YAS 25? I have been offered a good one for £400. I know it isn't quite on the level of what I was looking for, but it might be enough of a distraction with a relatively small outlay......
I'm not the one to ask!
All I do know is that all the variations in my playing comes mostly from me, the reed, the MP a bit and leaks in the horns.
 
I am 60 this year and want to treat myself to my "forever" saxophone.
I am 61 right now, and I have been learning the saxophone for about 12 years.
I don't think there is such a thing as a forever horn. At some point one is ready for the next step, sort of graduating from a basic horn that is easy to play (but perhaps a bit limited in its possibilities). But even if you go for a very good, professional level saxophone, there is a (significant?) chance that you'll be looking for some kind of a change in a couple of years (5? 10? 20?). One of my previous sax-teachers was playing a Borgani tenor (Joe Lovano signature model) like you can see on the end of this page Borgani OBT Vintage tenor, Joe Lovano and Vintage alto saxophone review. I think he was very pleased with it.
I saw that sax for sale at my tech's shop last year, it was his sax. Het had just gotten himself a Yanigasawa, don't know which model.
On the other hand, I got myself a R&C curved soprano in January as my first soprano. And I have the impression that I won't be needing another soprano after that one. But we'll see how that goes ......
 
Partly repeating what others have already said...
  • There's no such thing as 'beginner' 'intermediate' or 'pro' horns
  • There are price points which define amongst other things materials, build quality, ergonomics, serviceability....
  • Generally, assuming the horn is well set-up a more expensive instrument will be easier to play
  • Ergonomics vary enormously between makes but generally modern instruments are much friendlier than 'vintage'
There's no substitute for trying out horns. Some years ago, I tried various new and vintage tenors (I think) ranging from Conns, King Zephyr, Buescher etc., to Yamaha, Yanagisawa, Keilworth etc. The ergonomics were all different, especially the pinky tables
 
I suggest you drop the concept of a “forever horn” and settle for one that you like and can afford. I have my forever horn now, but several of the instruments that I’ve owned along the way were pretty good as well. I could have remained perfectly happy with the horn that I was playing in the ‘90s (Selmer Balanced Action) if I had known a good horn tech then and had it rebuilt. Several dozen horns and a few decades later, I know there is no better horn for me than the one I have now.
 
I don't think there is such a thing as a forever horn. At some point one is ready for the next step, sort of graduating from a basic horn that is easy to play (but perhaps a bit limited in its possibilities). But even if you go for a very good, professional level saxophone, there is a (significant?) chance that you'll be looking for some kind of a change in a couple of years (5? 10? 20?). One of my previous sax-teachers was playing a Borgani tenor (Joe Lovano signature model) like you can see on the end of this page Borgani OBT Vintage tenor, Joe Lovano and Vintage alto saxophone review. I think he was very pleased with it.
.
I disagree. I've owned about 150 saxes over the 45 years I've been playing, and I bought my Yanagisawa T992 about 20 years ago. I have had no desire for another tenor ever since, and I can never see me selling the Yanagisawa.
 
I think there is no one horn that can be a forever horn. There are so many good ones from the cheaper YAS to the more expensive SA80II. At the end of the day your choice of mouthpiece and reed and YOU will be more important to your sound than the hardware. You will find that you sound pretty much the same on every horn you try. Some days better some days worse. Keep practicing. I would spend £600 on a second hand one, have it ‘teched’ and experiment with mouthpieces and reeds. My forever horn is a vintage Martin that makes me sound great, is easy to service myself and did not cost a fortune. I used the £2400 surplus to go mountaineering in the Andes, the experience of a lifetime. Good luck.
 
I think there is no one horn that can be a forever horn. There are so many good ones from the cheaper YAS to the more expensive SA80II. At the end of the day your choice of mouthpiece and reed and YOU will be more important to your sound than the hardware. You will find that you sound pretty much the same on every horn you try. Some days better some days worse. Keep practicing. I would spend £600 on a second hand one, have it ‘teched’ and experiment with mouthpieces and reeds. My forever horn is a vintage Martin that makes me sound great, is easy to service myself and did not cost a fortune. I used the £2400 surplus to go mountaineering in the Andes, the experience of a lifetime. Good luck.

You are clearly on the wrong website. If everyone shared your attitude, the whole saxophone economy would collapse.
 
Yes saw that one. But they are selling it in behalf of someone so usual warranty doesn't apply.

If a horn has lasted this long, any “birth defects” will have been revealed. There’s really nothing much else that is covered by the usual warranty. Action adjustments from factory settings are also not covered by warranty. Wear and tear to pads and soft materials…. Same. Finish? Same - it has already happened to a used instrument, or is not covered by factory warranty.

If you ever bought an instrument from me, it would be better than when it left the factory. I have nothing for sale now.
 
If a warranty is important then you need to go to an established shop. I always buy horns from such places and have never needed the warranty but that tells its own story. Check out the well known shops and see what they have and be ready to travel if necessary. I bought my most used horn in Bradford and I live in London and it was worth the effort and travel.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,379
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom