Saxophones Can i borrow your ears please.

No, I am not referring to your speaking voice. I am talking about the sound of an imaginary saxophone in your mind. Let’s try some examples.

When you hear a melody in your mind, is it a tenor sax?

When you hear a random pitch and try to match it, does that happen more naturally if you are playing a Bb instrument or an Eb sax? I used to play with a singer that was very good at scatting. If I was playing tenor, I could easily play back the line they sang even if we were just playing randomly and not in the context of any particular key. I cannot do that as easily on alto. I don’t have perfect pitch, but I have very good relative pitch on the tenor.
🫣🫣🫣🫣 what a silly boy I am I always thought it related to your speaking voice ok , that makes sense now .👍👍👍👍👍
 
🫣🫣🫣🫣 what a silly boy I am I always thought it related to your speaking voice ok , that makes sense now .👍👍👍👍👍
You’re not silly at all - a lot of people do consider the idea of matching their horn to their speaking voice. This is just my perspective. I think of it as matching the horn to my personality, just as I might select a motorcycle (BMW vs H-D or play racer), canoe vs kayak, or cross-country ski vs downhill.
 
You’re not silly at all - a lot of people do consider the idea of matching their horn to their speaking voice. This is just my perspective.
I think there is some value to it. I’m sure it can help sometimes but not a golden rule.
 
Some chops adapt more easily to certain sizes. However with persistence all can be tamed to an extent.

Coming from clarinet, Alto was no problem. Adding baritone presented few problems but adding tenor was difficult and needed much work and persistence. Soprano remains a work in progress.

I wonder if I have alto chops or just more experience on it. On alto, playing along with anything comes easily, even in difficult/unfamiliar keys. Once worked out on alto it's easily transferable to the rest.

As far as sound goes, I'm very rarely satisfied with alto. Tenor and Baritone more often sound pleasing to my ear and soprano is often acceptable. Clarinet is always acceptable, often pleasing and very occasionally exceptional.

I do find it odd that the horn I feel most proficient on is the one I feel sounds worst.

For me it's a love hate relationship, but I wouldn't be without any of them.
 
I thought that the tenor sounded the best. I am curious about your recording setup. I have found cell phones to be terrible at recording adequately. They are nearly useless for determining one's actual sound. To me they always sound 'pitchy'.
 
I think there is some value to it. I’m sure it can help sometimes but not a golden rule.
Singing voice especially. Personally I find alto and soprano harder because they extend above my normal singing range. (Bizarrely it’s not an issue for altissimo on tenor… but perhaps that’s because it view it similar to falsetto, and it’s not ‘regular’ playing for me)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,207
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom