Playing the saxophone Advice Needed

DerekG

Member
Messages
9
Location
Edinburgh
Hi All

My first Post and a little bit about my Tenor Saxophone experience.

I purchased a Montreaux Student Tenor Saxophone in 1988 and due to various commitments over the years, I have only recently started teaching myself again with good progress achieved.

I have the original Rico Royal C5 mouthpiece, the original ligature, which is showing severe signs of distress and the reeds I am using are mainly Rico Royal 2 (French File Cut), but have started using Rico Hemke 2 1/2. more recently.

My intention is to upgrade my Saxophone in about a years time, however, I want to find out if the initial investments in the aforementioned would make a difference to my learning and crucially, my playing.

I find it reasonably easy to reach all notes, however, the lowest B takes a little effort
 
Hmmm,
Welcome.
Fundamentally there shouldn't be anything wrong with a Rico C5.
But if you could elaborate on signs of distress it would help to understand. Or is that just the ligature?
Also there will be better mouthpieces about that could well make things easier for you and even the placebo effect could result in genuine improvements.

So it depends on your take on the size of the investment.
Struggling down around low B & Bb could be your stage of development, a leak in the horn, the reed choice for your stage or a mouthpiece that is not suited to you. Truth be known in early stages its likely to be a combination of those.
If the distress is to do with the tip, the rails or the table and you want to change then that would be enough of a trigger for me to do so.

Mouthpieces aren't cheap but in the lower end of the price range from some reputable makes there are good pieces.
Your ultimate goal is about finding a piece that helps you blow top to bottom as easily and even as you can find with a basic tone that you like.

Even though you have not said that in your post I'm guessing the Rico C5 is not one that you feel this way about.
 
Hmmm,
Welcome.
Fundamentally there shouldn't be anything wrong with a Rico C5.
But if you could elaborate on signs of distress it would help to understand.
Also there will be better mouthpieces about that could well make things easier for you and even the placebo effect could result in genuine improvements.

So it depends on your take on the size of the investment.
Struggling down around low B & Bb could be your stage of development, a leak in the horn, the reed choice for your stage or a mouthpiece that is not suited to you. Truth be known in early stages its likely to be a combination of those.
If the distress is to do with the tip, the rails or the table and you want to change then that would be enough of a trigger for me to do so.

Mouthpieces aren't cheap but in the lower end of the price range from some reputable makes there are good pieces.
Your ultimate goal is about finding a piece that helps you blow top to bottom as easily and even as you can find with a basic tone that you like.

Even though you have not said that in your post I'm guessing the Rico C5 is not one that you feel this way about.
Thank You, its given me an idea of how to go forward
 
Back in the ‘80’s certain “student” instruments tended to have one or two traits:

Poor instrument/poor mouthpiece or;
Poor mouthpiece

A poor/v cheap mouthpiece was a way of saving money. I don’t know about the RICO mouthpiece but I’d say that it was no match for a Yamaha - they have always been cheap, but they really are exceptional for the money. It’s a cheap way to test your horn, and still a good mouthpiece to be on should you upgrade your horn.

Frankly though, at this stage if your horn is airtight and plays properly without leaks then an upgrade will most likely make little difference to your playing. I’m sure that the mouthpiece upgrade would though.

You might try and find someone who can play-test your horn for potential leaks.
 
Right around the lower end costs you will get many recommendations for Yamaha 5C, 6C etc. These are plastic and durable unless dropped.

The next rung of the ladder in Hard Rubber
D'addario Select Jazz
Jody Jazz HR*

Just food for thought.
Thank you for your advice and I am currently looking into your recommendations.
 
Back in the ‘80’s certain “student” instruments tended to have one or two traits:

Poor instrument/poor mouthpiece or;
Poor mouthpiece

A poor/v cheap mouthpiece was a way of saving money. I don’t know about the RICO mouthpiece but I’d say that it was no match for a Yamaha - they have always been cheap, but they really are exceptional for the money. It’s a cheap way to test your horn, and still a good mouthpiece to be on should you upgrade your horn.

Frankly though, at this stage if your horn is airtight and plays properly without leaks then an upgrade will most likely make little difference to your playing. I’m sure that the mouthpiece upgrade would though.

You might try and find someone who can play-test your horn for potential leaks.
Thank you, great advice on both. My plans are to continue with my current sax and looking to upgrade in several months time.
 
I would drop into a local music shop and try out likely candidates, I expect they can give some advice. There seem to be a few shops in Edinburgh that have a small but decent selection. Any of them would be an improvement and you'll start to get a sense of the differences. Take your time and go back another day if you're not sure.
 
I would drop into a local music shop and try out likely candidates, I expect they can give some advice. There seem to be a few shops in Edinburgh that have a small but decent selection. Any of them would be an improvement and you'll start to get a sense of the differences. Take your time and go back another day if you're not sure.
Thank You for your invaluable feedback, much appreciated.
 
I find it reasonably easy to reach all notes, however, the lowest B takes a little effort
Are you saying that low B takes effort but Bb does not? This implies you need to get your instrument checked unless you can diagnose and fix a leak yourself. (Always a goos skill to learn)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom