Tech/maintenance Bare brass/ raw finishes

succumbed, disassembled my Mark VI, stuck it in a giant pot of boilng water, and removed all the lacquer.

I can’t say I regret it, but I’ll never do anything like that again.
Well someone I knew round about 25 years ago took a packet of wire wool to his MKVI hoping it would make him sound like Branford Marsalis.

Guess what?
 
Last edited:
Brass - aka various shades of yellow(ish).
Well, no. Because they use some sort of patina chemical to darken it. It's only brass coloured where the patina finish has worn off. It's the finish that is particularly the problem.
I've managed to wash the keys - one at a time, drying with a towel straight after. Then tackling remaining calcium carbonate with some meths rubbed on. Tried isopropyl alcohol too. Both a bit slow.
Tried the old lemon juice mix which works well but a bit ran and caused a streak on the body. You have to be very slow and steady with just a little on a cloth. And yes, it does seem to discolour certain areas. So it's just a pain in the backside to deal with.
 
Well, no. Because they use some sort of patina chemical to darken it. It's only brass coloured where the patina finish has worn off. It's the finish that is particularly the problem.
I've managed to wash the keys - one at a time, drying with a towel straight after. Then tackling remaining calcium carbonate with some meths rubbed on. Tried isopropyl alcohol too. Both a bit slow.
Tried the old lemon juice mix which works well but a bit ran and caused a streak on the body. You have to be very slow and steady with just a little on a cloth. And yes, it does seem to discolour certain areas. So it's just a pain in the backside to deal with.
Once the verdigis has formed the finish has gone. It's just a top layer (which can wear off) which is easily removed. The XS model is the same horn - after someone's taken the ol' wire wool to it.
If you want to apply an acid selectively you'll have to thicken the solution. Starch works quite well (instant mash!) or KY jelly.

It's a complete pain to deal with, I agree - but it's exacerbated by the dark (factory) patina. If you make the client aware that there will be a cosmetic change you shouldn't have any problems...and (so far) all of my clients seem to be happy that the horn isn't green any more.
 
Because they use some sort of patina chemical to darken it.
It is a wax finish on the RAW.

From the Trevor James website


"Why is the 'RAW' darker than the XS version?​

Distinguishing the 'RAW' from the 'RAW XS' models lies primarily in their finishing details. The 'RAW' model is enriched by a wax finish applied to both the body and mechanism, enhancing the inherent charm of the raw material with an instant aged appearance. On the other hand, the 'XS' model foregoes the wax finish and undergoes meticulous hand buffing within our saxophone workshops, resulting in a sleek and pristine aesthetic."



Just to make it clear, I don't buy into the unlacquered finishing making a difference to the sound, I have horns in most of the popular finishes but this was the only finish available at the time of my purchase, I loved the way this horn played and bought it with that reason only.
 
Just to make it clear, I don't buy into the unlacquered finishing making a difference to the sound,
I remember many years back I played a P.Mauriat unlacquered, I think it was something like a 66 UL. I really liked and asked if I could get a custom one but have it lacquered. It would have been a lacquered unlacquered tenor.
 
I remember many years back I played a P.Mauriat unlacquered, I think it was something like a 66 UL. I really liked and asked if I could get a custom one but have it lacquered. It would have been a lacquered unlacquered tenor.
I had one of the early P Mauriat system 76's with that fake vintage look, the horn played well but I never really liked that finish.
 
I had one of the early P Mauriat system 76's with that fake vintage look, the horn played well but I never really liked that finish.
From what I remember this one was not a fake vintage look, just unlaquered. I don't like the fake vintage look either.
 
The 'RAW' model is enriched by a wax finish applied to both the body and mechanism, enhancing the inherent charm of the raw material with an instant aged appearance.
I doubt it's a wax finish in the traditional sense, otherwise it'd come off with the application of heat or a suitable solvent. It's possible that a wax finish is applied which contains a patination chemical, but that seems a bit unlikely.
 
I doubt it's a wax finish in the traditional sense, otherwise it'd come off with the application of heat or a suitable solvent. It's possible that a wax finish is applied which contains a patination chemical, but that seems a bit unlikely.
You would have more knowledge regarding this than me Stephen, the quote was from their website and if I remember right I was told the same from the shop I bought mine from, in all probability I would have bought the XS version had it have been available at the time, but have no regrets its a great horn and still love mine 13 years on.
 
You would have more knowledge regarding this than me Stephen, the quote was from their website and if I remember right I was told the same from the shop I bought mine from, in all probability I would have bought the XS version had it have been available at the time, but have no regrets its a great horn and still love mine 13 years on.
I suspect it might be a case of something being lost in translation.

Still loving mine too - even though I'd have bought a lacquered version had it been available at the time.
 
I'm not sure what it is they use but I doubt it is the wax that turns it that dark colour. They may wax it with something like Rennaissance Wax afterwards, but there doesn't seem much evidence of it being there.
Anyway, here's what it looks like after a lot of rubbing. Not perfect,. but a lot better than it was!

BTW has yours got an insert in the F palm tonehole? I don't remember seeing that in other TJ Raws.

IMG_0421.webp

IMG_0423.webp
 
I don't think mine has an insert. I'll have to go look. And I don't recall seeing one on any of the RAWs I've done recently.
Aftermarket add-on?
 
Aftermarket add-on?
I may be imagining it but I very vaguely recall something about TJ saying that some MKVI owners finding the tuning different, ie the Raw was bang in tune and as they'd been compensating on their MKVI that TJ tech (Dave Farley?) did some kind of custom fettling.
 
I may be imagining it but I very vaguely recall something about TJ saying that some MKVI owners finding the tuning different, ie the Raw was bang in tune and as they'd been compensating on their MKVI that TJ tech (Dave Farley?) did some kind of custom fettling.
I guess that's a possibility. I can't say I've ever noticed a tuning problem on the top F myself.
 
I guess that's a possibility. I can't say I've ever noticed a tuning problem on the top F myself.
No it’s the MKVI that has the tuning problem hence the idea of a mod to make it like the MKVI for players used to it like that. I can’t imagine I would have made that up but I know it sounds far fetched.
 
No it’s the MKVI that has the tuning problem hence the idea of a mod to make it like the MKVI for players used to it like that. I can’t imagine I would have made that up but I know it sounds far fetched.
It's not an unreasonable assumption. There are horns out there that I struggle to play in tune, though plenty of other players don't. I guess it's what you get used to.
 
I hate working on these modern 'bare brass' finishes. Typically they have some kind of patina chemical to darken the brass. If you wash the sax this can dissolve the chemical a bit and if you have any drips or runs this can result in marks or streaks forming.
Also the bare metal often gets hard green deposits I'm guessing is calcium carbonate and/ or verdi gris. If you use anything too aggressive it can remove the patina finish too.

Has anyone found any effective method of cleaning these things without causing more problems?

The current victim on the bench is a Trevor James Raw.
View attachment 26817View attachment 26818
Don't fight it... my 12 year old RAW looks like this, plays pretty well tho. You can't win with this, just enjoy how it sounds
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,444
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom