Tech/maintenance Bare brass/ raw finishes

no one really cares what your sax looks like when you are on a gig
I’ve known bandleaders that DO care. They only hired players with shiny horns, who dressed well. Society gigs, mostly.

It used to be common to get your horn relacquered every few years, because people did care how they looked. In some ways, I’m glad those days are gone, and in some ways I long for them to return.

Of course, my working horns are pretty spotty. I did live on a boat in a marina for a while; if you want a bare brass horn, a year on a boat in a salt water marina is just the ticket.
 
I’ve known bandleaders that DO care. They only hired players with shiny horns, who dressed well. Society gigs, mostly.

It used to be common to get your horn relacquered every few years, because people did care how they looked. In some ways, I’m glad those days are gone, and in some ways I long for them to return.

Of course, my working horns are pretty spotty. I did live on a boat in a marina for a while; if you want a bare brass horn, a year on a boat in a salt water marina is just the ticket.
A student of mine once remarked that my mk6 looked like it had been dug up.
 
I’ve known bandleaders that DO care. They only hired players with shiny horns, who dressed well. Society gigs, mostly.

It used to be common to get your horn relacquered every few years, because people did care how they looked. In some ways, I’m glad those days are gone, and in some ways I long for them to return.

Of course, my working horns are pretty spotty. I did live on a boat in a marina for a while; if you want a bare brass horn, a year on a boat in a salt water marina is just the ticket.
It used to be that brass players always had their horns re lacquered and hated having a dull horn.
 
I remember a long time ago I was playing one of those Society gigs, the bandleader or musical director insisted that we all had to get suited up and play with shiny horns, then he booked a top draw sax player to join us who turned up in chinos and a shirt and had the scruffiest Selmer tenor, most of us saw the funny side but not the MD.
 
I did a strip-down - relacquer on a Buescher Aristocrat series 1 alto and it definitely sounded different afterwards. The work was purely esthetic, replacing cracked pads with fresh ones, leveling those sawtooth tone holes, freeing up stuck keys that used to hang in mid-air. But boy, that lacquer made a difference! And it was spray-on shellac from HomeDepot - highly recommended for this kind of work!
The lacquer thickness must make a difference. Take it to extremes and make it 10mm thick and I'm sure it'll sound different.
 
The lacquer thickness must make a difference. Take it to extremes and make it 10mm thick and I'm sure it'll sound different.
I think the amount of lacquer manufactures put on is not going to make any difference to the sound, they make unlacquered saxes because there is a market for them.
The problem you have is that if you have a lacquered sax and a unlacquer sax of the same manufacture and model they may sound different in the same way as if you have 4 RAW unlacquered saxes that will sound different from each other, I have tried other RAW saxes that didn't sound like mine.
 
I did a strip-down - relacquer on a Buescher Aristocrat series 1 alto and it definitely sounded different afterwards. The work was purely esthetic, replacing cracked pads with fresh ones, leveling those sawtooth tone holes, freeing up stuck keys that used to hang in mid-air. But boy, that lacquer made a difference! And it was spray-on shellac from HomeDepot - highly recommended for this kind of work!
Changing pads and altering toneholes will have an affect on the sound. I didn't do any of that as the horn was otherwise OK. As I said, there was no difference between ordinary lacquer and unlacquered. But when I did several layers the sound was different - and there were no new pads, tonehole alterations, spring adjustments etc. Nothing else different.
 
Last edited:
Somebody recently asked me if mine was one of those horns you're supposed to get down on your knees and pray to. I'd never thought of it but told him he should. It's a 50's Super 20 that hasn't seen any lacquer in a long time except the odd bit that for some reason still sticks to some of the pearls.
 
Changing pads and altering toneholes will have an affect on the sound. I didn't do any of that as the horn was otherwise OK. As I said, there was no difference between ordinary lacquer and unlacquered. But when I did several layers the sound was different - and there were no new pads, tonehole alterations, spring adjustments etc. Nothing else different.
I have to take your statement at face value, even though I am very skeptical. But that's the never-ending discussion on this topic, based on anecdotal evidence this way or the other.
 
I have to take your statement at face value, even though I am very skeptical. But that's the never-ending discussion on this topic, based on anecdotal evidence this way or the other.
Steve's a professional repairer of many years standing - and not one given to making extravagent claims. If he says he noted a difference then he very probably did.
Quite why is up for debate - but I'll pitch my guess at lacquer on the tonehole rims. Which'll stand for a long as it's unknown as to whether the rims were dressed after the lacquer was applied?
 
Steve's a professional repairer of many years standing - and not one given to making extravagent claims. If he says he noted a difference then he very probably did.
Quite why is up for debate - but I'll pitch my guess at lacquer on the tonehole rims. Which'll stand for a long as it's unknown as to whether the rims were dressed after the lacquer was applied?
Exactly my thought. Or else some minor changes in the sealing after disassembly - reassembly. Especially @Steve Marshall being a professional, I wager he cleaned the pads before re-assembly. And I know for sure that alone can make a big difference.

But it's all academic.

And the $65,000 question is: Was it better or worse?
 
Exactly my thought. Or else some minor changes in the sealing after disassembly - reassembly. Especially @Steve Marshall being a professional, I wager he cleaned the pads before re-assembly. And I know for sure that alone can make a big difference.

But it's all academic.

And the $65,000 question is: Was it better or worse?

Duh. You've been around long enough to know that any difference is always better. :optimistic:
 
Pads didn't really need cleaning. Horn was fine. As I said, it was something to do during lock-down.
I don't think I dressed the toneholes, but I'm not convinced that would make a great difference.
To me the sound wasn't better, it had less upper partials so sounded a little softer.
I know it's anecdotal and a sample of 1, so doesn't really count, but something that makes me think.
Wilfried Kausel did some experiments with a French horn entirely encased in a foam box and said there was a difference in sound. I have some concerns about the box shape, but still.
Different metals are essentially the same so far as wind instruments are concerned. There is some vibration in the metal but it'll be pretty much the same miniscule occurance. A thin coat of lacquer isn't going to change things. (Wilfried Kausel was invovled in those flute experiments with 7 different metals.)
I've done all the experiments with Blutack stuck on the horn and found no difference whatsoever. I've tried all the LeFreques, Klangbogen, and other 'sound enhancers' and found no real difference. Occassionally I think your embouchure falls slighty differently and produces a small change, but if you keep trying you can get your old sound back. I don't believe in that stuff and just try it out of 'scientific curiosity'
In this case with the lacquer, I couldn't get the usual sound back. Once the lacquer was off it was there again, back to normal.
So, yes, I'm agreeing that this stuff doesn't matter normally, but my lacquer job did something to sound. I didn't expect it to make any difference.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,443
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom