Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

Yes, I will never be as good as you.
Well, I don't know about that, since neither of us has heard the other play.

My point is that if you want to gain command of the operations of playing the instrument, the fastest most reliable way to do that without developing bad habits, for the vast majority of people, is to take lessons from an in person instructor and practice assiduously the basic fundamentals of playing the saxophone.

I'm not saying you can't get there without doing that. In fact, on saxophone I'm pretty much 100% self-taught; I've spent decades reversing some things that I mistaught myself (when an actual instructor could have set them right immediately). But I was bullheaded and wanted to "do it my own way" - well, eventually, when I did get a good handle on the rudiments of playing the saxophone, guess what. All those things like airstream, embouchure, finger position, articulation, etc., etc., etc? I was doing them just like the books said. Because by and large, the standard way to play musical instruments works well.
 
Just gonna jump in and add on. @annw pay close attention to things like embouchure and breath support. These are the key to a good sound. And minimal pain starting out. Try to be relaxed, a lot of this stuff is unnatural feeling at first, but relaxation is important.

Try to find videos of players you admire and watch closely what they do.

If there are local musicians you like, ask them for tips. Most people love to share advice (…most…). I want to say, I admire your attitude a great deal 🙂
 
Just gonna jump in and add on. @annw pay close attention to things like embouchure and breath support. These are the key to a good sound. And minimal pain starting out. Try to be relaxed, a lot of this stuff is unnatural feeling at first, but relaxation is important.

Try to find videos of players you admire and watch closely what they do.

If there are local musicians you like, ask them for tips. Most people love to share advice (…most…). I want to say, I admire your attitude a great deal 🙂
Thank you. I will definitely work on my embouchure and breathing from the start, from what I understand both of these are required to be done properly to lay a solid foundation to being able to play.

I used to lead meditation classes and have studied breathwork, so some of my past endeavours and learning may be of use when it comes to regulating the breath 😊
 
Is a teacher the universal tool to play the saxophone? Sax teachers in USA, UK, Sweden, Denmark, Germany .... are not working in the same way.

For some persons the journey is more important than the goal! The saxophone was just a thing I did when the more important things were done. Teachers, not all, must understand that many apiring sax players just want to play for fun. Maybe to play some easy folk songs, 12- bar blues, birthdays songs .... on their saxes without being able to play in all 12 keys ...... . We maybe have to accept bad habits as well?

I remember, many years ago, when I talked with my friend about bad habits. He had visit his child's preschool and the teachers were worried how his child was holding the pen, pencil, crayon ... when she was writing and drawing. My friend took up a pencil from his pocket and did some sketches. He and his child was holding the same way. The teachers didn't knew that he was an architect and his child have seen how he was holding the pen.

If you want to be taught by a teacher ... go for it.

I worked as a teacher for 22 years. My goal, as teacher, was not to be like the teachers I had when I was young.

" Well, we busted out of class
Had to get away from those fools
We learned more from a three-minute record
Than we ever learned in school " ("No Surrender", Bruce Springsteen)

Without the radio and records and the reel to reel I would probably not been playing/honking the saxophone.
 
Last edited:
I remember, many years ago, when I talked with my friend about bad habits. He had visit his child's preschool and the teachers were worried how his child was holding the pen, pencil, crayon ... when she was writing and drawing. My friend took up a pencil from his pocket and did some sketches. He and his child was holding the same way. The teachers didn't knew that he was an architect and his child have seen how he was holding the pen.
But some sax teachers will be pragmatic Thom. As you've said at the start of your post, there are many types of teacher. If you have a poor car, you don't give up on cars altogether.

And I think that everyone that is seemingly advocating for a teacher doesn't mean that solely - if a friend or a group of people that have good information and are close then they will act as a teacher - I'm not sure there is much of this in the UK these days. It's just this thought of shutting yourself away and almost shunning advice.

Playing an instrument isn't like much else at all. You don't start from a point of having some information. You probably won't even recognise a relatively poor sound. It is one of the most difficult thingpthere is, and for most, progress is extremely slow when measured against most other things in life.

In some ways the joy is in the learning. The journey. It has to be, you have to enjoy practising. But, if you get stuck - and you probably will - there is no joy in that. And, it could be unlocked by a simple piece of knowledge.
 
Thank you. I will definitely work on my embouchure and breathing from the start, from what I understand both of these are required to be done properly to lay a solid foundation to being able to play.

I used to lead meditation classes and have studied breathwork, so some of my past endeavours and learning may be of use when it comes to regulating the breath 😊
I have learnt that patience and perseverance is also important in this.

I have been taking lessons for about 10 years now. And I have a solid background in Aikido, so I assumed that my breathing would be fine. I guess it wasn't bad to start with.
But it is only 2 or 3 years ago that I really started to develop a decent breath support. And even now I feel that I don't have the control I would need to be consistent in my playing.

Just to say that these things take time to develop, don't lose your patience, keep at it.
We'll get there in the long run .....
 
There's a lot of physical aspects to playing a sax and books and online are not a substitute for an experienced teacher standing next to you to fix things before they become a habit and showing you how to do things.

I am a big advocate of people joining groups even as an absolute beginner. Groups aimed at beginners exist - community bands/orchestras etc.
 
I used to lead meditation classes and have studied breathwork, so some of my past endeavours and learning may be of use when it comes to regulating the breath 😊
From my perspective, breath and breathing have very little to actually do with air support and playing the saxophone.

The mindfulness aspect of meditation is very helpful though, and for me, when playing music, those states are achieved through music - at least that's always when I play my best music.
 
From my perspective, breath and breathing have very little to actually do with air support and playing the saxophone.

I'm starting to get this idea as well, it's a bit confusing because it seems there are two contradictory goals -- do you want to stay completely relaxed, and also have a rock solid air support (not 'breathing' necessarily!) at the reed?
 
From my perspective, breath and breathing have very little to actually do with air support and playing the saxophone.
I'm starting to get this idea as well, it's a bit confusing because it seems there are two contradictory goals -- do you want to stay completely relaxed, and also have a rock solid air support (not 'breathing' necessarily!) at the reed?
I used to lead meditation classes and have studied breathwork, so some of my past endeavours and learning may be of use when it comes to regulating the breath 😊
Wind instruments are different. The real issue is this - how do you develop a solid tone, which requires very firm muscles in the abdomen and “just so” firm muscles in the face, and remain completely relaxed everywhere else? All while making small precise movements with your fingers and small precise movements with your tongue and throat and standing or sitting straight and ….

Further, training yourself in this body-set so that you can forget about it, so that it is natural to you, so that these things can be unconcious and you can concentrate on making sounds that fit the moment.

All of this is why it takes time, and why a teacher is a good idea. I will not say you can’t do it without help, but it is hard to do. Teachers should be guides, pointing out the path - all too often they are rigid, inflexible and disagreeable! After all we do train ourselves, mostly. But having the guidance of a mentor is invaluable.

I know you “just want to play for myself”, and that is fine. But the experience of playing with others can be most helpful to our development. A mentor can be found in a band mate. So please don’t rule out making music with others.

I’ll shut up now. Best of luck to you Ann, please keep us posted on your progress.
 
Further, training yourself in this body-set so that you can forget about it, so that it is natural to you, so that these things can be unconcious and you can concentrate on making sounds that fit the moment
This is literally a huge focus of the lesson I had today.

Rhythm and groove are everything. Trying to get to the point where I can purely focus on that and just not worry about notes or playing the horn is the goal at the moment.

Getting the emotional feel and sound ahead of what I'm playing, so what I play next happens because it has to happen.

Always hugely inspired after a lesson, and highly recommend Iain Dixon's approach to anyone.....
 
Sorry gonna step in one more time. This is part of a longer video from the great trumpet player Clark Terry. Here he talks about the “sound post”. In a violin this is the little hard stick that supports the upper plate so the strings don’t bend it, and also transmits sound to the lower plate.

In a human, it’s like a brick post or a 8x8 piece of lumber in your belly, holding the sound up. It’s the key to tone on a wind instrument. This is the best demonstration I have seen of the principle of breath support, and it works exactly the same for ALL wind instruments from piccolo to tuba.

View: https://youtu.be/lFUm92uARiU?t=4m49s
 
Hi Ann not sure if you read music..I didnt when i first started..Theres a brilliant fun book that will get you started playing adult popular songs..Its called blowout sax by Mark Archer, worth a look and makes it fun..
 
From my perspective, breath and breathing have very little to actually do with air support and playing the saxophone.

The mindfulness aspect of meditation is very helpful though, and for me, when playing music, those states are achieved through music - at least that's always when I play my best music.
Thank you - just shows how little I know! Breathwork does cover breath control quite extensively, so I am guessing there will be a little overlap there, at least. But I might be wrong!
 
Hi Ann not sure if you read music..I didnt when i first started..Theres a brilliant fun book that will get you started playing adult popular songs..Its called blowout sax by Mark Archer, worth a look and makes it fun..
Oh wow, that is just the sort of thing I am looking for, thank you 🙂
 
Breathwork does cover breath control quite extensively, so I am guessing there will be a little overlap there, at least. But I might be wrong!
Knowing how to do diaphragm breathing is useful (even if that is a bit of a misnomer), as is having good lung capacity. being able to breather (or blow) out at a very constant rate is also useful as it allows you to not rely too much on the resistance of a hard reed. We cover a lot of that in the tutorials here.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,428
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom