Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Sorry for the Tribble Prof but Nahhhh, the odd Alto every few months isn`t GAS .. three a week is GAS !. I know what GAS is, I had it properly with Melodeons - had up to 30 at one time and that was light compared to some on the forums
 
Last edited:
Did you watch Matt Stohrer's video? He seems to be saying the straight neck Conn alto is the best of the C-Mels, and that's a lovely one he's showing.

This is the only photo of the one for sale I've seen so far...

View attachment 5171
I've watched it a few times, and my take on what he said was that they were among the best... Possibly I was distracted by the voices in my head chanting "Shiny! Shiny! Must buy a C melody!".

Anyway, he clearly knows his stuff - I've watched quite a few of his sax repair/maintenance videos - kind of an American Stephen Howard. Even so "best" is always just someone's opinion, and might not agree with your own. I expect he's right in that they are very good. But it's still down to personal choice, either way. Is a Porsche 911 better than a late 20th century Citroen Saxo covered in unusually large dents? Probably is, yes. Would I have bought one? No, because it doesn't meet my personal criteria.

The playing position for a straight neck C mel, if you're standing up, is worth considering - the neck is quite long, compared to an alto so you either need to bend your head down a little, to rest it against your belly, or push the bow end out, away from you, to get the right angle on the neck. I've seen a picture of someone doing that. If I find it, I'll stick it in here. Some people might just be more comfortable playing one with the tenor style neck, for that reason.

Personally, I only play to entertain myself (and hopefully get better at it), and always sitting down, so the straight neck suits me better, but it might not suit everybody.
 
Is that nickel plate rather than silver?
Could be. I have two sort of vintage silver plated brass instruments (40s and 50s), and the plating has held up really well, but it doesn't tarnish, like my silver plated flute (which now quite brownish - I'm not convinced excessive polishing is a good idea).

It's a matt, slightly dull look though. The brass repairer I've been to told me it probably is real silver, but I assume that means a blend of real silver and other metals. Silver flute heads aren't pure silver either - it would be too soft. There has to be other things mixed in with it to make it viable.

So, if it was silver plate, it would have to be polished, probably quite often, to look as shiny as that one, or it would be the more maintenance free matt look, like my old tenor horn and cornet.

For a shiny plating, Nickel holds up a lot better. My nickel plated clarinet keys still look as good as the day it was delivered, without anything more than the occasional wipe with a soft cloth.
 
It would take it up. It's something like half a semitone, but it might be easier to tune up, with bad intonation, than trying to tune down.

The top end of each octave would go really flat, to get the bottom end in tune, but we tend to notice the high notes being out of tune more. If you tuned it up to B for the upper end of the second octave, that would get it closest to sounding in tune with bad intonation - some notes out. You might be able to to tweak it a bit better by reducing the opening on the lower keys too.

Getting it to play lower than it wants to, for the physical size, would be harder.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,458
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom