Hi @annw , I haven't read all 10 pages of replies to your question. But from the first 1-2 pages, my 2 cts. is:It's a personal character thing, I guess: I don't enjoy being taught, I get more out of exploring and learning myself. Although I do get that I could be doing something wrong and could do it better with expert help. But then there is me listening, and if I am happy with the sound I am producing, is it so wrong?! If I can play a tune and others can recognise that tune; and I enjoy playing it, and they're not running away screaming or sticking their fingers in their ears, is that acceptable?! Probably is, to me, anyway 😉
I get that I would be a much better sax player if I had lessons, but I am not sure that that is the goal for me. If that makes sense!
- people who want to learn anything have different (initial) learning ambitions and different preferred learning styles
- both learning ambitions and (consequently) preferred learning styles/methods may or may not change over time
My initial 'Learning sax' story was similar to yours:
- Agd 40, I rented a sax for 3 months (on a whim) from a music store ad in the local paper. Just to see whether I could play anything on a sax. I'd played guitar for years but I'd always loved the sound of a sax.
- In the store, they asked me whether I wanted to rent an alto or tenor sax. I could only reply "what's the difference?"
; so they gave me both to try out - both with a beginners mpc and reed; I immediately preferred the feel and almost physical 'deep resonance' of the tenor so I went for that- Way back in UK primary school, I'd played a 'descant recorder' and to my amazement, the 'notes' on the basic main keys of the sax (when I'd looked them up) corresponded pretty well with my 'descant recorder' experience of 30 years previously:
- So I was delighted when - after a day or two - I could play a couple of nursery rhymes and Christmas Carols by ear (and trial and error); this continued for about a month when I gradually began to realise that - even on these simple tunes - my 'sound' wasn't anything like the 'sax sound' I'd imagined in my head.
- The music store had already given me a few contact details of 'sax tutors' and after a month or so, I called one of them up; TBH he was just what I needed! He was a good (amateur) sax player and an amateur tutor. He had no programme, no 'first things first', he just just listened to whatever I wanted to play and suggested a few simple tunes too.
- So whenever I played a tune, I'd ask "what do you think?". And he'd say something like "'Sounded good'' or 'well, if you breathed from lower down in your lungs, you'd probably sound better'. Then he's put his hands just above my waist and said "OK breathe right down into my hands"; so there was no 'theoretical' instruction on the importance of 'breath support', 'open throat', a firm but relaxed 'embouchure', etc. He was just very practical and invited me to try things out (OK, but try relaxing your shoulders a bit more, try loosening up the muscles around your mouth, etc.); I learned the 'physical basics' from him. Not as something I needed to do. But just things I could experiment with.
- My 1st sax tutor unfortunately moved away after 6 months to take up a job as a musician with the Royal Marines; his recommendation was to join a local (amateur) 'Wind Orchestra'. Just to get more experience and practice.
- So I did. I also signed up for a year's tutoring at a local music school; a very different (and often frustrating!) experience compared to my 1st tutor. My musical school tutor was classically trained sax player and (given my intention to play in a 'Wind Orchestra' initially gave me classical sax pieces to study and rehearse. Until, after a month or two, I told him that I actually wanted to learn how to to play jazz & blues. I'd already bought the study materials. He finally agreed on one condition: that I would play all notes (timing, dynamics) very precisely. At the time, I often cursed him for being so meticulous and critical! But since then, I'm very grateful to him for teaching me the importance of 'timing' and 'dynamics' in both orchestral and jazz/blues numbers!
Most of what I've learned since then has been via the cafe and by playing in Bands.
Mike
