Playing the saxophone When can you say....I can play the saxophone?

The guidance from Music Grades would seem to be the following:

1. There are 3 levels of playing - Beginner (1,2 & 3), Intermediate (4,5 & 6), & Advanced (Grades 7 & 8)
..........................
My own experience with the ABRSM Jazz Grades (in sax, trumpet and trombone) is that they are designed for players who learn through reading music and also learn by ear - with the emphasis being on learning to "play" - and both are considered valuable.

According to Trinity Information and Regulations Grade 6 is actually Advanced :welldone

Grades 1-3 or 'Foundation', NQF level 1
Grades 4&5 or 'Intermediate', NQF level 2
Grades 6-8 or 'Advanced', NQF level 3

With regard to the question - I always say yes I can play the sax because I am reasonably competent at it and confident on it, although I have strengths and weakness (which I'm working hard on!) I can hold my own and entertain people - Ive been asked to join quite a few bands to the point where I've had to turn them down (I'm in 2 that's enough!!) They say I play very well :thumb: but I'm yet to be convinced, as I'm my own worst critic ;} )
 
Sorry i made the mistake of taking your statement literally and not thinking you meant something different.

Brian

You are literally mistaken taking OG literally. Somehow he always manages to have an apparent meaning implied that is only apparent after he points them out 🙂
 
I can see your point here, but I think there's a real danger of never moving on in ones own mind from "learning" to "playing". Even the best players are still learning something, and after a few weeks most of us could play something recognisable to an audience as "three blind mice". I just think it's more constructive to think of it all as degrees of the same activity, rather than worrying about whether you belong to some exclusive club.

This is actually what I was getting at. One can have a standard, as I suggested, but where does that leave all those who for one reason or another are not in a professional outfit, but who like to play and frequently play very well?

Take for example something like the Australian Youth Orchestra. (The comment hat follows could equally well apply to lots of other youth orchestras.) They play very well, and they are probably better than many of the orchestras that Wagner, Verdi (and even Mahler at some stage) had to work with. They are certainly much more cooperative. Their training is rigorous, their discipline on statge is strict, but they are not a professional outfit.

As one goes further and further down the amateur ranks, it seems to me that at some stage one has to admit that one is now in learner territory. Being able to offer a passable rendition of "Three blind mice" in a relaxed family setting is not quite the same as being "able to play". What may be a good achievement for little Arthur at seven will not be viewed in the quite the same for Martha, a much more accomplished sixteen-year old performing at some school celebration. So, yes, we talking about degrees of the same activity.
 
~~~ Brand New Opinion ~~~

Well ok, maybe it's just a recycled old opinion, but it feels like new, check it out,...

Tonight I was trying out all of my mouthpieces. I just bought some Vandoren mouthpiece cushions and stuck one on all four of my mouthpieces. I've been having embouchure problems, and these new mouthpiece cushions really do the trick! I love em!

In any case, I have four mouthpieces total. Two Rico's, one cheap "replacement mouthpiece" I bought for about $5 on Amazon but I can't remember who the manufacturer is, and it doesn't have any markings on it. And then there's the original mouthpiece that came with my sax.

Tonight I practiced diligently using each mouthpiece and recording the session. Much to my surprise I actually like the cheap no-name $5 mouthpiece the best of all of them.

I wish I new what it was in terms of specs.

Well, all of this may seem far off topic, but the whole time I was practicing I was thinking about this thread, and what it means to be able to 'play' a saxophone (or any instrument for that matter).

What am I looking for?

Well, the bottom line for me is that I'm looking to express myself. I have a sound in my mind that I would like to produce using this instrument. When I record myself and listen back I'm actually comparing the results of the recording with my idealized imagined saxophone music that I have in my mind that I'm trying to get out through the instrument.

In other words, I'm trying to express my musical "art". Musical art that I have in my mind, but may not be able to physically produce on the actual saxophone.

This "realization" that this is my ultimate "goal" is actually a good mindset to have I would think.

If I can express myself the way I would like to on this instrument, then, and only then, would I say that I can "play" the saxophone. I might have a limited repertoire, and I might not even be able to play from sheet music (so a lot of people will say that I can't really "play").

But none of that is my own personal 'goal'.

My own personal goal is to be able to express myself musically on the instrument, even if that is limited in scope by repertoire. That is not something that I'm personally concerned with. I'll worry about expanding repertoire as needed, but ultimately my main "goal" is to first be able to "play" the instrument. And for me, that means to be able to express myself in a way that feels right for me.

I've noticed tonight also that there are many different aspects to this. Viewing it from this perspective I can see things more clearly in terms of phrasing, tonality, attack (starting notes), and being able to hold notes longer and savor them more softly at the end of a phrase if I want to.

By recognizing that my 'goal' is to express my own musicality I can better see precisely what obstacles are preventing me from achieving my goal.

Ok, that was a ramble, but that's what forums are for aren't they? ;}


 
Not sure how long it was back but used to also post that the soloist was expected to improvise at the end of concertos. Some prats wrote down the better improvisations and that became the norm played. Suspect the same was true of continuo.

Was quite amazed that some did not appreciate that my post regarding nothing left to learn was meant to illustrate the impossibility of answering the OP. You are what you are and can judge how satisfied you are with your progress. Once played a triangle at an evening class concert. Just one note but expertly performed. That's until I heard Cajun music.

Quite right, the cadenza would usually be introduced with a dominant 7th chord and away the soloist would go on his impro. As you say, some people would right down a particular soloist's, or the composer's, improv and that then gets to be the 'standard'. I have been to the odd concert where the soloist has performed his own.

The other area for improv is the continuo players (i.e. keyboard or theorbo/archlute). They realise the figured bass and make it up as they go along. When my main choir uses period instrument players, it's always fun seeing what the continuo players are going to do (theorbo players ar fiendish - they just rip through a figured bass line and produce all this rippling harmony).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom