Playing the saxophone What exactly is subtone?

I was prompted by the SOTW discussion to try a technique I had never tried before, to play the low notes while lightly cushioning the reed with a flat tongue, without consciously changing embouchure. The resulting sound is not breathy, but is muffled, (soft and fluffy) lacking the bright higher partials. Whether that classifies as "subtone" terminologically is up to you.
 
Whether that classifies as "subtone" terminologically is up to you.
Not really because it is wrong terminology. That is not subtone, which is a type of tone technique. What you are referring to is an articulation effect known variously as ghost tonguing, dooden tonguing, half tonging and even lala tonguing:

 
I am not sure about this either but even with normal playing, does the reed ever close fully against the tip rail? I know I can force it but then it chokes.
This is from Larry Teal:

In April 1941 the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America published an article by two physicists C.S. McGuinness and C. Gallagher, who had succeeded in photographing the time and motion of a single reed while in the process of tone production. The results of this experiment showed the reed functioning as a valve which emits "puffs" of air into the instrument, and also forms an airtight seal during half of the time of each vibrating cycle.
 
Last edited:
This is from Larry Teal:

In April 1941 the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America published an article by two physicists C.S. McGuinness and C. Gallagher, who had succeeded in photographing the time and motion of a single reed while in the process of tone production. The results of this experiment showed the read functioning as a valve which emits "puffs" of air into the instrument, and also forms an airtight seal during half of the time of each vibrating cycle.
Thanks Pete, always glad to learn something fact-based new.
 
Does anyone know the etymology of the term subtone, or have any early references referring to it? Not that the the word itself is so elusive, but I'm curious how it was described over time and what involvement breath had in the definition if any.
 
Does anyone know the etymology of the term subtone, or have any early references referring to it? Not that the the word itself is so elusive, but I'm curious how it was described over time and what involvement breath had in the definition if any.
 
One definition:
webster.com/dictionary/subtone
Mirriam-Webster said:
subtone 1 of 2 noun ˈsəb+ˌ-
: undertone

subtone 2 of 2 adjective
: relating to or constituting clarinet playing especially of popular music in which the tones are played very softly and usually in the lower register with little wind pressure from the player

Word History
Etymology Noun
sub- + tone
I just noticed that if you click on the link, it defaults to the dictionary opening page, but typing "subtone" in their box and hitting "Enter" will bring up the above information.
 
This is fun though, on clarinet it's just described as extreme pianissimo.
Not a whiff of breathiness there. I think the idea of breathiness in the subtone is maybe a red herring as it is somthing you can have or not.

If it is literally the air from the players breath then it will be most apparent at the start if the articulation is more of an F than a T or at the end as the actual note fades but breath is still there. Or else it is escaping breath that dorsnt enter the mouthpiece.

I think this is mostly what people mean when they say breathy, not that it’s part of the tone
 
Not a whiff of breathiness there. I think the idea of breathiness in the subtone is maybe a red herring as it is somthing you can have or not.

If it is literally the air from the players breath then it will be most apparent at the start if the articulation is more of an F than a T or at the end as the actual note fades but breath is still there. Or else it is escaping breath that dorsnt enter the mouthpiece.

I think this is mostly what people mean when they say breathy, not that it’s part of the tone
Sure, but to be fair, clarinetists aren't altering the tone in any way. They are merely playing ppppp. So, in my viewpoint, it doesn't really match either saxophonic description.

Just to show I'm not crazy, here's Patrick Bartley describing it as a breathy, vouvou sound.
View: https://youtu.be/MCUtuNdKXb0?si=IVkiINsdcWPuj5Oq&t=48


Anyway, I had the thought that I couldn't play a subtone without breath with my setup because it was too hard so I slapped a 1.5 on my Link 13 and I was able to get it. Not overly pretty, but it's there.

View: https://soundcloud.com/gj-dikeman/subtone-no-breath/s-yd2M9ka9M0l?si=a0c84554a1e54bdf830f645dfdb4e928&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing
 
Sure, but to be fair, clarinetists aren't altering the tone in any way. They are merely playing ppppp. So, in my viewpoint, it doesn't really match either saxophonic description.
And I was quite surprised when i saw clarinet mentioned in the Wikipedia article.
Anyway, I had the thought that I couldn't play a subtone without breath with my setup because it was too hard so I slapped a 1.5 on my Link 13 and I was able to get it. Not overly pretty, but it's there.
I listened to the recording. Its a very nice well controlled sound but isn’t what i would immediately think of as subtone if you hadn’t mentioned it. It isn't overly bright, but then if its a Link that is to be expected.

But to me there us still a touch of edge that I don't associate with subtone.
 
Ha, well if that's not it, I think I'm out of luck.
Well, it's relative to your normal sound right? To be clear, I was alternating between pure tone and subtone.

If you have a minute, and the will, sometime could you make a quick clip like that, alternating between pure tone and a subtone without breath?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,199
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom