Playing the saxophone When can you say....I can play the saxophone?

... your audience or family or friends ...

Exactly ... when your audience says you can play. And don't forget that sometimes the audience is you yourself, and when, once in a while, you reach the end of a piece, and know you've nailed it, and have enjoyed your own playing, then you can tell yourself: "I CAN play the sax".
 
If you are able to make an intended sound on the sax, then you can play it. Anything else is just a question of how well you play it. I can play a sax. I will never be as good as Sonny Rollins, nevertheless, I do play the sax.

Reading notes and improvisation are musical skills and not necessarily dependant on any instrument nor any particular skill on any instrument.

That's how simple I want it to be 🙂
 
When you go a blues club (2 days ago) and the bloke on the door takes one look at you and says, "No sax players allowed in here thank you".

Fortunately he was joking.

About allowing me in, that is.

I think.

Anyway, Geoff Achison was very good.
 
As an living entity of another form I think it depends on who I'm talking to and the impression I want to give.
If the neighbour asks what the noise is then I play the sax.
If someone were to ask me to join a band then I don't.

This is very true. Most things are relative.

However, when it comes to playing a saxophone I can say with absolute certainty that I can not play a saxophone,.... yet.

I often wonder if there will ever come a day when I will feel differently?

On an optimistic note, I have PROGRESSED from not being able to "play" the saxophone at all, to being able to make noise with it that can sometimes be recognized by some people to actually be associated certain "tunes".

I'm not sure if that's actually progress, or just dangerous. 🙂))
 
If you are able to make an intended sound on the sax, then you can play it.

I agree that this is the perfect criteria to go by.

And the truth is that I personally cannot make the intended sounds on the sax. Therefore I cannot play, obviously.

However, sometimes I wonder if it's just because I have a really cheap crappy instrument?

I should rent a really nice horn for a while and find out if it's me or my horn that can't play. ;}
 
More seriously, than my last post on this thread :ashamed, I had this issue when I started out singing. I had my first lesson in my mid 30s, until then I'd never sung a note, let alone performed in public.

Within a year, I was singing with my music teacher's chamber choir, giving Christmas concerts, performances of the Messiah, etc.

It took me a long time (well over 10 years) before I was able to say 'I'm an amateur musician' when people asked me what I did outside of work (the answer used to be 'amateur astronomer' but that's another story 😛).

What 'persuaded' me was when I moved house in 1999 I joined my present two choirs, but I also started going to choral workshops and summer schools. This really improves your sight-reading. I then joined a big festival chorus that just meets in the summer term. This gave me the opportunity to sing with professional full-size symphony orchestras such as the BBC Philharmonic, The Royal Liverpool Phil, The Royal Philharmonic. With them I've sung in the Bridgewater Hall (Manchester), Chester Cathedral etc. The pinnacle was singing the Vaughan Williams Sea Symphony with the RLPO at the Royal Albert Hall in a BBC Prom concert, broadcast live on Radio 3 and shown on BBC4.

Am I a pro? No. Can I sing solo? No, I get too nervous for that, but I wil happily sing even just two to a part. However, at that point I decided I could call myself an amateur musician, but even now after 18 years, I feel a bit of a fraud...:confused:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Am I a pro? No. Can I sing solo? No, I get too nervous for that, but I wil happily sing even just two to a part. However, at that point I decided I could call myself an amateur musician, but even now after 18 years, I feel a bit of a fraud...:confused:

But why beat yourself up like that? I bet you wouldn't call your fellow choir members frauds, so why do it to yourself? You're a musician, and judging from the sort of pieces you're performing, quite an accomplished one. Ok, you don't get paid so you're an amateur. Lots of pop stars can't sing a note but get paid stupid amounts of money for it so they're professionals. So what? You've clearly reached a level of musical skill way above what most people ever reach. Enjoy it, I say, and don't be sheepish about it.
 
I can think of a couple of reasonably objective criteria of how to judge whether one can play: (a) if Sir Simon Rattle tells you that you can, then you can, and (b) if you get invited to play with a professional orchestra (classical, light music, jazz, etc.), then you can also play.

Most of us are not in that category, but many still have a reasonable claim for being able to play, but the claim perhaps becomes more qualified. It could be: "I play first tenor in a community orchestra and we perform regularly at public events", or "I play baritone every Friday and Saturday night in a little jazz group at the Busy Bee Hotel". These are accomplishments that cannot be denied.

I do not believe that there grounds for believing that anyone having been a learner (from scratch) for six months (30 minutes a day) can credibly say "I play the saxophone". More honest would be "I am learning the saxophone".
 
For me a musician is someone who entertains people through music. And if you use a sax to do this, then by my definition you can play it. Everything else is to do with proficiency. And if you want to define ability to play as proficiency, it's OK, but it gets away from the real point.

Music/playing are about emotions, entertainment, ability of others to enjoy your playing.
 
But why beat yourself up like that? I bet you wouldn't call your fellow choir members frauds, so why do it to yourself? You're a musician, and judging from the sort of pieces you're performing, quite an accomplished one. Ok, you don't get paid so you're an amateur. Lots of pop stars can't sing a note but get paid stupid amounts of money for it so they're professionals. So what? You've clearly reached a level of musical skill way above what most people ever reach. Enjoy it, I say, and don't be sheepish about it.
I think I'm being terribly 'English'! Here's a pic from the rehearsal in the RAH

IMG_0019.jpg


Update: to be fair, these days with regard to singing I tend to say "I am an experienced amateur musician". With regard to the viol I tend to say, "I am a lower intermediate player: I can sight read reasonably well, but I need to work on consort playing". For the sax I say: "I have recently started to learn to play the sax".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I do not believe that there grounds for believing that anyone having been a learner (from scratch) for six months (30 minutes a day) can credibly say "I play the saxophone". More honest would be "I am learning the saxophone".

I can see your point here, but I think there's a real danger of never moving on in ones own mind from "learning" to "playing". Even the best players are still learning something, and after a few weeks most of us could play something recognisable to an audience as "three blind mice". I just think it's more constructive to think of it all as degrees of the same activity, rather than worrying about whether you belong to some exclusive club.
 
Possibly when there is nothing left to learn?

I am sure this will never happen because no matter how good you are there is always something to learn.

I remember seeing a program some years ago about James Galway a great flute player he could play almost any piece of music but when he tried to do some jazz and blues improv he really struggled unless it was written down on music paper,he couldn't do it by ear as i say this was a few years ago so might have got by now.

Brian
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am sure this will never happen because no matter how good you are there is always something to learn.

I remember seeing a program some years ago about James Galway a great flute player he could play almost any piece of music but when he tried to do some jazz and blues improv he really struggled unless it was written down on music paper,he couldn't do it by ear as i say this was a few years ago so might have got by now.

Brian
Upto and including the Baroque period (i.e. upto about 1750) musicians were expected to improvise and decorate the line they played. Classical music (i.e. after 1750) was more prescriptive and composers wrote out all of the ornaments and decoration that they wanted, i.e improvisation not allowed! So it's fallen of the map for many 'classical' musicians.

The development of 'historically informed performance' (period instruments to you and me) is seeing a return of an expectaiton of the player being free to extemporise and decorate the line.

There is one big exception, organists. Organists are expected to improvise either on a given tune or ad lib and it's a formal part of the training and exams (e.g. ARCO, FRCO). By the way I don't play the organ, in case you're wondering!
 
Upto and including the Baroque period (i.e. upto about 1750) musicians were expected to improvise and decorate the line they played. Classical music (i.e. after 1750) was more prescriptive and composers wrote out all of the ornaments and decoration that they wanted, i.e improvisation not allowed! So it's fallen of the map for many 'classical' musicians.

The development of 'historically informed performance' (period instruments to you and me) is seeing a return of an expectaiton of the player being free to extemporise and decorate the line.




There is one big exception, organists. Organists are expected to improvise either on a given tune or ad lib and it's a formal part of the training and exams (e.g. ARCO, FRCO). By the way I don't play the organ, in case you're wondering!

Thanks i wasn't aware of that,as i said earlier always something to learn.

Brian
 
Not sure how long it was back but used to also post that the soloist was expected to improvise at the end of concertos. Some prats wrote down the better improvisations and that became the norm played. Suspect the same was true of continuo.

Was quite amazed that some did not appreciate that my post regarding nothing left to learn was meant to illustrate the impossibility of answering the OP. You are what you are and can judge how satisfied you are with your progress. Once played a triangle at an evening class concert. Just one note but expertly performed. That's until I heard Cajun music.
 
Not sure how long it was back but used to also post that the soloist was expected to improvise at the end of concertos. Some prats wrote down the better improvisations and that became the norm played. Suspect the same was true of continuo.

Was quite amazed that some did not appreciate that my post regarding nothing left to learn was meant to illustrate the impossibility of answering the OP. You are what you are and can judge how satisfied you are with your progress. Once played a triangle at an evening class concert. Just one note but expertly performed. That's until I heard Cajun music.

Sorry i made the mistake of taking your statement literally and not thinking you meant something different.

Brian
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom