Tech/maintenance Bare brass/ raw finishes

All good and well, but the OP is a repairer requesting ideas as to how to deal with a client's horn. I doubt that "I've scrubbed it with wire wool and sprayed it with lacquer" is gonna cut much mustard with his customer...no matter how reasonable it appears to be to you.
IMG_20240903_122609077.webp

Clean it up and then clear coat it
 
Frankly on a deal like this I'd leave it all green and sticky. If customer wants it made not green, you can educate them on the basics of brass oxidation and let them decide - leave green? Steel wool and leave? Polish and spray lacquer like it should've been done in the first place? Clean and send for silver plating?
 
Don't fight it... my 12 year old RAW looks like this, plays pretty well tho. You can't win with this, just enjoy how it sounds
Don't fight it... my 12 year old RAW looks like this, plays pretty well tho. You can't win with this, just enjoy how it sounds
I accept that my Martin Handcraft (Committee) is almost bare brass. Less than 10% of the gold lacquer remains. But I try to keep the outside of the sax as clean as I can without disassemble the keys. A bare brass sax needs more care than a lacquered or plated sax.
 
The TJ Signature Custom Raw is the one with the name that features in all the reviews -I'm not sure people are aware that you can buy the same horn in lacquer finish. Especially when TJ have reused the Signature Custom name several times over for different ranges of instruments.

I think anyone who owns one of these (or similar needs to be accept that any work on the instrument may leave a 'clean patch' on the metal. What about the matte lacquer finishes that seem to flake very easily over time?

'Relic' treatment of musical instruments by making them appear used and road worn seems to be a popular trend that's here to stay. It doesn't appeal to me personally, but each to their own.
 
Of course and the myth about lacquer killing the tone is, unfortunately, ubiquitous.
My own tenor is TJ Signature in silver which was originally lacquered over the silver plate. TJ seem to have iussue with finishes and with this one the laquer kept flaking off. I got fed up with it and ended up removing it all. No change in sound.
The bare silver tends to be a bit of a pain as it tarnishes easily and needs a bit of a spruce up. TJ use very thin plating so if yoiu polish it there's often bits that go through to the copper plating underneath. So I've patched the plating up and tried to leave it, but during a covid lock-down I thought I'd try lacquering it and bought some stuff that was supposed to be superior lacquer. It wasn't applying very well and I ended up putting on a few coats. Once back together the sax sounded a bit deader - it'd lost a bit of the upper partials. And the lacquer started flaking off again. This was supposed to be tough stuff that you could buff up, but it flaked quite easily. After a while I got fed up with it rubbed the stuff off. Put it all back together again - and the sound of the sax was back.
So , if it wasn't the lacquer, I'm not sure what else could have altered the sound. But maybe - when the lacquer is thick enough - it can slightly alter things? I wouldn't think it would matter ordinarily.
 
The TJ Signature Custom Raw is the one with the name that features in all the reviews -I'm not sure people are aware that you can buy the same horn in lacquer finish. Especially when TJ have reused the Signature Custom name several times over for different ranges of instruments.
I think you are right, but most of the stockist's of these only buy these in the RAW or RAW XS.
I would hope/think that most players would buy a new horn using their ears rather than their eyes and of course the ergo's have to be right too, I actually don't mind the look, it doesn't take any more care than any of my other saxes, my preferred finish is the cognac lacquer ie dark gold but as long as it plays well then I'm a happy player.
20/25 years ago I went up to see Stuart at Woodwind Exchange to buy a Mark VI, I tested about 15 Mark VI horns of different years and different finishes, I ended up much to my wife's disgust with one which had got about 15% lacquer left that didn't look the best but sounded great to my ears, no one really cares what your sax looks like when you are on a gig, it's the sound you make that they are there for.
 
Last edited:
I think you are right, but most of the stockist's of these only buy these in the RAW or RAW XS.
I would hope/think that most players would buy a new horn using their ears rather than their eyes and of course the ergo's have to be right too, I actually don't mind the look, it doesn't take any more care than any of my other saxes, my preferred finish is the cognac lacquer ie dark gold but as long as it plays well then I'm a happy player.
20/25 years ago I went up to see Stuart at Woodwind Exchange to buy a Mark VI, I tested about 15 Mark VI horns of different years and different finishes, I ended up much to my wife's disgust with one which had got about 15% lacquer left that didn't look the best but sounded great to my ears, no one really cares what your sax looks like when you are on a gig, it's the sound you make that they are there for.
I wanted rose brass purely for aesthetics. But it would have cost £700 more and would have had to order, I ended up buying a normal brass lacquered one, which was hard to find someone that had one in stock.
 
Unless you're blindfolded your eyes are going to contribute to your decision.

And they won't care much about that either.
At least with the RAW at the time I bought mine there was only 2 decisions, you either bought that finish or you didn't.

At some gigs you do wonder how many would be there if there was no beer to drink.

I always sound better after the listener has had a few pints.
 
At least with the RAW at the time I bought mine there was only 2 decisions, you either bought that finish or you didn't.

At some gigs you do wonder how many would be there if there was no beer to drink.

I always sound better after the listener has had a few pints.
We always tell that to our audience: "The more you drink, the better we sound"
 
My own tenor is TJ Signature in silver which was originally lacquered over the silver plate. TJ seem to have iussue with finishes and with this one the laquer kept flaking off. I got fed up with it and ended up removing it all. No change in sound.
The bare silver tends to be a bit of a pain as it tarnishes easily and needs a bit of a spruce up. TJ use very thin plating so if yoiu polish it there's often bits that go through to the copper plating underneath. So I've patched the plating up and tried to leave it, but during a covid lock-down I thought I'd try lacquering it and bought some stuff that was supposed to be superior lacquer. It wasn't applying very well and I ended up putting on a few coats. Once back together the sax sounded a bit deader - it'd lost a bit of the upper partials. And the lacquer started flaking off again. This was supposed to be tough stuff that you could buff up, but it flaked quite easily. After a while I got fed up with it rubbed the stuff off. Put it all back together again - and the sound of the sax was back.
So , if it wasn't the lacquer, I'm not sure what else could have altered the sound. But maybe - when the lacquer is thick enough - it can slightly alter things? I wouldn't think it would matter ordinarily.
I did a strip-down - relacquer on a Buescher Aristocrat series 1 alto and it definitely sounded different afterwards. The work was purely esthetic, replacing cracked pads with fresh ones, leveling those sawtooth tone holes, freeing up stuck keys that used to hang in mid-air. But boy, that lacquer made a difference! And it was spray-on shellac from HomeDepot - highly recommended for this kind of work!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,443
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom