Saxophones Can i borrow your ears please.

Using your diaphragm is a simple enough thing to advise, but I suspect most have no idea what you mean by it. Hence the gut punch method. At least most guys should understand that. And it works.
 
While I 100% agree with the air support advice, I think your main issue is voicing. I mean you do indeed play most notes perfectly in tune, so air support is sufficient for those. But the voicing is wrong on some, making you extremely flat. The good news is once the technique clicks for you, it will become automatic and foolproof. You just have to identify those bad notes and work until you can bring them up to pitch.

I don't usually advocate mouthpiece only exercises, but it might get you over the hump in this case. So try to play a simple tune like Mary Had a Little Lamb on just the mouthpiece to get a feel for changing pitch entirely with voicing. Then put the mouthpiece on and play a high A and bend it down as far as you can then back up to pitch so it matches the tuner.
 
While I 100% agree with the air support advice, I think your main issue is voicing. I mean you do indeed play most notes perfectly in tune, so air support is sufficient for those. But the voicing is wrong on some, making you extremely flat. .....
I mentioned voicing using vowel sounds on another thread and like most things saxophonic got different opinions! These ranged from doing the 'aaah' 'eee' 'oooh' tongue approach to jaw fore and aft motion, or forgetting all that and ensuring a good embouchure, open throat and strong breath support.

I can do it with the mouthpiece alone but not once attached to the sax or it just goes off. Maybe I'm not doing it correctly........?
 
I mentioned voicing using vowel sounds on another thread and like most things saxophonic got different opinions! These ranged from doing the 'aaah' 'eee' 'oooh' tongue approach to jaw fore and aft motion, or forgetting all that and ensuring a good embouchure, open throat and strong breath support.

I can do it with the mouthpiece alone but not once attached to the sax or it just goes off. Maybe I'm not doing it correctly........?
Can you whistle? The same tongue shapes you make to whistle different notes work for voicing as well. The vowel analogy doesn't work for me because I couldn't make an oooh with a mouthpiece in my mouth if I tried. It's more like varying degrees of a guttural hiss. Something like that is really hard to put into words. But a teacher can guide you.

With the mouthpiece on the horn, some notes are easier to bend than others. That's the reason I picked high A.

In Punchy's case, like a lot of beginners, it's easy to default to the wrong voicing, making the note flat every time. It's just a habit that needs to be broken with the help of your ears and this voicing technique.

Once you get better at it, you can control not only pitch but timbre, making your tone darker, brighter, fuller, thinner, gentle, or powerful. It's what makes Sanborn sound different from Desmond. It's a really valuable and essential technique that often gets overlooked when you can just push the buttons and blow and get a sound. But if you want a really good and flexible tone, you need to learn voicing.

In your case, realize that it takes years to develop this level of control. It's simply not possible for a beginner to master in a short time. So don't worry about it until you get a lot of playing hours under your belt.
 
Can you whistle? The same tongue shapes you make to whistle different notes work for voicing as well. The vowel analogy doesn't work for me because I couldn't make an oooh with a mouthpiece in my mouth if I tried.......
@Targa Yes, I do whistle and understand how my tongue position affects the pitch.
Flat and down, touching lower front teeth for low, drawing tongue back into an arch raises the pitch.
That works for me on the sax better than trying to mimic 'ah ee ooh'.
Cheers.

Edit: This post should have been addressed to @lydian
 
Technically you have a lot of good advice. The voicing recommendations are particularly good, however there is a larger picture. It seems that you are reading everything you're playing. That's a mental pathway the engages eyes to fingers and most often leaves out hearing what you're playing. Playing with feeling, good phrasing, in tune, and with good tone depend on YOUR hearing what you play. With very experienced readers this can come about (eventually). If you are playing tunes you know and enjoy then do not read them, play them by ear. Hear the melody in your head and play them without thinking about where your fingers are and listen to yourself. You will make mistakes, however if these are tunes you know well, they will sort themselves out and you can then have your own feedback as you play and adjust to what you would like to hear.

Players are often told to copy someone whose tone and playing they like. That's OK (up to a point), yet it's difficult or impossible if you aren't hearing how you play now so that you can adjust your tone, phrasing etc. It is the shortcut to developing the aspects you currently know are lacking.

Reading without direct feedback from hearing as you play = no improvement. The suggestion of playing a simple tune (Mary had a little lamb), but on your horn is a good one, yet doesn't have the emotional commitment that you have for the tunes you're already playing. You have stuck on the sides of your head all the equipment you need to improve. Use them.
 
Agree with @turf3 - push in. I think your ears work pretty well actually, as you are biting a lot of the time, because you are hearing flatness. The extra air support that people have talked of will help with flatness a bit, but more along the lines of keeping a good steady tone throughout the range. It's better to be sharp rather than flat when tuning as with good air / voicing (as mentioned by @lydian) and embouchure it's easily dealt with and a good open tone won't be compromised. Flat by more than a few cents isn't dealt with without compromising - and probably isn't dealt with anyway (biting does very little over the majority of the range).
 
I'm not playing baritone in the same style as I'm playing tenor. I play baritone with less pressure and is not often I play over G2. On tenor I play more as a singer. Playing the singing lines or give "harmonics" to the singer (fillings, background). I play more in upper register on tenor. More pressure on tenor or firm embouchure or more "biting"!!!

On baritone I hear a good baritone voice. On tenor I hear a good tenor voice. I stay out of judgments as flat, off pitch ...... . Practice breathing/blowing technique and use the breathing technique when you are doing embouchure exercises. Don't be afraid to "unleash the animal" inside of you. Try to get more boxing into your playing.

When I started to play baritone sax back in 1977 I knew what kind of music I wanted play on my bari. It was the same when I started to play tenor some years earlier. It was more or less playing riffs or playing in the background in blues, R&B or rock & roll songs. Easy songs but I had to put in energy. I practiced stuff that were useful for me to be a backing rock saxophonist. I tried to play "jazz" as well but that was not my thing. We all do mistakes.
 
Last edited:
Agree with @turf3 - push in. I think your ears work pretty well actually, as you are biting a lot of the time, because you are hearing flatness. The extra air support that people have talked of will help with flatness a bit, but more along the lines of keeping a good steady tone throughout the range. It's better to be sharp rather than flat when tuning as with good air / voicing (as mentioned by @lydian) and embouchure it's easily dealt with and a good open tone won't be compromised. Flat by more than a few cents isn't dealt with without compromising - and probably isn't dealt with anyway (biting does very little over the majority of the range).
It's better to be sharp than out of tune.

(Old bandsman's joke)
 
While I 100% agree with the air support advice, I think your main issue is voicing. I mean you do indeed play most notes perfectly in tune, so air support is sufficient for those.
Watch the first video again and see how quickly he runs out of air. Air support is the main issue and correcting it should improve everything else.
 
When you decide to play a wind instrument, the most important thing about it is always the air. Everything else is secondary.

Again, I refer to my recommendations of long tones, pppp to ffff and back to pppp, done over the full range of the horn. If done with INTENTION and ATTENTION to maintaining tone quality and holding pitch (judged by ears, not by eyes on a needle), this daily practice can't help but build an awareness of airstream. Your objective isn't to use this voicing syllable, or that phrase about how to breathe. Your objective is to learn within yourself how it FEELS to breathe properly, to blow through the horn properly, and to make a good quality sound over the full dynamic range of the sax. (You'll find that using weird incorrect techniques simply won't work here, you'll end up using the standard saxophone embouchure and proper breathing technique, or you'll be in pain and sounding bad.)
 
Couple counterexamples:

Notice how these players are deciding phrase length based on how they feel it should go, not on running out of air. You want always to sound like you've got plenty in reserve.

And when you blow properly through the horn with a good well supported airstream and a stable standard embouchure, it becomes easy to find a good tuning point on the cork, and all the notes will suddenly snap into tune.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_vPnXrIaOtw&list=RD_vPnXrIaOtw&start_radio=1


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4SjD2Lb_6c&list=RDw4SjD2Lb_6c&start_radio=1


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_I5n05YMTI&list=RD6_I5n05YMTI&start_radio=1
 
1) Commit to any horn. I’ll admit a lifelong passion for tenor for myself (now 70).

2) Please review what seems like years of guidance to you for developing your airstream and support. “Belly breathing”, “yoga breathing”, “abdominal breathing”…. Same dog, different leash.

I understand that it’s tough finding a practice space, but please, if only once in a while, try practicing outdoors where the sound is not reflected back at you. Blow through the horn and develop a full sound. Once you can do that, then you can learn to play softly with a full tone. Air support and control are the goals.

There are a great many people here that put their energy into playing many sizes of saxophones because it’s fun, others double because it is required of the gigs they take. Most GOOD doublers focus first on one instrument, then add the rest. I suggest that you pick the horn voice that best matches the voice in your head, and commit.
Dr G ,
Thank you iv been thinking you said pick the horn voice that matches my voice , any takers out there you can hear me speaking introducing the Apache video what would you say my voice tone compares to?
 
I suggest that you pick the horn voice that best matches the voice in your head, and commit.

Dr G ,
Thank you iv been thinking you said pick the horn voice that matches my voice , any takers out there you can hear me speaking introducing the Apache video what would you say my voice tone compares to?

No, I am not referring to your speaking voice. I am talking about the sound of an imaginary saxophone in your mind. Let’s try some examples.

When you hear a melody in your mind, is it a tenor sax?

When you hear a random pitch and try to match it, does that happen more naturally if you are playing a Bb instrument or an Eb sax? I used to play with a singer that was very good at scatting. If I was playing tenor, I could easily play back the line they sang even if we were just playing randomly and not in the context of any particular key. I cannot do that as easily on alto. I don’t have perfect pitch, but I have very good relative pitch on the tenor.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,193
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom