Tech/maintenance Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?

Seems like an unsuitable material to make pads from then.
It's a tad concerning, for sure. If it's possible for the pad face to break down over time it rather puts a limit on the longevity of the pad. This repad's just four years old, or thereabouts.
Ethanol seems marginally better on the pad face - but I have no idea what the long-term implications might be.
 
It's a tad concerning, for sure. If it's possible for the pad face to break down over time it rather puts a limit on the longevity of the pad. This repad's just four years old, or thereabouts.
Ethanol seems marginally better on the pad face - but I have no idea what the long-term implications might be.
Wow, only 4 years old? Looking at the pictures I thought you were dealing with much older pads than that.
 
I guess there's stuff you shouldn't use on leather too BUT the pad material shouldn't just break down in normal use. Or are these only supposed to last 4yrs?
£200 per year. Less than a pound a day... bargain!
It might just be some slight surface degradation from, say, loose particles. Only time will tell.

The horn is all sorted out and feels more positive now. Still not as nice as with a set of traditional pads, but good enough.
In terms of tone it definitely has the Conn 10M thing going on, but it sounds a little muted. It's not quite as perky as others I've played - but this might be down the the characteristics of this particular horn.
It'll be interesting to see how it fares over the next few years - and, more importantly, how my adjustments hold up.
 
Re the initial topic.
150 years... Apparently we've been using fingertips on wind instruments for over 30,000 years. Our paleolithic for fathers had great techs who, obviously, knew better.
Ummm.. a pad replacement would mean new fingers
 

Why have pads had the same design for 150 years?​

I think pads changed over the years. Most of the pads have the been made of leather and the basic function is that the pad seals against the tone holes rim. I don't know if it's been like this for 150 years but at least for last 100-120 years. Three samples: 1. A thick Snap-On-Pad for Buesher snap-on system with metal back (stiff). Not to glued in. 2. A thick Kohlert white leather pad to be install with screw and washer. Very soft. Not to be glued in. 3. A thin modern pad with medium hard (not stiff or soft) back. To be glued in. Pads use to have some kind of soft material behind the leather/skin. To be picky; rivets, washer, reflectors/resonators are not a part of the pads.

Same, same ..... but different?

How the pads were installed is important .....what kind pads were installed ..... players care of the pads .... decide the playability.

An ordinary pad is doing a good job.


IMG_4878.JPG
IMG_4879.JPG
 
All I can say is that I accidentally bought a few pairs of leatherette shoes over the years (bad product description online, i.e. engineered leather or similar) and if tone holes are anywhere as sensitive as my feet, then I'd stay away from any of those synthetics, not to mention the durability which, there is no other word for it, sucks.

I've been wearing the same two pairs of boot day in and out for 30 and 50 years, respectively and they show some wear but that's the soles and heels which have been replaced a few times whereas the top leather is still in great shape.
 
Yes, dents can affect the flatness of tone holes... Is that really the norm for saxophones in their lifetime? I have been playing for 50+ years and never damaged a tone hole. Does everyone else bung up their tone holes in normal use?
You can find a lot of damaged tone holes on ebay if you want to study the subject.
 
I think your original statement was rather more than a bit of pessimism - it came across more like "I have studied this phenomenon in depth and can categorically say that...".

Yep, dents and dentwork can affect the flatness of the toneholes - but this stands true for any method of padding. You can undoubtedly build some tolerance into a new design, but there will be limits as to what it can achieve - and a corresponding effect on the feel.
As an engineer it is part of my job to be cautious of the risks of the compromises in a design. My involvement with saxophones is purely recreative. I see the saxophone as a brilliant compromise of a design full of holes.

Now is it possible to improve this house of cards by replacing it with a stronger house of cards? I don't know, but I have fun in trying.

I am not worried about the feel as it can be regulated by the thickness of the silicone ring and the type of silicone.
The fit of the new pad at a light touch must be far beyond 0.1 mm to avoid a spongy feel. I am aiming at an unmeasurable 0.01 mm.
 
@Stephen Howard - do I recall you saying not too long ago, on the topic of levelling tone holes, that the mere act of tilting a horn from horizontal to a more vertical playing position can slightly distort a tone hole which has been levelled when horizontal? This makes sense, but also means the levelling needs to be done in the final playing position or the pad needs a degree of flexibility to accommodate this flexing.

I'm not sure a hardening silicon sealant, used as the sealing material, would allow for this slight flex unless it too has the same amount of flex as the tone hole, or a leather pad, or some other material.

What's your thought on this @Woodpad ?
I just let the sealant harden in the playing position as suggested by Stephen Howard. I don't see how you can guarantee the same amount of flex as the saxophone flexes different in different positions. Just need some amount of flex without getting a spongy feeling.
 
Small change in the priorities of my pad project:

1 have fun
2 understanding the differences between rolled and straight tone holes for this method
3 ordering the first industrial made version of these pads
4 expanding to ringpads for a padless system
5 looking for a more optimal type of silicon.
 
What seems odd to me is that there's clearly a demand. From beginners being told to check for leaks when they can't get some tone or other; to pro's only allowing their favorite tech to repad etc. you'd'v thought "Guaranteed leak free" would be an appealing selling point.
Shouldn't that be a guaranteed leak free system with automatic repair function?

My saxophone buddies see the time between discovering a leak and the actual repair as a good reason to buy some extra saxophones.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,457
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom