Beginner Saxes Yamaha YTS280 v Trevor James EVO (Tenor)

Thanks cappers, it sounds like you are on the same journey that I'm hoping for. Learning for the fun of it and the love of the Instrument. No drama, no pressure just have fun and hope that along the way it starts to sound less awful.
 
Ther are many good saxes and Yamaha rules. They use to be considered to be the best saxes to start on. But most aspiring saxplayers starts on other brands!!

I think your love for the tenor sax is a good start. And you also know how your tenor should sound.

Teacher? An openminded teacher/saxplayer who listen to you and your wishes is the thing. I'm more or less self-taught. As self-taught I'm glad I was soo open-minded and understanding when I wanted to sound and play like sax heroes.😉

Just one more thing. Yamaha student mouthpieces are terrible if you prefer the dark, fat and smokey tenor sound.

Have a pleasent and fun sax journey.
 
Interesting about the Yamaha student mouthpiece. Do you have any suggestions of an alternative or would it be best to start with that and move on once I've developed my breathing and embouchure
 
A new yam will come with a 4c. A new TJ, as far as I can remember, comes with a Bari. Both suitable to start with and may be all you'll ever need.

If you think which sax is a conundrum, mouthpieces can become a distracting rabbit hole and then there's reeds.
 
Totally agree on the reeds front, there's makes, cuts, thickness and then materials. Like the idea of synthetic for consistency and the ease of use but the traditionalist in me leans towards cane
 
Interesting about the Yamaha student mouthpiece. Do you have any suggestions of an alternative or would it be best to start with that and move on once I've developed my breathing and embouchure
I think a "Rico" (D'Addiario) used to be called "Gratonnite" as well, is a good mouthpice for beginners. Three differnt size of the chamber (A large, B medium, C small) and three differnt tip openings.
 
Reeds! Pha!
Like the idea of synthetic for consistency and the ease of use but the traditionalist in me leans towards cane
IMHO - and this may blow the thread up - get a Legere. I guess quite soft 2.25 or such. Ask in the shop or here (then run!). Just one less thing to worry about. I'm sure I've got 20% more practice time in having switched to synthetic.
Cane reeds will still be around in a year or so when you feel equipped to experiment with them.
 
Hi Pete, I'm trying to find the original source. I definitely saw it mentioned on a Facebook group, but it didn't go into any real detail other than it had a darker, richer sound and something about it having a greater amount of brass in it's construction.

Finding any reviews of the TJ EVO has been hard work though. Whenever I find something it invariably turns out to be the alto rather than the tenor.
Yeah, I couldn't find anything substantial either, except a couple alto reviews. Everything seems to relate to the TJ signature custom Raw tenor. I couldn't find hardly anything on the TJ SR either.... Frustrating when your only option is to travel some distance just to try out a couple options.. 🤷
 
I was all set to visit Headwind on Wednesday of this week to buy a second hand mint condition TJ SR Tenor, but it looks like it's been sold today. So in all honesty I'm not sure what I'm going to do now. Really liked the look of the SR and the price was perfect.
 
I have Yamaha. I am tempted by TJ.

It'll be a long time, if ever, before you can play musically. Never having played anything leaves me wondering why. Are you after a saxophone for the look or the cool. The noise a raw beginner makes is neither.

Perhaps a recorder would be a better place to start. Anything you learn on recorder will transfer to saxophone and give you a head start. The money investment is minimal and if you can't master it, the saxophone will be beyond you.

Tenor saxophone isn't an easy instrument to play. It takes daily practice. A few days off and your face starts to ache again and your pitching goes awol.

I'm 50 years in and still learning. If this post can put you off, you shouldn't start. It takes dedication, patience and tenacity. Saxophone is frustrating, uplifting and addictive. It's occupied my time when I had no money and earned me money when I had the time.

A saxophone is not just for Christmas. 😉
Wow!.... Just.... Wow!
That's extremely harsh to my ears Colin..
Not at all encouraging for @Bwlmog
Whether or not he ever gets to grips with it is irrelevant.... Playing any musical instrument is a personal journey and as a community we should be encouraging everyone to explore the possibilities of that journey, wherever it may or may not lead.
Frankly I find the "recorder" comment a little insulting and it wasn't aimed at me. 😳 Not cool Colin, not cool at all in my personal opinion.
And ANYONE can master a saxophone!
As a community we should be providing positive feedback for anyone on here!! after all..... We're not all here "just for Xmas" are we!
 
That all sounds a bit bleak to me.

I've always considered the sax one of the easiest instruments to play. By its nature it's very forgiving...even when it leaks like a sieve. And sure, there's a world of difference between being able to get a noise out of one and being able to stand on stage and rattle off a dazzling solo - but then there's also a world of difference between what people are content with.

I've seen many of my clients progress over the years. Some have gone from rank beginners to cutting albums and touring with big names. Others have settled into that spot where being a 'weekend warrior' suits their lifestyle. And then there are those who are happy to just noodle around.
It all boils down to two factors; the desire to do a thing and the time in which to do it. The more you have of both of those things, the better your progress is going to be. It's just a matter of finding the balance that suits the individual and then just getting on with it...and hopefully enjoying it.
Well said!! 👏👏👏
 
Thanks again everyone, to be clear the Saxophone is for me and for my own enjoyment. I have no desire to play in a band, ideally I'd like to reach a point where my wife recognises a tune and neighbours stop posting about "that racket" on Facebook.

I'm under no illusions about the challenges ahead and recognise that it's a lifetime commitment, which will undoubtedly frustrate at times. But if I don't do it now I never will, and I don't want it to be that one regret in life.
I'm excited for you too! Take no notice of some of the negative remarks here, just go for it! Start and enjoy your journey right from that first visit to headwind! You have the support of your family and that's great, take them with you on this journey. They must be excited for you too I'm sure ☺️
Whatever horn you decide on will work out just fine I'm sure, I agree with the guys on here, both are a good choice. I'm drawn to the TJ horns myself as I've heard in reviews that they lean towards the warm side which also appeals to me, so I totally relate there.
And definitely don't wait, get going with this. The sooner you start the sooner you can enjoy it.
Yes, it is frustrating at times. I've been playing for years and still get frustrated, but record yourself right from the off, then you can really see how far you've come in a few months time, there will be a difference 😉👍
 
View attachment 37669
As a 'mature' late starter with no prior musical experience, I have really enjoyed my first two years of learning to play the sax. It has been fun, frustrating yet very fulfilling and I am so glad that I started. It has become addictive and the more I develop the more I want to continue.

I know I'll never be particularly good but with daily practise, a good teacher and a mentor, I have made some progress. My tone needs a lot more work, as does my general 'musicality', but I can knock out a few tunes now, read moderately well, and have been playing in a community band since last year. I have been told I'm doing OK, and maybe in another couple of years I might be approaching 'basic competence'.

Best wishes and good luck!
Oh bravo! Well said! And thank you! 🙏👏👏😉
 
I was all set to visit Headwind on Wednesday of this week to buy a second hand mint condition TJ SR Tenor, but it looks like it's been sold today. So in all honesty I'm not sure what I'm going to do now. Really liked the look of the SR and the price was perfect.
Oh goodness, I was looking at that one too! 😳😂 And now it's sold you say! Ah well, something else will come along.
Actually, @Stephen Howard did say to me that he thought the Evo was marginally better in some areas than the SR and at the moment Sax. Co have them on black Friday at around £1200 I think? Very tempting 🤔🤔😉
 
Hi @teen37, thank you for the lovely message. I didn't let the negative comments out me off and took it as a reminder that learning the Sax is a commitment. I've always loved the sound of the Sax and have the uttermost respect for everyone that has taken that journey.

I have a tutor lined up to support me as I get to grips with the basics and learn good habits early on. I just need to find the right Sax, I'm still very much focussed on the Trevor James Tenors, but it's strange that there are so few reviews on YouTube etc for these horns with there seeming to be an overwhelming voice for the Yamaha.

I'll probably go back to Headwind this week, try a couple and make a decision, just a bit gutted that "the one" may have slipped through my fingers.

Good luck with your continued learning and thank you so much for the messages. They really mean a lot.
 
Hi @teen37, thank you for the lovely message. I didn't let the negative comments out me off and took it as a reminder that learning the Sax is a commitment. I've always loved the sound of the Sax and have the uttermost respect for everyone that has taken that journey.

I have a tutor lined up to support me as I get to grips with the basics and learn good habits early on. I just need to find the right Sax, I'm still very much focussed on the Trevor James Tenors, but it's strange that there are so few reviews on YouTube etc for these horns with there seeming to be an overwhelming voice for the Yamaha.

I'll probably go back to Headwind this week, try a couple and make a decision, just a bit gutted that "the one" may have slipped through my fingers.

Good luck with your continued learning and thank you so much for the messages. They really mean a lot.
Oh you're very welcome. ☺️ We all need help encouragement on our respective journeys. I just play for my own pleasure now too, I'm still on what's considered a student horn hence my search for an upgrade, but whatever horn you buy you will definitely make beautiful music with it I'm sure. ☺️😉
Stay positive, you will find your horn.
Don't worry too much about mouthpieces just yet. The Yamaha 4c is more than OK for a while to get you going. It's an easy blow 🤔😉☺️ which is all you need initially.
Give it 12 months then see how your journey is going and maybe look at getting your family to treat you to an Otto Link tone edge or a Jody Jazz HR*. Both give a nice warm, dark sound with a slightly harder reed. 👍
But that's the next exciting step in your journey ☺️😉
 
Oh goodness, I was looking at that one too! 😳😂 And now it's sold you say! Ah well, something else will come along.
Actually, @Stephen Howard did say to me that he thought the Evo was marginally better in some areas than the SR and at the moment Sax. Co have them on black Friday at around £1200 I think? Very tempting 🤔🤔😉
I've just joined the forum having seen your mention of the Sax Co. offer on the Evo. I bought one just last week at the discounted price of £1199 and whilst they say they are discounted because they have cosmetic faults I've yet to find a blemish on mine. I'm very pleased with it but having not played a tenor before I can't offer any opinion on it's playing quality compared to other models. It's playing ok for me with the supplied mouthpiece but I have a Jody Jazz HR on order which will be interesting.
 
Oh goodness, I was looking at that one too! 😳😂 And now it's sold you say! Ah well, something else will come along.
Actually, @Stephen Howard did say to me that he thought the Evo was marginally better in some areas than the SR and at the moment Sax. Co have them on black Friday at around £1200 I think? Very tempting 🤔🤔😉
Thanks for the heads up on Sax, I'll take a look. That's about £350 less than Headwind, which would be a fair few lessons and a sub with Tomplay.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,657
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom