Playing the saxophone What exactly is subtone?

If you have a minute, and the will
I have the will but i have not been able to play for a while. I’ll see if i can.
For reference sake, this is what I've always called subtone.
There is certainly breath there. It sounds like some subtone in places but not on others. There is some more brightness on the higher louder notes. Perhaps listening on my phone is not s good idea.
 
oooooook how about this? Both versions are breathy but the first one I tried to subtone, the second I tried to play straight, except it's got breath. And I involuntarily subtoned a bit on a couple notes...
View: https://soundcloud.com/gj-dikeman/subtone-mfv

One more. trying to do it even more extreme and with less air. If this doesn't count, I give up!
View: https://soundcloud.com/gj-dikeman/subtone-as-much-as-i-can-do
 
Last edited:
Not really because it is wrong terminology. That is not subtone, which is a type of tone technique. What you are referring to is an articulation effect known variously as ghost tonguing, dooden tonguing, half tonging and even lala tonguing:

I do know people, including well thought of educators, that actually do use the term subtone for this. And they would also teach ghost tonguing as a different technique.

It's not subtone as I understand it; but I think it's probably clear that the term is used to describe different thing depending on who/when/where someone was taught.
 
I've often heard it said that the articulation is often something that defines our concept of timbre. (e.g. if you truncate an audiofil by removing the start, it can be difficult to even identify the instrument)

So with subtone, the ballad tongueless articulation (Foo or Voo) tends to include a lot of breath at the start of the note. So we maybe perceive the whole note of phrase to be "breathy"

I recorded this video to demonstrate the difference between a Buescher and Grafton sound, however it's pertinent here because I specifically used a style of subtone (mostly) BUT with a definite tonguing on most of the notes. Hence I would say this is an example of non-breathy subtone.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uecbPgDNU4g
 
I do know people, including well thought of educators, that actually do use the term subtone for this.
Well all I can say is they would probably not be well thought of by me. It is confusing. Especially if they know that those are different techniques.

It's like when I hear people say they roll their Rs in order to growl. Fluttertongue is a different technique to growling.
 
I've often heard it said that the articulation is often something that defines our concept of timbre. (e.g. if you truncate an audiofil by removing the start, it can be difficult to even identify the instrument)

So with subtone, the ballad tongueless articulation (Foo or Voo) tends to include a lot of breath at the start of the note. So we maybe perceive the whole note of phrase to be "breathy"

I recorded this video to demonstrate the difference between a Buescher and Grafton sound, however it's pertinent here because I specifically used a style of subtone (mostly) BUT with a definite tonguing on most of the notes. Hence I would say this is an example of non-breathy subtone.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uecbPgDNU4g
Ah great to hear the Buescher, Grafton comparison as well!
Ha... but to be honest, most of that doesn't sound like subtone to me...! Just a little on the lower notes, the mid range just sounds like a great alto sound!.
So I think we just have very different ideas of what it is. The examples on your taming the saxophone page do sound like subtone, however.

I'm curious if any of the clips I posted fit the bill for you.
 
Ha, I’m doubting myself now but then I’m still relying on phone speaker. That alto track is one of the TTS examples though.

Funny thing listening to those it struck me that the first track had a lot of breath, however it is mostly on the start of notes as I mentioned above with tongueless articulation. Annoyingly on this speaker it doesn’t sound a lot different to the drummer brushes “stirring soup” we used to call it.

I do remember when I first got that track back from mastering engineer, the compression/eq had somehow made the breath a bit too sizzly.
I'm curious if any of the clips I posted fit the bill for you.
I’d say they are soft but not what I’d call a classic subtone. What I listen for is the lack or presence of higher frequencies through the note, not just on the articulation. But as mentioned I’m now doubting myself own examples in places. Maybe my ears are getting too old.
 
Well all I can say is they would probably not be well thought of by me. It is confusing. Especially if they know that those are different techniques.

It's like when I hear people say they roll their Rs in order to growl. Fluttertongue is a different technique to growling.
No they're saying they are two different techniques. They aren't sayiing that doodn tonguing is subtone. But (and I tried it earlier) placing the tongue on the reed to one side can be used to produce subtone.

And it does. What I noticed whilst trying this is that it performs a similar physical effect as how I normally play subtone, which does involves
pushing a little bit more of my bottom lip onto the reed, as well as all the changes in airstream.

Speaking of which, I tried to pull out a couple of recordings where I'd consider myself to be playing subtone a fair bit; would be interesting whether you agree, especially with your points about the higher overtones:

View: https://youtu.be/jwvVdwr2H6w?si=L2UbRVhUM_cD9RR7
 
Last edited:
No they're saying they are two different techniques. They aren't sayiing that doodn tonguing is subtone.

Well you said in post 44 that these teachers use the term subtone for ghost tonguing, and then said that they teach it as a separate technique. This seems to be a contradiction.

"I do know people, including well thought of educators, that actually do use the term subtone for this. And they would also teach ghost tonguing as a different technique."

That is very confusing because if they say it's a separate technique how can they also call it subtone?

Speaking of which, I tried to pull out a couple of recordings where I'd consider myself to be playing subtone a fair bit; would be interesting whether you agree, especially with your points about the higher overtones:
Yes it includes a fair bit of what I would call subtone and maybe also some ghost tonguing
 
a technique I had never tried before, to play the low notes while lightly cushioning the reed with a flat tongue, without consciously changing embouchure. The resulting sound is not breathy, but is muffled, (soft and fluffy) lacking the bright higher partials. Whether that classifies as "subtone"
I do know people, including well thought of educators, that actually do use the term subtone for this. And they would also teach ghost tonguing as a different technique.

Well you said in post 44 that these teachers use the term subtone for ghost tonguing, and then said that they teach it as a separate technique. This seems to be a cocontradiction
I was referring to leaving your tongue partially on the reed, not just for articulation but for the entire duration of the note.

Ghost tonguing/ doodn tonguing for me are usually referred to when playing a series of notes, such as a swing phrase, and I'd use the tongue to prevent a note from fully speaking; e.g. a line like be-dood-'n-ba-be-oo-bop.

But in this case with it being used to describe subtone, I would leave the tongue on for the duration of a longer note. (I don't actually play like this to stress, but as the aforementioned teachers described it, and the practise I had earlier).

So I would definitely think of the two as very different techniques.
 
Yes it includes a fair bit of what I would call subtone and maybe also some ghost tonguing
So I wasn't aware of any ghost tonguing there at all, but that's not to say it didn't happen of course.

With the higher overtones though, this is where I wonder where the effect of the mouthpiece comes in to play; this was played on a higher baffle piece, if I go back to similar ballad recordings on a lower baffle, wider chamber piece, the sound has less overtones and is a rounder subtone. But physically I'll have played in roughly the same style of playing... cause that's how I typically play ballads. I'll try and dig a recording out, or make some new ones between the two pieces.
 
That definitely fits my standard definitionof subtone.
I don't know, when i listen to Ben Webster, Coleman Hawkins or Stan Getz i don't hear a complete lack of overtones. I hear a rich voovvv sound with a lot of breath....
 
So I wasn't aware of any ghost tonguing there at all, but that's not to say it didn't happen of course.
Nor me I had misread you and thought you said there was some so I thought maybe there was but too subtle for me to hear on the phone.

Ghost tonguing/ doodn tonguing for me are usually referred to when playing a series of notes, such as a swing phrase
Yes it's where the tongue is damping the reed, can be either rhythmic (as in my example here) or held for longer as an effect. Neither are anything to do with subtone but let's just agree to differ. Perhaps those teachers that think it's the same are confusing it with subtonguing - another the many words used for the effect of damping with the tongue.


when i listen to Ben Webster, Coleman Hawkins or Stan Getz i don't hear a complete lack of overtones. I hear a rich voovvv sound with a lot of breath....

To me "voovv is all to do with the articulation where the breath is very obvious because the note itself is quieter than when tongued. And hence the perception of more breath.

Maybe that's why you don't perceive the alto track above with Buescher and Grafton as subtone, I am tonguing the notes so no breathiness or voooovv. You often get that with subtone but for me it isn't the defining factor which is the tone itself.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but without
Nor me I had misread you and thought you said there was some so I thought maybe there was but too subtle for me to hear on the phone.


Yes it's where the tongue is damping the reed, can be either rhythmic (as in my example here) or held for longer as an effect. Neither are anything to do with subtone but let's just agree to differ. Perhaps those teachers that think it's the same are confusing it with subtonguing - another the many words used for the effect of damping with the tongue.




To me "voovv is all to do with the articulation where the breath is very obvious because the note itself is quieter than when tongued. And hence the perception of more breath.

Maybe that's why you don't perceive the alto track above with Buescher and Grafton as subtone, I am tonguing the notes so no breathiness or voooovv. You often get that with subtone but for me it isn't the defining factor which is the tone itself.
But without those markers, to me, I'm not really hearing subtone on that track. Sounds like an alto. Overtones and all. Maybe much less than your regular sound?

Also I'm pretty sure i can get those aspects, the voov and the breath, without articulating. Next time in in the shed I'll try it!
 
Neither are anything to do with subtone but let's just agree to differ. Perhaps those teachers that think it's the same are confusing it with subtonguing - another the many words used for the effect of damping with the tongue.
No that's fine; I think here I just wouldn't refer to it as ghost tonguing for a held note, to me it's just an implied note that you don't really hear. But that may be my definition that's too narrow, hence why I didn't object as much as when they were saying that is a way to achieve subtone.

One of the folk that has used this description is Dave Pollack, so I'm going to ask him to discuss further.

But the effect of sound was very similar when I played earlier (though awkward and very uncomfortable for me.) And sounds very very different to your example of doodn tonguing which is how I understand that.

So: it appears maybe I don't really understand, or perhaps even hear (as with the Patrick Bartley example above - it just sounds like he's playing softer to me) subtone. And what I think of subtone is something else entirely. That just also happens to be a technique that Ben Webster uses (the sizzle of air, the vvvvooo articulation etc). Or perhaps there's a way of dulling the reed with your tongue that is subtone and is different from the technique you're demonstrating.
 
I think a subtone either has lower high frequencies or it has fewer of them. It is a warmer, soft sound.

Subtone to me means that lush sound with no higher partials and just the low fundamental.
I'm a bit doubtful about that. If you take away the higher partials altogether, you get a sine wave, which is anything but velvety-sounding. I've always thought a subtone had something klike white noise mixed in, ie untuned sounds like brushes on a snare drum, so that the overall pitch of the note is less sharply defined. But then. I can't really play with subtone (yet 🙂), so what do I know?
 
But without those markers, to me, I'm not really hearing subtone on that track. Sounds like an alto.
Well I think it's fair to say that any subtone is more obvious the lower the note. because you are getting more of the fundamental and the lower the note the wider and fatter sounding the fundamental is. Hence on alto I think any sunstone is less obvious, and I would also say that in regard to Johnny Hodges & Paul Desmond.

On alto subtone is less obvious than it is on tenor. And on tenor it is most obvious on notes lower than Eb. Any use of tongueless articulation (some people call it foofoo accentuates the subtone and also the sound of the breath as the note itself creeps in gradually. It's also more obvious at the end when notes trail off leaving just the breath.
 
That just also happens to be a technique that Ben Webster uses (the sizzle of air, the vvvvooo articulation etc).
Ah now I understand where that comes from. Notes can be ghosted and to me that is usually accidental, like the note doesn't quite speak.


I think here I just wouldn't refer to it as ghost tonguing for a held note, to me it's just an implied note that you don't really hear.
Ghost tonguing on a held note often sounds a dampened note as oppose to implied note that is more or less silent or pitches. People find this when transcribing you can hear a gap where a note didn't quite speak. So it can either be an intended effect or an unintended effect.

Some fine examples of both here in the second chorus at about 26 seconds. And not a subtone in sight.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foPwsp-Blds




Or perhaps there's a way of dulling the reed with your tongue that is subtone and is different from the technique you're demonstrating.
That's where I disagree, there is no correlation between subtone and ghost tonguing. They can of course be done at the same time but one doesn't cause the other or necessarily be involved with the other. I think I already said that though and agreed to disagree 🙂

John was talking about "voovv" which I understand totally and is often when you start a note without any tongue at all. By itself it isn't subtone but it accentuates the subtone due to the more audible great sound when you do it.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,326
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom