Did you watch Matt Stohrer's video? He seems to be saying the straight neck Conn alto is the best of the C-Mels, and that's a lovely one he's showing.
This is the only photo of the one for sale I've seen so far...
View attachment 5171
I've watched it a few times, and my take on what he said was that they were among the best... Possibly I was distracted by the voices in my head chanting "Shiny! Shiny! Must buy a C melody!".
Anyway, he clearly knows his stuff - I've watched quite a few of his sax repair/maintenance videos - kind of an American Stephen Howard. Even so "best" is always just someone's opinion, and might not agree with your own. I expect he's right in that they are very good. But it's still down to personal choice, either way. Is a Porsche 911 better than a late 20th century Citroen Saxo covered in unusually large dents? Probably is, yes. Would I have bought one? No, because it doesn't meet my personal criteria.
The playing position for a straight neck C mel, if you're standing up, is worth considering - the neck is quite long, compared to an alto so you either need to bend your head down a little, to rest it against your belly, or push the bow end out, away from you, to get the right angle on the neck. I've seen a picture of someone doing that. If I find it, I'll stick it in here. Some people might just be more comfortable playing one with the tenor style neck, for that reason.
Personally, I only play to entertain myself (and hopefully get better at it), and always sitting down, so the straight neck suits me better, but it might not suit everybody.