Playing the saxophone What exactly is subtone?

I don't think you have to go from one extreme to another!

The graphs in Pete's article shows a reduction in higher partials....
No, I'm not suggesting that you should. I meant that just taking away higher partials would seem to be moving towards a sine wave, which is quite a harsh sharp-edged sort of sound. I think there must be something else going on in a subtone which makes the pitch of the note less well-defined rather than more.
 
Ok. Some people think the pitch less well defined and others think the fundamental is better defined
Glad that's cleared up
That reminds me of an acoustic session I was sitting in where, on the same note, the bass player advised me I was playing flat and the guitar player thought I was sharp. And both are professionals rather than the average hack.
 
Ah now I understand where that comes from. Notes can be ghosted and to me that is usually accidental, like the note doesn't quite speak.



Ghost tonguing on a held note often sounds a dampened note as oppose to implied note that is more or less silent or pitches. People find this when transcribing you can hear a gap where a note didn't quite speak. So it can either be an intended effect or an unintended effect.

Some fine examples of both here in the second chorus at about 26 seconds. And not a subtone in sight.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foPwsp-Blds





That's where I disagree, there is no correlation between subtone and ghost tonguing. They can of course be done at the same time but one doesn't cause the other or necessarily be involved with the other. I think I already said that though and agreed to disagree 🙂

John was talking about "voovv" which I understand totally and is often when you start a note without any tongue at all. By itself it isn't subtone but it accentuates the subtone due to the more audible great sound when you do it.
OK so we are definitely talking about different things here.

Ghost tonguing as you demonstrate is a very very different sound from the subtone using a tongue as demonstrated by Dave and by tried by my self earlier. It sounds completely different.

When I leave my tongue dampening the reed somewhat, but allowing it to still speak and sound, the resulting sound is very very similar in sound to subtone. It's not an articulation. It continues in the same tone for the full duration of the note. I'm not talking about "voov" here but the tone of the held note.

I completely understand your definition and description of ghost tonguing. This effect is NOT that, but it is done by leaving the tongue remaining partially in contact with the reed for the full duration of the note, which could be a minim, a semi breve, longer etc. It then sounds like a "soft long note" as you might play on a ballad, as played by Ben Webster et al

I've asked Dave for input on how he learnt "subtone" in this manner, but it is definitely NOT ghost tonguing.
 
I've asked Dave for input on how he learnt "subtone"
Who is Dave?
Ghost tonguing as you demonstrate is a very very different sound from the subtone using a tongue as demonstrated by Dave and by tried by my self earlier. It sounds completely different.
Well yes that's what I'm saying. Ghost tonguing is a different thing. And subtone using a tongue may be misleading as it implies creating subtone by a tonguing technique. however I don't think that;s what you mean - just that it sounds confusing.

So to clarify the way I see it (and I may update the article)

Subtone is a technique of generating a tone that sounds soft, fat and warm. It is not just pianissimo because of its special tone character. It may be because the technique is such that the reed does not close fully against the mouthpiece during each single vibration cycle as it does with "full" tone (the most usually used opposite of subtone). It can sound particularly breathy especially when combined with a soft tongueless articulation (foo or voodoo) or at the end if the note fades out so that you hear the players breath along with the note. Calling it a breathy tone may be a slight misnomer because the breath may be literal breath as opposed to being a part of the tone.
 
Who is Dave?

Well yes that's what I'm saying. Ghost tonguing is a different thing. And subtone using a tongue may be misleading as it implies creating subtone by a tonguing technique. however I don't think that;s what you mean - just that it sounds confusing.

So to clarify the way I see it (and I may update the article)

Subtone is a technique of generating a tone that sounds soft, fat and warm. It is not just pianissimo because of its special tone character. It may be because the technique is such that the reed does not close fully against the mouthpiece during each single vibration cycle as it does with "full" tone (the most usually used opposite of subtone). It can sound particularly breathy especially when combined with a soft tongueless articulation (foo or voodoo) or at the end if the note fades out so that you hear the players breath along with the note. Calling it a breathy tone may be a slight misnomer because the breath may be literal breath as opposed to being a part of the tone.
Dave Pollack (I mentioned him in the earlier posts); one of the guys who uses the technique to play subtone that involves leaving your tongue on the reed.

I know what subtone should sound like. And the subtone that he produces is done using his tongue left partially on the read, which sounds the same roughly as the subtone I produce which I don't use my tongue for at all. And when I tried, today, to emulate his technique, it too sounds very similar to my normal subtone.

It doesn't sound like ghost tonguing. That is very much a different thing: completely agree.

But it appears there is a school of thought that teaches and plays subtoning by using the tongue as a dampener rather than the bottom lip. Which also sounds fat and warm and all those other subjective terms.

So circling back: these guys suggest that to subtone they use their tongue to dampen the reed. They also as a completely different technique, talk about using their tongue to play ghost tonguing/doodn tonguing, whatever you want to call it.

Hope that's clear now!
 
Dave Pollack (I mentioned him in the earlier posts); one of the guys who uses the technique to play subtone that involves leaving your tongue on the reed.
I don't know who that is but whatever, I think he's wrong about that. It's not a technique to play subtone.

The best way to learn the technique is to practice tone control and listen to the masters who developed that technique in the 30s, 40s and 50s as opposed to stick your tongue on the reed and instant subtone.
 
Last edited:
I don't know who that is but whatever, I think he's wrong about that. It's not a technique to play subtone.

The best way to learn the technique is to practice tone control and listen to the masters who developed that technique in the 30s and 40s as opposed to stick your tinge on the reed and instant subtone.
Except it is a technique that he's using, that produces a sound indistinguishable from subtone? So could be argued to be a technique that produces subtone......

As I say, it's not how I do it; but it's clearly come from somewhere, as it was also introduced into this conversation by someone else, so perhaps there is something to it.

Dave playing a ballad, dipping in and out of subtone at various parts (on alto, where its generally not as clear to hear as tenor, but he's primarily an altp player)
View: https://youtu.be/sRU2X6t0C3M?si=w4lj0rhEHlWw0G5U
 
Last edited:
I can't help thinking that the classic technique, lowered retracted jaw, which makes loose lower lip contact with the reed is equivalent to flabby tongue contact, in terms of the sound production mechanism – the reed higher frequency vibrations being lightly absorbed.
 
Seems a wide variety of opinions of what a subtone constitutes. If there were ways to differentiate them, perhaps with some newly developed terminology, that helps to differentiate the different flavours of it.
 
Last edited:
And I was quite surprised when i saw clarinet mentioned in the Wikipedia article.
Me too!

Which convinces me that looking for a definite existing worded definition is pointless as musicians - sax players - have taken the phrase and used possibly incorrectly.

Descriptions yes, dictionary definitions no.
 
Me too!

Which convinces me that looking for a definite existing worded definition is pointless as musicians - sax players - have taken the phrase and used possibly incorrectly.

Descriptions yes, dictionary definitions no.
Well, I'm just enjoying seeing how many concepts for "subtone" there are out there. Of course, when we're actually playing it doesn't matter what specific technique we're using, all that matters is we're getting the sound we hear in our heads. Still, it's fun. And it's been an interesting exercise for me trying to isolate the different aspects of what various people think of as a subtone.
 
Last edited:
I just looked at the spectrum of my subtoning vs. soft playing. I am not using any tonguing, just "breath attack" but my embouchure changes => taking in more MPC but pulling back the lower lip (on soprano).

Unfortunately I can't show any screenshots because I don't have a 3rd hand to hit the PrtSc button on the keyboard but there are two differences, the main one being that the harmonics are much reduced, it becomes prominent in the 1500-5000 Hz range. (fundamentals are in the 300 ish range).
The second difference is that the "peaks" are more pronounced and the valleys are deeper so it is almost like a "less noise" tone.
Just my personal experience and on soprano.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,326
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom