Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Beware Andy .......... this forum is trouble - I`ve managed to fight GAS pretty successfully , even my Alto count over the two years is relatively very low and I`m relatively new to Alto so susceptible and I`ve avoided Mouthpiece GAS totally but many have fallen massively here on all counts , remember that there are still exciting thunderous Baritones to try ........ 😱

Sound advice. Mouthpiece GAS is probably the worst. You end up with a box of things that weren't cheap, that you never use. I went through it a bit just trying to get the full standard range comfortably on my first soprano. Turns out it just needed fixing. Oh well.

I'm doing the same with trumpet and cornet mouthpieces for the same reason - I want to get more range (or to put it another way; I'm crap at it). Those really can have a drastically different sound, but it's just down to physics, of course. Nothing mysterious. A bucket makes a different noise than a thimble etc.

I have a little box of clarinet mouthpieces too - most of them will never get played again, at least not by me. I classify them as "ones that tend to squeak a lot" and "ones that don't do it so much". I prefer the second kind, but really, I could have settled for any one of those and just got used to it.

My main form of it is a bit different - not too many saxes, but pretty much one of every type of woodwind instrument and small to medium sized brass instrument that I could reasonably afford. I'm aware I now own so many I can't possibly hope to learn to play them all even half decently, but they do at least all get used.

I was deprived of a decent music education as a child. Seriously, I was. So, now I'm overcompensating. It passes the time though 🙂
 
Sound advice. Mouthpiece GAS is probably the worst. You end up with a box of things that weren't cheap, that you never use. 🙂

That`s what the Yardsale is for .. they can be hard to shift unless given away though

I haven't had MP GAS yet, but still have a drawer full of the things!
...

you`re a different case - you get them thrown in with horns so end up with them that way (best way IMO) . I`ve had a couple like that , they can offset the price of the horn and be a nice "easter-egg" when you open the case

Is the Martin better than the Conn @ProfJames ? , what was the difference in the comparison ? . out of the Oldies I`ve only played a Buescher
 
Last edited:
I see, yes. I hadn't considered mouthpieces included with instruments.

Have I posted the Matt Stohrer Conn C Melody link yet? I can't remember. His opinion was that the later straight neck Conns were among the best, but then that doesn't mean there aren't others just as good - and tenor players might prefer the tenor style crook, I suppose, subject to the ergonomics problems Richard mentioned with his.

Anyway - good video, I thought:

 
That`s what the Yardsale is for .. they can be hard to shift unless given away though

I'll give it some thought. I'm a hoarder, not a seller though. If there's some remote chance I might need or be able to use something again, my natural tendency is to hold on to it...

Maybe some terrible new rubber eating strain of bacteria will destroy the ones I actually use, and I'll need to dig out one of the plastic ones. You just never know 🙂
 
I used to be a hoarder - in the past year, I`ve given it up and spent that time clearing out big time , I`m lean and mean in house as well as stature now 😀 .. it`s very liberating to be free of all the clutter .

I own three Horns -- Tenor (High end) , Alto (lower midprice) and Sop (Ultra budget) and have ONE main Tenor Mp (Yani) and one cheaper backup (Sharpkbite), one Highend Alto Mp (LAW) and a 4C as a desperate backup and one Sop Mp period (Selmer HR) , that`s it ..

I`m getting down to one Clarinet, a B12 .... still got to sort out the bits of Buffet so watch the yard sale for a cheap Clari - not as cheap as the HR one I sold Jules but it`ll be a good buy ..

One guitar (Lp Std) one Bass (Streamer $$)

Two Squeezeboxes (one good melodeon, one mega cheapo)

and even cut back on Synths - one Workstation rompler thing, one Virtual Analog Polysynth and one real Analog Monosynth .

That`s it !! .................. no room for a C-Melody or a Baritone in this regime , maybe another Alto (JK or SA80-II is most likely now) otherwise the only other thing on the cards is to upgrade the Venus straight sop to something lower-Mid - a Bauhaus or Elkhart Deluxe (non Bronze) straight (Max £200) , I wish Yamaha did a 280 Sop, the 475-II was way too much money tied up
 
That`s what the Yardsale is for .. they can be hard to shift unless given away though



you`re a different case - you get them thrown in with horns so end up with them that way (best way IMO) . I`ve had a couple like that , they can offset the price of the horn and be a nice "easter-egg" when you open the case

Is the Martin better than the Conn @ProfJames ? , what was the difference in the comparison ? . out of the Oldies I`ve only played a Buescher
I haven't tried a Conn/Buescher. I have never heard people knocking Martin horns which is why I have owned several over the last few years and indeed, why I am buying more! They are so consistent, smokey sound, big bottom end and ergonomically right for me. I have tried Conn altos and they don't do it for me. Just preference I think Ads!
 
So the Martin may not be better than the Conn then ......
C Melodies are funny beasts , they`ve got to be taken on a per-horn basis rather than a per-maker, even if you don`t favour the maker of the horn you`re offered.
 
So the Martin may not be better than the Conn then ......
C Melodies are funny beasts , they`ve got to be taken on a per-horn basis rather than a per-maker, even if you don`t favour the maker of the horn you`re offered.
That is the way with all horns I believe Ads. I just favour Martins through experience and personal taste
 
So the Martin may not be better than the Conn then .......

I bought a frosty silver Conn C -melody -27-28 w straight neck and gold inside bell. A nice one in mint condition with "new" Conn Res-O-Pads. I hate the sound of a C melody. I just wanted the best collector sax that could get. There were no goldplated availalbe when I bought mine. A keeper! I got it for nearly no money at all back in the early 80's. A friend use to borrow my c melody. He is into old dance music from the 20's. And he get paid for playing c- melody!!!
 
I haven't tried a Conn/Buescher. I have never heard people knocking Martin horns which is why I have owned several over the last few years and indeed, why I am buying more! They are so consistent, smokey sound, big bottom end and ergonomically right for me. I have tried Conn altos and they don't do it for me. Just preference I think Ads!
Did you watch Matt Stohrer's video? He seems to be saying the straight neck Conn alto is the best of the C-Mels, and that's a lovely one he's showing.

This is the only photo of the one for sale I've seen so far...

YI502MBE8_2c994a19-6d99-420c-8b0c-c87d41314015_large.webp
 
I have my eye on a bari as well!!! Have you bought the C mel David?
Bari Prof?
Can I interest you in a Martin Bari?
...a Martin Typewriter Bari indeed?...
For sale now in an EU country near you.

I'll have yer bancrupt in no time... ha ha ha ha ha ha ha !!!
$_85-10.webp


What... too old you say?
Well how about a 50's Martin "The Martin Baritone"?...
For sale now in an EU country near you.

$_85-11.webp


...apologies for this interruption to C-Mel chat, but the Prof had to know!
 
Last edited:
It will have to be something special! The Martin Typewriter alto is an awkward cuss anyway let alone a bari. Send me details so I can look but it would have to go some way to deflect me!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,458
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom