Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Anyone got a suggestion for good mouthpiece(s) for a Buescher C mel? What do I need to consider?
I can recommend the Zinner C melody mouthpiece that came with my Thomann one, but they're not cheap - and of course it might not suit you as well, but it is what they're made for (wind back a page or two for more details / blather).

If you don't feel like spending that sort of money, personally I'd try (as in buy) the plastic Windcraft, or ask nicely if I can have the Windcraft ebonite on a trial. They used to do that, with their own mouthpieces. Possibly, they still do:

Saxophone C Melody

- it's still close to 3/4 of the cost of buying a Zinner though, so I'd definitely want to check I liked it. For £25 inc postage for the plastic one, I'd just take the risk.
 
I did manage to get the Graftonite B5 alto mouthpiece to stay on my Thomann today, and it did play in tune, and really not that badly. It was just kind of holding onto the end of the cork by its fingernails though - and as I mentioned, I suspect I'm used to mouthpieces being pushed further on than they really should be.

It could do with another inch or so of neck, just to hold a mouthpiece like that. An alto mouthpiece with a really long shank might be okay.

I also tried the Yamaha 7C tenor mouthpiece. It actually would fit very well, if I expanded the cork just a bit more - it was a touch unsteady, but it sealed on well enough (pushed right up to the micro adjuster), and I was playing it in tune, with the micro adjuster wound in a bit more than with my Zinner.

It worked quite well, I thought. It had a bit more of a tenor sound, and seemed a bit stronger on the low notes. Really, it would be down to personal preference, but that wouldn't be a terrible choice.

I played them both with the same reed I've been using so far with the Zinner - a Medium Soft Fibracell. I don't know if that's a 2 or a 2.5, in the new scheme of things - maybe about half way between. It was actually a new one in the sense that I hadn't used it before - I must have bought it as a spare, a while ago.

[ EDIT: Sorry; not the tenor mouthpiece of course, that was with a Fibracell No. 2 tenor reed. ]

Testing three different mouthpieces with the same reed is not really a fair test, of course - they might all perform better with a different strength.

I might expand just the last centimeter or so of the cork, that the Zinner isn't using, so I can switch between them.

I didn't try my Graftonite A7 tenor mouthpiece, because it's firmly wedged in an adapter I made to fit it to an alto recorder body. I do things like that sometimes. The reasons why aren't important 🙂

Oh, and my longer thumb hook mod works fine. I might refine it a bit more, but it was more comfortable.
 
Last edited:
Ah! Personally, I found playing a tenor made me feel like Rod Hull, being attacked by his Emu... Not sure if I mentioned that earlier.

You could well be right - one of each does have an appeal. I don't really want to go as far up as a sopranino... or so I keep telling myself... I like soprano and alto, and I found I wasn't all that keen on wrestling a tenor, so a baritone would be out of the question (just how tall is Lisa Simpson?).

I bought a Bb clarinet first - i.e before any sax. There's quite a lot in common in how you play them, of course. Later on, having bought the two sizes of sax I wanted most (alto and curved sop), I bought a Venus Eb clarinet, which is really pretty good - especially considering the more accepted models start at around ten times that - then more recently a C clarinet, and then an alto. I was thinking bass, but I went with the alto, and now don't really want a bigger one than that.

So, yes, I guess you're right. It's a size in the ranges of sizes I like, that I didn't have 🙂

It plays most of the range of a tenor (less the low B and Bb), but it's considerably less cumbersome to play sitting down, at least it is for me.

It is good for playing from sheet music that isn't transposed, of course - i.e. in the key it was intended to be in. I tend to use MuseScore and if I get a score for that, I can make it transpose for me easily, so it's not such a big deal, but I still have more music in C - that was my excuse for the C clarinet. As it turns out, that's probably about the best size for my hands, though I'm still fonder of my first Bb.
 
Last edited:
No, David. I only had the budget for one 🙂

It was up there, on my list of choices, but the distance to go and look at it put me off, so I decided to cheat and get a new one (delivered) - and I'm very happy with it. I'm not ruling out getting a vintage one at some point though.

If I'd thought about it, I'd have just made the title of this thread "C Melody Saxes", but I can't see any way to change it now.
 
There seems a lot of interest in C Melody saxes, but WHY? What's the appeal when there's not a great deal of music written for them nowadays? Is it the "must have one of each" thing going on?
Well my interest is that I play in a little local community orchestra, which I enjoy, but I can never guarantee what part I'll be playing. If I'm lucky it's a bass clarinet part. Or possibly a 2nd trumpet part (yawn, usually). But it could as easily be an oboe part, a viola part, a bassoon part or whatever.

My transposition-at-sight isn't good enough if a) it's fast b) there are many accidentals and/or c) another clef but treble is involved. So I thought a C mel might help the situation a bit.

Plus the fact that it might be a bit less 'strong' than my tenor might suit the (rather weedy) violins better 😉
 
I've found an identical straight neck Conn C-Mel for half the Jones' price! Discussing with the UK seller right now. :w00t:
Not really sure why? :confused2:
Must be the "must have one of each" thing going on, or maybe I just don't like being left out? If anyone here (Andy 1st dibs?) really wants it (you pay 5% forum finder's fee), let me know?
Andy... you could send the NEW one back???
 
Cool 😎

Most of the "why" is that the Trevor Jones has had some work done on it to get it saleable, and they're a traditional small music shop so they have to charge the rates they do.

Thanks, but I won't be sending this one back though. I like it. Buying any instrument tends to fill me with a sense of dread - wondering what state it will arrive in, and whether I'll be sending it back (has happened) or fixing the problems myself (ditto) or paying someone to, rather than go through it all again when they botch the repair / redelivery / just send me one someone else returned to see if that shuts me up.

So, anyway, this time I won. I don't always 🙂 All I've had to do so far, that was wrong, is tweak the adjuster screw that makes low B hold the C# key cup shut. I may tweak a couple more, but it plays well, and I'm happy with it.

As Ads said about his Sakkusu, it sounds like a saxophone. I can make it sound bloody awful with an alto mouthpiece that doesn't fit though - not a moo, in this case, more of a mewl.

Listening to the recordings of jazz C melody sax players, on csax.net, in their prime, I thought they sounded quirky, but wonderful. I guess with the wrong setup, and in poor condition, they can sound terrible. I'm still wondering if they'd sound any worse than, say, trying to play a tenor with a clarinet mouthpiece held on with gaffer tape....

If I still had a tenor, I'd be forced to try that, now 😀
 
I dread buying horns too for the same reason Andy, what will need fixing when you open the case.. 🙁

they almost always need something adjusting even if its just the regulation screw on the G# linkage thingy or a cork or two - After that, the dread turns to curiosity to see how it fares... if the thing puts a smile on your face and you can`t put it down -- compared it to the (not so local) Sax hoarder's RAW and the RAW lost -- Done a very successful Gig on the Sunday with it -- Having jammed with another band alongside with a sax playing mate a day later to critical acclaim -- then you know you`ve cracked it .. Job done ....

(this was Tenor in my case - if I`d followed my original plan 2 years ago I`d not have had to go through all this but this damn forum lead me astray)
 
Last edited:
The plan Jeanette was to buy a Cheap used Walstein (which I did) to keep me going while I had an extensive rebuild on the MkVII I`d abused for the past 30 years but Davey listed that Damn Silver Yam 62 and that went out of the window (Sold the BW and the "Scrap" MkVII) .. the Yamaha "Diversion" (Sorry about the Pun Bike Fans) lasted 2 yrs (62 then 32+61) and what did I end up with - another damn Selmer, Perfect - back home and happy .. interesting 2 years though :rolleyes:..
 
Beware Andy .......... this forum is trouble - I`ve managed to fight GAS pretty successfully , even my Alto count over the two years is relatively very low and I`m relatively new to Alto so susceptible and I`ve avoided Mouthpiece GAS totally but many have fallen massively here on all counts , remember that there are still exciting thunderous Baritones to try ........ 😱
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,458
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom