I keep a couple of Hemke in the ato case, for emergencies. They're very consistent. Never great. Never bad. Just consistently and reliably mediocre. But they always blow.
I have an alto sax Selmer S90-190. It is a very versatile mouthpiece, capable of projection yet also maintain control over dynamics where required. I love it.
Everyone's embouchure is different, what suits one may not suit another. This is why there is a great variety of mouthpieces and options within certain models. But for others, perhaps in their particular situation, it does not suit one's embouchure and playing style as well as others?
Could you further clarify how the Selmer S90 (including which option you have) has a modicrum of mediocrity? It may help others in selecting mouthpieces to try.
I have an alto sax Selmer S90-190. It is a very versatile mouthpiece, capable of projection yet also maintain control over dynamics where required. I love it.
Everyone's embouchure is different, what suits one may not suit another. This is why there is a great variety of mouthpieces and options within certain models. But for others, perhaps in their particular situation, it does not suit one's embouchure and playing style as well as others?
Could you further clarify how the Selmer S90 (including which option you have) has a modicrum of mediocrity? It may help others in selecting mouthpieces to try.
I had a 180 tenor. It was stuffy or quacky with most of my reeds but a very easy blow with the Hemke with a decent tone on an SA80. I don’t know the particular properties of the Hemke over VanDs and Ricos but it seemed to get on with the S90 which is supposed to be a jazzier mpc than the S80.
I’m not the only one who had this problem, search the forum and you’ll find at least two other critiques. YMMV as they say.
The DC 2.5s arrived today. Feel harder to blow than the DC2s, a bit harder than the RR 2.5s. I used it for about 10 minutes before going back to the 2s and will try again tomorrow.
The sound is delicious (even from me!). I felt it sounded deeper, richer and more complex but I had to work on the low C, B & Bb, not so much the voicing but ensuring good air support. The octave key and palm key notes were sweet.
So far I've tried Vandoren Blue, Rico Royal and Alexander DC and I think I will be staying with the DCs for the foreseeable future.
The DC 2.5s arrived today. Feel harder to blow than the DC2s, a bit harder than the RR 2.5s. I used it for about 10 minutes before going back to the 2s and will try again tomorrow.
The sound is delicious (even from me!). I felt it sounded deeper, richer and more complex but I had to work on the low C, B & Bb, not so much the voicing but ensuring good air support. The octave key and palm key notes were sweet.
So far I've tried Vandoren Blue, Rico Royal and Alexander DC and I think I will be staying with the DCs for the foreseeable future.
I followed the above instructions. After a soak I flattened the back with my ersatz reed geek and played scales and arpeggios for about 10 minutes. I'll repeat tomorrow for a little longer. I'll also rotate the other 4 doing the same for each new one.
I noticed this on the blurb: A tendency of these reeds is to harden a little after a few days of playing, so you may find a slightly softer reed that will end up being perfect in a few days after break in.
Interestingly when I went back to the DC2s today I thought they sounded better than yesterday and weren't closing up!
I mostly use Jazz Selects. The ones that are my current ones are stored in an airtight plastic box with an amount of vodka. There are always rather more than I need in each box (1 box each for SATB). They’ve often been in there for a number of years. Especially the ones that aren’t Jazz Select (Vandoren, La Vox, etc.). When they eventually die, after many months usually, they get replaced by new ones straight out of the box. I haven’t worked on a reed for over 30 years and I don’t have reed problems. The one major thing that has changed over the years is my preference for reed strength. They’ve got softer and softer. I can’t remember the last time I discarded a reed from the box.
I do not break reeds in; rather I adjust them for balance immediately and play them. I find this obviates the need (real or imagined) for break in. Occasionally a reed will harden slightly after first play. This is usually due to a slight warp in the back, which causes a slight leak at the table or window.
I don’t think I d ever broken reeds in, it seems a bit complicated to me. But then neither have I ever rotated them. It seems I am not your normal saxophone player. But then I survived as a professional for a reasonable amount of time .
I do just like you do, @skeller047 and @Pete Thomas , basically play them right out of the box. If too soft, then I will nip the tip with a reed clipper.
If at band practise or out playing, then put it in a reed guard. When I was more active practising at home, I'd leave the reed on the mouthpiece, place sax on a stand. To rewet, remove the neck without affecting adjustments, dip the whole tip into a cup of water. Remount, let it sit for about 10 - 15 minutes, then play.
until it was worn out, replace with new. In this case, it got rotated (to the bin) when worn. (What's one down out of 25 in a box?)😉
When I am running short of reeds, then go back to the non-playables and rework. If rework doesn't work, then bin them.
My habits would probably drive an (O)bsessive (C)umpulsive (D)isorder ( - (O)bstinate (C)offin (D)odger for the senior ) person batty, who is used to complete meticulous order in purchasing, inventorying, storing, rotating, maintaining and disposing of reeds properly in accordance to all applicable regulations and school taught practises.
Please understand that I am not criticising or pointing the finger at any member of the Café community, just trying to keep things light by adding a little humour.😉
I don’t think I d ever broken reeds in, it seems a bit complicated to me. But then neither have I ever rotated them. It seems I am not your normal saxophone player. But then I survived as a professional for a reasonable amount of time .
I've no idea whether breaking in reeds or rotating them is necessary. There must be several threads arguing the toss on here and elsewhere. So many variables.......
@Pete Thomas you've been playing and a pro for years and can do things I only dream of! For me this is all such a steep learning curve. I thought you just put the thing in your mouth, blew and twiddled your fingers......now it's all reed brands, strengths, cuts, mpcs, mpc tip sizes, lays, baffles, chambers.......what do I know?????
My "break in" is to wet a new reed enough to play it for about 5-10 minutes, let it dry in a reed case, then flatten the back after it dries. That takes care of any swelling or distortion that occurs with first play. I seal the tubules with light pressure while the reed is wet, then polish top and back with paper because I like the smooth feel. I prefer to play with the ligature only snug (vs tight). Necessary? I don't care. It's my ritual.
For me this is all such a steep learning curve. I thought you just put the thing in your mouth, blew and twiddled your fingers......now it's all reed brands, strengths, cuts, mpcs, mpc tip sizes, lays, baffles, chambers.......what do I know?????
Some of the info you mention is background information. It helps one to understand the mechanics involved so they can select starting and advancement points as they progress. Reed strengths are a combination of mouthpiece tip opening and one's particular embouchure, every one's is different.
Interestingly during community band practise, the new tenorist next to me plays with a brighter tone than I do. And, this is even my using a Bari (brand name) tenor mouthpiece that is IMO roughly equivalent to a Yamaha 5C but less than half the price. (This is just a rough guesstimate on my part based on both specifications as listed in catalogues.) I have a softer, mellower tone more copacetic with jazz playing. (IMO this softer mellower tone works well as ensemble bottom end with the flutes, oboe and clarinets.)
But, personally I have found that the so-called "beginner's" mouthpiece still has a place, if nothing else, acts as a backup mouthpiece in case the "prized" one accidentally gets dropped and shatters, or a metal one is dropped and tip is dented.
I know this as a fact because I have broken a couple mouthpieces both clarinet and sax during my lifetime. Accidents do happen.
I don’t think I d ever broken reeds in, it seems a bit complicated to me. But then neither have I ever rotated them. It seems I am not your normal saxophone player. But then I survived as a professional for a reasonable amount of time .
I never rotated reeds either, other than for a hot minute on one tour where I had to cover so much ground / range on tenor and couldn't afford a gig with a blown-out reed. I do think that it's an excellent idea, but I didn't even do it in my classical clarinet days.
I've no idea whether breaking in reeds or rotating them is necessary. There must be several threads arguing the toss on here and elsewhere. So many variables.......
Yes, lots of "voodoo" when it comes to reeds. I like to prepare/work on reeds, It's maybe more the meditative feeling I'm searching for than perfect reeds? A candle on the table, coffee, nice music in the background, the tools and light board are ready .... then I relize that I have forgotten I'm playing Plasticovers. But just on tenor.
Interestingly during community band practise, the new tenorist next to me plays with a brighter tone than I do. And, this is even my using a Bari (brand name) tenor mouthpiece that is IMO roughly equivalent to a Yamaha 5C but less than half the price. (This is just a rough guesstimate on my part based on both specifications as listed in catalogues.) I have a softer, mellower tone more copacetic with jazz playing. (IMO this softer mellower tone works well as ensemble bottom end with the flutes, oboe and clarinets.)
But, personally I have found that the so-called "beginner's" mouthpiece still has a place, if nothing else, acts as a backup mouthpiece in case the "prized" one accidentally gets dropped and shatters, or a metal one is dropped and tip is dented.
I know this as a fact because I have broken a couple mouthpieces both clarinet and sax during my lifetime. Accidents do happen.
Many people have more than one good mouthpiece. If I carry a backup mouthpiece, it is one that I can count on to play as well as my #1. Aside: I have dropped exactly one mouthpiece in 50+ years. I can still see my Morgan 3C bouncing on the saltillo tiles of my Santa Fe kitchen almost 30 years ago. That piece was refaced by Ed Zentera and remains my favorite piece for classical saxophone quartet. I bought another 6C from Morgan, but, after not using it for ~15 years, sold it on.
Used the DC 2.5 again today and it was easier to blow and sounded good.
Is my embouchure improving or just the reed breaking in ?
Who knows? Who cares? It works.
I do just like you do, @skeller047 and @Pete Thomas , basically play them right out of the box. If too soft, then I will nip the tip with a reed clipper.
If at band practise or out playing, then put it in a reed guard. When I was more active practising at home, I'd leave the reed on the mouthpiece, place sax on a stand. To rewet, remove the neck without affecting adjustments, dip the whole tip into a cup of water. Remount, let it sit for about 10 - 15 minutes, then play.
until it was worn out, replace with new. In this case, it got rotated (to the bin) when worn. (What's one down out of 25 in a box?)😉
When I am running short of reeds, then go back to the non-playables and rework. If rework doesn't work, then bin them.
My habits would probably drive an (O)bsessive (C)umpulsive (D)isorder ( - (O)bstinate (C)offin (D)odger for the senior ) person batty, who is used to complete meticulous order in purchasing, inventorying, storing, rotating, maintaining and disposing of reeds properly in accordance to all applicable regulations and school taught practises.
Please understand that I am not criticising or pointing the finger at any member of the Café community, just trying to keep things light by adding a little humour.😉
+1 for soaking new reeds for 5 -10 minutes before playing. I still do this at rehearsals for new reds. Usually 2 at a time. I try 1 and if this feel comfortable playing, I try the 2nd one and pick the best of the 2. I picked up this tip from sadly deceased member @jbtsax who used to tell his young band students who were 'squeaking' on new reeds to go soak their reeds for 5 minutes in water. In his experience, it was usually an instant cure.
Very occasionally, I dig out an old piece of fine sandpaper from my sax bag and maybe just marginally adjust a soaked new reed on a flat surface.
When I first joined the café as a beginner, I read some threads on 'caring for reeds'. Including soaking them in water (or alcohol), breaking them in, grading them (from soft to hard) and adjusting the ones the could be adjusted to make them 'playable'. Rotating them too.
Fast forward and I've become much less 'attentive' to reeds. I've a reed brand and strength that I play pretty much (after 5 minutes soaking) out of the box. I still carry a 4-reed box around with 'my current reed', an 'OK' reed which (even if slightly chipped) I can play quit well on, and 2 others which are either 'emergency reeds', unknown reeds or both.
I keep posting these links on the café but an article on 'reed placement and adjustment' by Steven Mauk, Professor Emeritus, Music Performance (Speciality Saxophone) at the ITHICA college completely changed my whole outlook on 'reed adjustment'.
In summary, his (tutorial) article says that the very first (and most effective) 'reed adjustment' is the fine adjustment of the reed on the mpc and - secondary - the adjustment of the ligature on the mpc./reed. For me, his article was a total eye-opener and I've used the principles of his article ever since reading it. At each and every rehearsal or performance. It's made such a difference to making different reeds 'optimally playable'! Not by sanding or clipping but just by minutely adjusting the position of the reed and possibly the lig.
Steven Mauk has a whole list of (downloadable) publications on 'saxophone playing' to his name and for the sake of completeness, you can find the list at 'Steven Mauk publications'
Thank you. I received the same advice and have been doing so. It was the same in martial arts, learn a pattern bit by bit and practice it slowly and only speed up a bit more when you can do it without thinking or hesitation.