Saxophones Baritone decision

johnw

Member
Messages
141
Location
Lichfield
I have a chance to swap my Selmer low A mark 6 baritone ( 1968 ) with a nice yamaha 62 baritone which is tempting me and asking for views re the pros and cons.

I have played the selmer for about 20 yrs so very used to it .

My thoughts are that the yamaha is a bit heavier and the ergonomics not quite as slick; soundwise the yamaha is immediate response and bigger ( i think ? ) plus different sound quality.

Thanks for your thoughts
 
Ok. Could do with some input of specific baritone players at this point. Β£6k seems low, but perhaps that’s what Bari’s fetch.
 
soundwise the yamaha is immediate response and bigger ( i think ? ) plus different sound quality.
I would agree with that I have owned a MKVI low and test played Yamahas and my choice would definitely be the Yamaha.

Β£6k seems low, but perhaps that’s what Bari’s fetch.
For a long time baris (and sopranos) did not get the same kind of overpriced hype that the tenors have had, but I think they may be swinging towards that these days.
 
I played a low A VI bari in college jazz band and have a buddy who bought a pristine example some years ago. They're at the top of the line. I've never been a Yamaha fan, but do try out their baritone saxophones when I can at Symposiums over the years. Like the OP, I don't like their ergonomics as they seem to squeeze my fingers into places they don't fit (I do have rather large hands though). I understand selling or trading down when you need the money and that's the only reason I'd do this swap. Plus six grand for a low A VI is a rather lowball figure in my view unless it's been poorly refinished.
 
Β£6K = $8K US. Is that still a low figure?
Forgive me for missing the difference. $8K U.S. is definitely in the ballpark. I believe my buddy paid more than ten grand for his, but it was pristine.

I had a lot of high dollar horns at one time. A few vintage Selmers and such. On a whim some years ago I picked up a Buescher True Tone alto for a couple hundred bucks and within a few months realized I'd never need my SBA alto ever again. So off it went. Same with a VI soprano that just killed my right thumb. I'd rather play my vintage curved Buescher soprano, even keyed only up to Eb3. So off it went along with the VI sopranino I never played. I also sold a cherry, silver plated 10M that seemed to impress everyone but me. So I'm not for keeping a horn just because it's valuable or revered by others; especially when you find a more frugal alternative. However, that frugal alternative needs to work for you with absolutely no regrets. You have to prefer it in every way. Unless you really need the money. And I say that given that I sold horns I wasn't using right around the time of my divorce. I definitely needed the money, but I could live with the consequences. With no regret. I don't miss any horn I've ever sold.
 
The money isnt an issue for me its really how it plays- sound-ergonomics and suitability for big band playing which is my main outlet
I think only you can answer those questions. Both are incredible horns, and everyone has their own personal preferences. If it were me, I'd keep the VI. In my mind, the lineage of Selmer goes all the way back to Adolph Sax, and most of the masters of the 20th century I listened to and emulated played VI's. So that sound is embedded in my brain and remains my ideal. I've played many Yamahas, and they're great, but they don't have the history or lineage or sound which is important to me.

Sounds like you already have your answer, from your other posts:
- Ergos: Yamaha heavy, not as slick
- Sound: Yamaha bigger/different
- Suitable for big band: most of the big band greats played VI's

Why play a copy when you already have the original?
 
If it were me, I'd keep the VI. In my mind, the lineage of Selmer goes all the way back to Adolph Sax, and most of the masters of the 20th century I listened to and emulated played VI's. So that sound is embedded in my brain and remains my ideal. I've played many Yamahas, and they're great, but they don't have the history or lineage or sound which is important to me.
The sax is the brush that we paint the music canvas with. Every artist is different. The most important thing is one is happy with their decision in choice of bari. The rest are the colours and brush strokes they use in painting that canvas.

I don't have either Yamaha nor the Selmer, but am content with my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito low Bb and my 2014 Antigua Winds BS3220LQ low A.

I wish @johnw true wisdom and confidence in making his selection, that he be happy with his choice, whether he opts for the Yamaha or keeps his VI.
 
I wish @johnw true wisdom and confidence in making his selection, that he be happy with his choice, whether he opts for the Yamaha or keeps his VI.
Me too. I think the important thing is not to let the MKVI label influence any decision. The tenors were great, the altos were great. The sopranos and baritones were OK but I don't even think the sopranos labelled as MKVI were even developed beyond the older models from the 30s just got a MKVI "badge".

The baritones (in my experience) were nothing special. Didn't have the beefy sound of the Conns, Martins or Bueschers of that time. And when compared to Yamahas and Yanagisawas do not cut it unlike the MKVI (and BA/SBA) tenors and altos that in most cases do have something special.
 
... but I don't even think the sopranos labelled as MKVI were even developed beyond the older models from the 30s just got a MKVI "badge".
My VI soprano had the high F#, which Selmer wasn't doing in the 30's. But hey, I figure the best sopranos were made in the 1920's, so an early design is no stigma for me. With an open mouthpiece, my VI soprano sang. I'd have kept it, but for the pain I developed holding it (right thumb). Then again... it was an original factory black lacquered model (as was the sopranino), so the cash was rather nice.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom