Mouthpieces Which alto mouthpiece from this list is a Meyer-a-like?

Messages
700
Location
USA
Hello all, hoping for a bit of info. There is a local seller here who posts a list of MPs that he has. I was thinking it could be fun to arrange a play test and try a few, however I don't know much about most of the pieces on his list. I'd like to find a Meyer 5 or 6 a-like to compare against the S80 C* I play now (the only MP I've played). Anyone see something on this list that would be worth a try?

Here is the list, copied from his ad:

ALTO:
--- Bamber 6 Tip .070
--- Bay 6S-M/N Tip .082
--- Bay 9M T pd $55 Tip .090
--- Beechler S5S Tip .081
--- Beechler S6S Tip . 084
--- Brilhart Ebolin #2 Serial # 54629 Tip .072
--- Brilhart Ebolin #3 Serial # 105799 Tip .070
--- Brilhart Ebolin #3 Serial # 105799 Tip .070
--- Brilhart Ebolin #3*Serial # 129689 Tip .085 banded
--- Brilhart Ebolin #4 Serial # 164335 Tip .072
--- Brilhart Ebolin #4 no serial number Tip 78 stock
--- Brilhart Ebolin no Serial Tip .074
--- Brilhart Ebolin #5 Serial # 226515 Tip .085
--- Brilhart Ebolin #7 Serial # 9839 Tip .084
--- Brilhart Ebolin #2* on table #32304 (lg) Tip .065
--- Brilhart Tonalin 3* great neck #75469 Old font Tip 71.5
--- Brilhart Tonalin 3* great neck #75469 Old font Tip .071.5
--- Brilhart Personaline Ebolin S4 #189450 Tip .70 facing 19mm
--- Brilhart Tonalin S5 Personaline #121314 Carlsbad CA. Orig. Box
--- Bundy 3 Tip 80 Rubber – Bob Carpenter reface
--- Conn Comet 3 Tip ? Black
--- Conn Comet 3 Tip .068 Black
--- Conn Comet Orange Clear Tip .070
--- Conn Comet Yellow Clear Tip ?
--- Conn Steel Lay tip .059
--- D'Addario Jazz Select D7M Tip .084
--- Many vintage pieces from the 20's thru 40's Contact for info.
--- Ernie Northway custom M283A/8 Tip .090
--- Ernie Northway Tip 84
--- Ernie Northway NEW STOCK Bob Carpenter reface
--- Gale Hollywood 5 Script logo Tip .069
--- Goldbeck Superb metal tip .060
--- Herbert Couf 5* Artist Tip 82.5
--- King Tonalin 1920’s Tip 66
--- Lakey 6*3 Tip .086
--- MC Gregory 5A-18 Diamond logo #18298 MINT
--- MC Gregory Hollywood Masters 120 -- 5A – 20M- tip .072
--- Meyer NY USA Alto 7 Tip .085 Med Chamber
--- Meyer NY USA Alto 10 Med Tip .098
--- Meyer NY USA Alto 10 Med Chamber Tip .099
--- Otto Link Super Tone Master 7* Early Babbit (Wide) USA with cap and lig. Tip. .082
--- Otto Link Tone Edge 4* slant signature USA Florida HR. Tip .064 Facing 38mm KILLER PLAYER
--- Rico Metalite New M5 Tip 80
--- Selmer Soloist Scroll Shank Long and Short Shanks C thru E Tips --- Contact for Prices and tip openings.
--- Selmer S 80 C* Tips: .062.5, .066.5, .067, .069, .080
--- Strathon 7 tip .090 Like New adjustatone sticker
--- Strathon 7 tip .099
 
I like the D'Addario, Meyer NY 7 and Selmer Soloist D or E.

All except the Soloist will be a bit of a shock coming from a C*, but worth the effort to learn.
 
Coming froman S80 you do not wanna make too big a tip jump.

I would say stay .090 or below, the S80C* is supposedly .075ish)

Meyer 5 = .075 tip (sorta closed), Meyer 6 = .080 tip (closed side of medium but noticeably different than a 5, a modern 6 is the equivalent to a vintage 5 in Meyer).
Selmer C* is also around a .070-75 tip, so same as a Meyer 6.
Meyer 7 sounds like a nice option, .085 tip and it's a NY.

Ebolins are sorta closed-tip, so go #4 or above or you may end up with a tip more closed than your S80. Something is wrong on his characterization of the Brilhart 7 , he says .084 but vintage Brilly 7's hover around a .100 tip typically.
The Brilhart 5 may be a nice step-up for you.

The Lakey would be an interesting try, it will blow and sound quite differently than a Meyer, Brilly, Link Rubber.

The Beechlers might also be interesting for you.

The old Conns and Kings...meh....cannot say I would ever buy one of those, they are sorta "vintage case candy" kinda finds....

I also don't get is description of Selmer C* collection with a variety of different tips (???) A C* whether vintage or contemporary is gonna sit within a narrow range of tip variance - .070-.077....not .063-.080 (???) Unless the latter has been refaced,. a .080 Selmer 80 tip is gonna be a D or E in Selmer.

If you need a doorstop....buy the Metalite. They also make good endplugs when you cut the beak off...but, a bona-fide endplug is only around $4, so probably not a pennywise purchase there....
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,226
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom