Saxophones Can we talk about GAS?

There is only one legit way to get a "forever" sax.
- You start working on your own horns.
- You gradually acquire the skills do do the work right (alternatively, you have superior talent).
- You find something neglected and bring it back to factory new or better condition.

You fall in love with the instrument!

- you try some other fancy stuff out there and you realize how much bling covers the shortcomings of those instruments

Rinse and repeat. After the third time you don't even want to try anything else anymore.

If you ever bought an instrument from me, it would be better than when it left the factory. I have nothing for sale now.
100% true.
 
You are clearly on the wrong website. If everyone shared your attitude, the whole saxophone economy would collapse.
This is a players’ forum, not a vendors’ forum, no mistake. As for the saxophone economy, it is already in peril. Fewer and fewer young players (have a look at the demography of members on CS) from a combination of lack of interest, decreased funding for school band programmes and the price of new instruments (with or without tariffs), add £40 on average per lesson per month and another 40 for a 5 pack of reeds per quarter and it becomes prohibitive for a lot of people. And that’s just in what ‘was’ the Western world.
 
I don’t know why I should pile on, but I don’t have a good reason not to, so here we go.

Regarding “professional” vs. “student” saxophones, the difference is mainly in build quality, with additional differences in tonal quality and complexity. From the standpoint of playability, a “pro” horn will reward good technique more than a student horn would. I’ve read good things about the Trevor James instruments, but I know from experience that a YAS-62 or A-W01 will do anything the most advanced player asks of it. Same is true of many vintage horns if they are in good condition.

Will an experienced professional sound fine on a student instrument? Absolutely. Would the professional prefer to play her (insert high-end horn name here)? Again, absolutely. A pro wants a horn that gets out of the way and lets him or her express themselves freely, and is of high build quality. A student horn generally has a few build and response issues that would be noticeable to an experienced pro, but might not matter to a beginner.

I don’t know if that helps with your decision, @Mix O Lydian 🙂 My advice is buy the Yanigisawa …
 
my "forever" saxophone
For me it's more the "forever" saxophone style/genre. I just play Rock & Roll Saxophone (Blues, Rock & Roll, Rockabilly, R&B, Soul, Rock ...). I can play an Amati, Dörfler & Jörka, New King, Martin HC (Comm I or II), The Martin, Yani 880, YTS 25, YTS 62, King Super 20 ...... as long as the tones comes out they way I want. The saxes must be well adjusted (no leaks, at least not too big/many) and capeable to handle my Rovner Deep-V mouthpieces, The mouthpieces are more important than my saxes.

But GAS can stroke me as well. For two weeks ago I was close to buy a Keilwerth SX Shadow in mint condition. At the age of 70! When I came home I talked to myself and came to the conclusion that I already have a poor man Keilwerth SX, the New King! So now I can concentrate more to play Rock & Roll Saxophone. I don't need better saxes. I need to play more so I can get out and play more Rock & Roll Saxophone.
 
Please do not degrade threads about Alto Saxophones, with comments about Tenors.
C Melody saxophones are OK.

Just kidding.

If you have, £2500-£3000 to spend, get the best horn you can afford, new or used.
As stated, play tested by an accomplished musician.
Why even consider a £400 horn.
An accomplished flute player, can make a well regulated 104, sound great, especially when using a mic. Same with a well made student grade Sax.

I have a MKVI Alto, and the only reason for another Alto, would be a backup, if I was working.
I do have two C flutes, two Piccs, and one Alto flute. A top tier Alto flute and Sop are something I might buy, to play and leave for the kids/grandkids, age 5/8.
Have a nice B12 for them, and am the custodian/player of that old C grenadilla.
Kids moved to Colorado. Wish we could sail there, as a 60' class yacht is cheaper than another house, and more fun.
We'd be lockin, ⛵️🏴‍☠️
 
I don’t know if that helps with your decision, @Mix O Lydian 🙂 My advice is buy the Yanigisawa …
I agree - I think you’ll likely find them quite a dream to play. I’ve had two altos and two sopranos.

The most recent one was their entry level straight soprano. Didn’t like it as it felt too constricted. Great horn though.

The others were:

Curved 991 soprano - v nice
991 alto
A800 Elimona alto

The two altos were vv good. Easy to play. Liked the Elimona more actually. In fact it was a great horn.

Why do I not have them now? I couldn’t find enough versatility in them.
 
Before I bought my new RAW alto I tried a used one "fully serviced" at a retailer and repairer. It was unplayable and I immediately lost faith in the establishment and left.
As with Dr G, if I'm selling a fully working horn (see Yardsale) it will have had at least a recent service or have been overhauled by a well regarded tech in the past. Lydia's not far from me but the two pro horns I'm selling may not give her enough to choose from.
She's welcome to come and try them, and also have a play of my just serviced SA80II but that's not for sale.
 
If a warranty is important then you need to go to an established shop. I always buy horns from such places and have never needed the warranty but that tells its own story. Check out the well known shops and see what they have and be ready to travel if necessary. I bought my most used horn in Bradford and I live in London and it was worth the effort and travel.
Yes. I feel I would prefer to buy from a musical instrument shop whose technician has checked the sax before sale, or from a tech person, or from someone who has had the sax looked over and serviced prior to sale, rather than from someone on Ebay who has had the sax stored in their garage/attic/back of the wardrobe for ten years and not had it checked over before selling.
 
There is only one legit way to get a "forever" sax.
- You start working on your own horns.
- You gradually acquire the skills do do the work right (alternatively, you have superior talent).
- You find something neglected and bring it back to factory new or better condition.

You fall in love with the instrument!

- you try some other fancy stuff out there and you realize how much bling covers the shortcomings of those instruments

Rinse and repeat. After the third time you don't even want to try anything else anymore.


100% true.
I wish I had the skills to do that. But sadly, I don't.
 
Yes. I feel I would prefer to buy from a musical instrument shop whose technician has checked the sax before sale, or from a tech person, or from someone who has had the sax looked over and serviced prior to sale, rather than from someone on Ebay who has had the sax stored in their garage/attic/back of the wardrobe for ten years and not had it checked over before selling.
Don't be put off with buying a horn that is on consignment in a reputable shop, they would have been looked at by the stores technician,Jimmy mentioned going to Bradford which was probably Woodwind Exchange most of Stuart's horns were on consignment but there was no risk, I bought a number of horns of him.
Go and try as many as you can in your budget, don't have any preconceptions of brand and just go with your heart.
 
Don't be put off with buying a horn that is on consignment in a reputable shop, they would have been looked at by the stores technician,Jimmy mentioned going to Bradford which was probably Woodwind Exchange most of Stuart's horns were on consignment but there was no risk, I bought a number of horns of him.
Go and try as many as you can in your budget, don't have any preconceptions of brand and just go with your heart.
That was the place, sadly covid put him out of business. There is another place there now, West Yorkshire Woodwind, I think he bought the business from Stuart, but I can't vouch for it as I've never been there.

I have fond memories of standing in Stuart's try-out room with 5 King Super 20s and a Conn 10m. I just played them round and round and one by one they were dismissed, and then there was one. I went looking for a Conn and came away with a King.
 
Last edited:
This is a players’ forum, not a vendors’ forum, no mistake. As for the saxophone economy, it is already in peril. Fewer and fewer young players (have a look at the demography of members on CS) from a combination of lack of interest, decreased funding for school band programmes and the price of new instruments (with or without tariffs), add £40 on average per lesson per month and another 40 for a 5 pack of reeds per quarter and it becomes prohibitive for a lot of people. And that’s just in what ‘was’ the Western world.
I share MarkSax opinion/description. It has been going on for a few years and I think it's getting worse in the future. What can we do? Stick our heads in the sand and pretend we are living in the happy 50's? Or try to spread saxophone music around .......? But we shouldn't talk about it here on Mix O Lydian's topic.
 
That was the place, sadly covid put him out of business. There is another place there now, West Yorkshire Woodwind, I think he bought the business from Stuart, but I can't vouch for it as I've never been there.

I have fond memories of standing in Stuart's try-out room with 5 King Super 20s and a Conn 10m. I just played them round and round and one by one they were dismissed, and then there was one. I went looking for a Conn and came away with a King.
It was well worth the journey, I tried about 14 mark VI altos, eventually bought the best one for me, it was a proper Aladdin's cave and Stuart was great to deal with.
 
As far as the Yamaha 25's go, I bought tenor and alto used. Both needed a tweak, clean, a couple of pads and a bit of cork. They play great. They do everything I need to do and they're easy to regulate.

As far as a used pro horn goes, there's a refurbished Yani in Curly Woodwind at a very reasonable £2k asking price.

If my car didn't need tyres and a timing belt and the front door wasn't falling to bits it'd be here with me 🤗
 
As far as the Yamaha 25's go, I bought tenor and alto used. Both needed a tweak, clean, a couple of pads and a bit of cork. They play great. They do everything I need to do and they're easy to regulate
I played a YTS 25 as well and they are good saxes. But one day the low stack F was stuck. The tech had to drill out the rod and replace it with a new. My The Martin Tenor ,1959 and Martin Handcraft (Committee), 1938 have are original beside pads, corks and felts. The Yamaha YTS 23, 25, 275 are fine saxes.
 
A few thoughts on various things that have come up.

1. If you're going to carry on playing, invest in the "best" horn you can afford. Try a bunch out to get a feel for them, don't try anything we'll above your price range, and go for the one you like best. That way, you will then focus on playing the thing rather than looking at other horns. Make sure you do the same with mouthpiece, but know that certain things will change as you improve, and forever mouthpiece is probably not a thing.

2. There's definitely a concept of forever horn. I've had my BA tenor for 24 years now following the above process. I've never played a tenor I prefer more; and now I have an alto to match. Nearly plumped on the silver BA bari that was in Australia but well.... justifying funds.

3. My second horn was a YAS25, after blowing apart a Boosey & Hawkes thing in 3 months. They're perfectly serviceable horns.... but it won't be your forever horn and you'll be constantly looking at other shiny horns.
 
1. If you're going to carry on playing, invest in the "best" horn you can afford. Try a bunch out to get a feel for them, don't try anything we'll above your price range, and go for the one you like best. That way, you will then focus on playing the thing rather than looking at other horns. Make sure you do the same with mouthpiece, but know that certain things will change as you improve, and forever mouthpiece is probably not a thing.
I have a further view: the more progress you make, the more likely your choice of “perfect horn” might change.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,380
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom