~~~ Brand New Opinion ~~~
Well ok, maybe it's just a recycled old opinion, but it feels like new, check it out,...
Tonight I was trying out all of my mouthpieces. I just bought some Vandoren mouthpiece cushions and stuck one on all four of my mouthpieces. I've been having embouchure problems, and these new mouthpiece cushions really do the trick! I love em!
In any case, I have four mouthpieces total. Two Rico's, one cheap "replacement mouthpiece" I bought for about $5 on Amazon but I can't remember who the manufacturer is, and it doesn't have any markings on it. And then there's the original mouthpiece that came with my sax.
Tonight I practiced diligently using each mouthpiece and recording the session. Much to my surprise I actually like the cheap no-name $5 mouthpiece the best of all of them.
I wish I new what it was in terms of specs.
Well, all of this may seem far off topic, but the whole time I was practicing I was thinking about this thread, and what it means to be able to 'play' a saxophone (or any instrument for that matter).
What am I looking for?
Well, the bottom line for me is that I'm looking to express myself. I have a sound in my mind that I would like to produce using this instrument. When I record myself and listen back I'm actually comparing the results of the recording with my idealized imagined saxophone music that I have in my mind that I'm trying to get out through the instrument.
In other words, I'm trying to express my musical "art". Musical art that I have in my mind, but may not be able to physically produce on the actual saxophone.
This "realization" that this is my ultimate "goal" is actually a good mindset to have I would think.
If I can express myself the way I would like to on this instrument, then, and only then, would I say that I can "play" the saxophone. I might have a limited repertoire, and I might not even be able to play from sheet music (so a lot of people will say that I can't really "play").
But none of that is my own personal 'goal'.
My own personal goal is to be able to express myself musically on the instrument, even if that is limited in scope by repertoire. That is not something that I'm personally concerned with. I'll worry about expanding repertoire as needed, but ultimately my main "goal" is to first be able to "play" the instrument. And for me, that means to be able to express myself in a way that feels right for me.
I've noticed tonight also that there are many different aspects to this. Viewing it from this perspective I can see things more clearly in terms of phrasing, tonality, attack (starting notes), and being able to hold notes longer and savor them more softly at the end of a phrase if I want to.
By recognizing that my 'goal' is to express my own musicality I can better see precisely what obstacles are preventing me from achieving my goal.
Ok, that was a ramble, but that's what forums are for aren't they? ;}