Playing the saxophone What put you off??

mizmar

Eternal early intermediat
Messages
6,142
Location
Trondheim, Norway
Level
Eternal early intermediat
Inspired by the "What got you started" thread ;

What put you off jazz/classical/prog rock/....?
Did you get over it?


When I was really young I listened to a BBC jazz program on the radio and after each piece the presenter spent twice as long again reeling of who was playing what instrument (there's a joke video, can't find it). At the best of times I have a really rubbish memory, particularly for names and dates. So I was convinced jazz wasn't for me if I had to remember so many names to like it....
.... Now, if only I could remember how to play a iI V tritone substitution over a C13b4ø#15....
 
Last edited:
Classical? Got bored with it, doing Grade 8 on the clarinet at 15, fed up with Mozart. Sax was like a breath of fresh air in comparison.

Lots of jazz leaves me cold, I wouldn't listen to it and don't much like playing. Some grabs me, but not most, and atonal stuff makes me just switch it off. Like @thomsax I like rock sax, and at my age - late 50s - I can't see much change coming.
 
Classical? Got bored with it, doing Grade 8 on the clarinet at 15, fed up with Mozart. Sax was like a breath of fresh air in comparison.

Lots of jazz leaves me cold, I wouldn't listen to it and don't much like playing. Some grabs me, but not most, and atonal stuff makes me just switch it off. Like @thomsax I like rock sax, and at my age - late 50s - I can't see much change coming.
FED UP WITH MOZART. LOTS OF JAZZ LEAVES ME COLD. LOL. I LIKE ROCK SAX. ?
 
HI

sorry I was a bit short in my previous post. The reason being, your post reminded me of a story/joke my old teacher told myself and some other students at the time, and I thought it would be a bit rude to mention it, but don’t take it personal, so here goes. Anyway, the conductor stops the orchestra suddenly and addresses a viola player, and asks is there a problem. The Viola player shakes his head and indicates no. The conductor continues then after a short time he stops the orchestra again and asks’ is it a personal problem , family ? . The Viola player shakes his head again saying no,no, so the conductor continues, then after a short time he stops the orchestra again, and confronts the player and says. WHAT IS THE PROBLEM. The viola player answers. I HATE MUSIC.



You can read into that whatever.
 
Last edited:
I think Rock & Roll and Blues is more love and peace. Jazz and classic can be very elitist and authoritarian. That goes for most music but ...... .

I was in Albania back in July 1969. The guys that played in the hotel orchestra were very good. Well educated and could play everything without or from sheet music. The cultural revolution was a reality in Albania by then. The good musicians became stevedores in Durres and new "musicians"took their places in Tirana. they were working 10-12 hours as stevedores and then they were picked up to play at the hotels for 6-8 hours. No extra money. They had very bad instruments. I "forgot" my Conn Director alto (Mexico) with lots of reeds and some mouthpieces. A dream horn in Albania in the late 60's. They were not allowsd to play rock or pop songs. Just one song that pass through the censoring; "The House Of the Rising Sun". They let me play with the hotel orchestra. No sheet music, to learn by ear is freedom. CCR's/John Fogerty's song "Bad Moon Rising" was dangerous.
 
I can't really say there is any specific style of music that I used to like and now dislike. I will say that early 70s "cockrock" has lost some of its appeal from the lyrics, but I still like it a lot musically.
 
Prog Rock lit no fires under me and Metal likewise is an aural fire extinguisher, whereas equally complex, equally long, equally virtuosic and equally non-pop, modern jazz numbers held (some of) my attention in my yoof

I don't know the reason for my antipathy, but prog rock/metal are the last thing I would choose to take to a desert island. Well after having to put on 70's D.I.S.C.O. under a palm tree

But, if there d nothing else to listen to, I have no doubt I would get into it
 
Classical? Got bored with it, doing Grade 8 on the clarinet at 15, fed up with Mozart. Sax was like a breath of fresh air in comparison.

Lots of jazz leaves me cold, I wouldn't listen to it and don't much like playing. Some grabs me, but not most, and atonal stuff makes me just switch it off. Like @thomsax I like rock sax, and at my age - late 50s - I can't see much change coming.
Clarinet is still my main instrument, and I still love it... But I'm with you here, I played the Mozart concerto/quintet so much for auditions and competitions, I was bored of it by the time I left school. Still have a soft spot for the Brahms sonatas though.
 
When I first started playing sax, and by extension jazz, I loved Mozart, operas mostly, not much of any jazz, and I couldn't understand why my phrasing was so bad. I eventually worked out that playing jazz and listening to Mozart was a bad idea. So I stopped listening to the Magic Flute, il Seraglio etc. and I haven't listened to Mozart since; my phrasing is better. But I miss him and can probably go back now, and I think I might.
 
Clarinet is still my main instrument, and I still love it... But I'm with you here, I played the Mozart concerto/quintet so much for auditions and competitions, I was bored of it by the time I left school. Still have a soft spot for the Brahms sonatas though.
I agree with you completely that a young guy at 15 @jonf) reaching grade 8 and the pressure he must’ve felt. At that age you need a mentor who can guide you musically through this complicated thing we call music. His clarinet background is something of an achievement and for sure contributes to his expertise he has enjoyed with the sax. Myself, my music journey started in an Australian military brass band , Kapooka in Wagga Wagga NSW. as a 3rd cornet. The polar opposite to how @ Jonf started his musical journey. I purchased a green clarinet that was left in a shop window exposed to the sun not long after joining the army brass band, and fell in love with the late great Pete fountain who was recording lots of the more expressive pop songs at that time. What the Australian Army gave me was the time to practice my new instrument all day long and soon I was off to a full military band in Canberra, ( Duntroon) with flutes and saxes, string double bass etc. I never progressed through the music exams as others did but took the grade before the diploma LTCL. As requested before being eligible to take the diploma, which I did soon after as I required it for some part time teaching. Anyway enough about my beginnings as a a clarinetist. I understand that we move on musically and chose a different related main instrument but it’s a personal choice.

As is the music we chose to play. I think although I would consider myself a failure if I hated my first instrument if it was the clarinet. There is only good or not so good music and it has nothing to do to do with the genre. BTW. It was Mozart who first realised the potential of the new instrument named a Klarinett. Danke Mozart.
 
Your teacher HATED JOKES?
My teacher who I talk about had a great sense of humour and was an amazing clarinetist who escaped communist Russia. He moved to Paris initially with his French wife and worked with the Strasbourg Phil. Until he retired. But he was a great guy. I miss him RIP valentin.
 
My teacher who I talk about had a great sense of humour and was an amazing clarinetist who escaped communist Russia. He moved to Paris initially with his French wife and worked with the Strasbourg Phil. Until he retired. But he was a great guy. I miss him RIP valentin.

The late great Valentin Sakharov.
A live performance found by Sacha his son, but it’s a pity the audio quality does not do His sound justice. Recorded Sydney NSW. When he worked at the Australian Opera as principal Clarinet. Then the Elizabethan Trust.
RIP Val

View: https://youtube.com/watch?v=v2Z8GkZ4PRQ&si=tpGXk-NDPz3AyqlQ
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,548
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom