... your audience or family or friends ...
As an living entity of another form I think it depends on who I'm talking to and the impression I want to give.
If the neighbour asks what the noise is then I play the sax.
If someone were to ask me to join a band then I don't.
Are you suggesting that the presence or absence of anacoluthonic sentence structures and a tendency to the use of sesquipedalianisms is indicative of one's ability to play the saxophone?maybe classical....

If you are able to make an intended sound on the sax, then you can play it.

Am I a pro? No. Can I sing solo? No, I get too nervous for that, but I wil happily sing even just two to a part. However, at that point I decided I could call myself an amateur musician, but even now after 18 years, I feel a bit of a fraud...![]()
I think I'm being terribly 'English'! Here's a pic from the rehearsal in the RAHBut why beat yourself up like that? I bet you wouldn't call your fellow choir members frauds, so why do it to yourself? You're a musician, and judging from the sort of pieces you're performing, quite an accomplished one. Ok, you don't get paid so you're an amateur. Lots of pop stars can't sing a note but get paid stupid amounts of money for it so they're professionals. So what? You've clearly reached a level of musical skill way above what most people ever reach. Enjoy it, I say, and don't be sheepish about it.
Possibly when there is nothing left to learn?
I do not believe that there grounds for believing that anyone having been a learner (from scratch) for six months (30 minutes a day) can credibly say "I play the saxophone". More honest would be "I am learning the saxophone".
Possibly when there is nothing left to learn?
Upto and including the Baroque period (i.e. upto about 1750) musicians were expected to improvise and decorate the line they played. Classical music (i.e. after 1750) was more prescriptive and composers wrote out all of the ornaments and decoration that they wanted, i.e improvisation not allowed! So it's fallen of the map for many 'classical' musicians.I am sure this will never happen because no matter how good you are there is always something to learn.
I remember seeing a program some years ago about James Galway a great flute player he could play almost any piece of music but when he tried to do some jazz and blues improv he really struggled unless it was written down on music paper,he couldn't do it by ear as i say this was a few years ago so might have got by now.
Brian
Upto and including the Baroque period (i.e. upto about 1750) musicians were expected to improvise and decorate the line they played. Classical music (i.e. after 1750) was more prescriptive and composers wrote out all of the ornaments and decoration that they wanted, i.e improvisation not allowed! So it's fallen of the map for many 'classical' musicians.
The development of 'historically informed performance' (period instruments to you and me) is seeing a return of an expectaiton of the player being free to extemporise and decorate the line.
There is one big exception, organists. Organists are expected to improvise either on a given tune or ad lib and it's a formal part of the training and exams (e.g. ARCO, FRCO). By the way I don't play the organ, in case you're wondering!
Not sure how long it was back but used to also post that the soloist was expected to improvise at the end of concertos. Some prats wrote down the better improvisations and that became the norm played. Suspect the same was true of continuo.
Was quite amazed that some did not appreciate that my post regarding nothing left to learn was meant to illustrate the impossibility of answering the OP. You are what you are and can judge how satisfied you are with your progress. Once played a triangle at an evening class concert. Just one note but expertly performed. That's until I heard Cajun music.
