Reeds What a difference a brand of reed makes

I do not break reeds in; rather I adjust them for balance immediately and play them. I find this obviates the need (real or imagined) for break in. Occasionally a reed will harden slightly after first play. This is usually due to a slight warp in the back, which causes a slight leak at the table or window.
Was it you or someone else that mention the current orange box D'Addario Rico reeds are not as good as earlier?

I started using a new box of 25 #2's. Usually I find these acceptable on my tenor mouthpieces, tweak with a reed clipper if need be. The reed plays fine for the first 20 - 30 minutes. Then acts like it is "soggy", like a worn out reed. This is consistent oddly enough.

The machining of the reed is good, up to a light source it seems reasonably cut, consistent. I think it is the quality of the reed material, appears softer instead of stouter like the older stock, paler in colour.

The old ones IMO were manufactured of specially bred "European" reeds. (And please note, I don't keep up with this stuff to know all the specifics if when and how on manufacturing.) I've got my stuff packed away on a pending move, so need to relocate the box I packed all the new reeds in. The old had better colour definition, would last until worn out.

I had a similar experience when I was purchasing "no name" bargain reeds from the Orient on E-Bay about a decade ago ($10 US or less for 10). Those were made of inferior reed stock.

I know the court is out and I don't mean to unfairly criticise a brand until sufficient use is in. Has anyone else experienced my observations?
 
Reed production varies with the growing season, year to year.

I used vandoren blue for decades but they became unreliable and inconsistent. I searched and changed to Rico Select. They again changed when Daddario took them over. I had quite a stock but began once more searching. I ended up back on Vandoren blue. Which are, at the moment, marvelous.
 
Yes, I hear you, @Colin the Bear .

Some years back, around 1974 or thereabouts, remember reed players discussing how current reed crop was not as good as before, growers were having a problem with good weather, etc. So there were a few QC issues where it seems more reeds in a box were disposable.

Then we had our choice, it was either the standard Rico's or La Voz in cardboard box or Vandurens in plastic purple box (think it was 10 per box for Rico / La Voz and 8 per box for Vanduren) from our "office supplies" shelf with my band. (No one I knew of then abused that situation.) 😀

How many today would love that situation, just freely pull a box off a shelf in the size you need? 😉
 
As a
Reeds really do make a huge difference. Strength, cut, tip thickness, the lot. And the only way to work out what works for you is to try loads, which is an expensive proposition.

I tend to think that most folk who go to synthetics do that too quickly without trying a whole bunch of other cane reeds, brands, cuts and strengths first.

I generally hate Rico/D'Addario reeds. They just don't work for me. Neither do Vandoren. Rigotti (also make BSS which I now use), Marca (who make Alexander and Pisoni I think) and Gonzalez are all more consistent and more responsive, and then it's just a case of dialling in the strength.

As I've been playing more the last few years that strength has increased: and I've tweaked the cuts as I want to mould my sound differently.
When I started playing sax during the pandemic was very curious about everything sax. Bought my brands, strengthen of reeds.

Eventually found out as a hobbyist sax player I craved simplicity.

So I decided on Legere synthetic reeds.

I am playing Legere 2.25 strength on French Cut and American cut reeds on my alto sax.

Waiting to receive a Bundy II Tenor sax from a local tech . Have ordered Legere reeds in the same cuts and strengths.
 
Was it you or someone else that mention the current orange box D'Addario Rico reeds are not as good as earlier?
I have said that, so it may well have been me. My experience is that the spine/heart on the current Rico brand reeds is short and weak compared to Rico from the 1980’s and earlier. I suspect this was done to make them easier to play for beginners and young students. This may also account for your experience of them becoming mushy after a short time playing - an experience I share, which is why I don’t recommend them.
 
I suspect this was done to make them easier to play for beginners and young students.
Easier? Perhaps, but if I am having problems with the reed, then others IMO would too. (Along a similar vein, if a student is given an intermediate or professional level sax to play, because they are easier and "more ergonomic" in the hands and finger tips, plays better in tune, is a boost to an avid learner, IMO.)
 
I made a very early decision playing Ricos and Rico Royals back in the 90s that they were terrible. Any flirts with them at a later date has just continued to confirm that opinion.

I've never had the chance to try some NOS orange box.
The orange, ealier brown wood box, Rico were not well made but it was possible turn them to decent playing reeds. IMO; the reeds we buy today are much better compared to reeds we bought in the 60' and 70's. I have many Rico (brown wood boxes) reeds that we couldn't sell.
 
Last edited:
The orange, ealier brown wood box, Rico were not well made but it was possible turn them to decent playing reeds. IMO; the reeds we buy today are much better compared to reeds we bought in the 60' and 70's. I have many Rico (brown wood boxes) reeds that we couldn't sell.
If those reeds are in intact boxes, you can likely sell them on eBay. Or here in the marketplace 🙂 If they are in the most desirable sizes (2 1/2, 3 or 3 1/2), they will sell quickly. Size 5’s, not so much.

I agree that reeds today are better made and more consistent. I rarely throw a reed out these days, but those older Ricos had poor QC. Every box of 25 had at least 2, and often more, as many as 5, reeds that were so badly made they would never play. Bark all the way up one side of the vamp, stock paper thin on one side, or thin at the back, deformations in the surface of the cane that went so deep they showed up as visible twists in the vamp. But most of the reeds were well cut, and once adjusted, played like a dream.

Note that in the 1970s and 80s, Vandoren only had one cut of reed; some players liked Vandoren saxophone reeds, most did not. I’m talking jazz and pop/rock players; classical folks mostly used Vandoren. Interestingly, most working pros at that time used Vandoren on clarinet, with a few folks using Mitchell Lurie or Hemke (both Rico products). Vandoren clarinet reeds also suffered from occasional deformities, but not to the degree that Rico saxophone reeds did.
 
If those reeds are in intact boxes, you can likely sell them on eBay. Or here in the marketplace 🙂 If they are in the most desirable sizes (2 1/2, 3 or 3 1/2), they will sell quickly. Size 5’s, not so much.
Not sealed boxes, then I wouldn't be sure that it was a bad reed. Every reed we sold landed on a light table so we could see if it was an ok reed. I bought the bad reeds and tried to make them better .... then I gave the reeds to sax teachers that taught in public music school. They were often complainig that reeds was a problem. Some parents didn't understand, or cared?, if the children had ok reeds. I'm a person that like to give! I can make a soft reed harder and hard reed softer. It's about time.
 
The old Ricos you didn’t need a light table to see which ones were bad.

I was taught to hold reeds up to the light to judge them, and back in the day, when I bought individual reeds, I did that. I later learned that holding reeds up to the light didn’t really tell me anything. I’ve had too many reeds that looked bad and played great, and vice versa. Nowadays I reserve judgement until I play it.
 
The desk where we had the light board was in the middle of the shop and I also live in a country when it's getting dark around 3.00 -4.00 pm during autumn, winter, ... I also hold the the plexiglas piece, with the reed, against the daylight but when It's dark I use some kind of light. The symmetrical upside down "V" is important. Also that the reed are filed (cut) in a symmetric way. Reeds with uneven stocks ended up in the bad box. It's like to judge timber/wood. A reed is just smaller.

After the "visual inspection" the reeds were placed in "cardboard holder". The "visual inspection" was not 100 %, you have to play the reed as well. If a reed didn't play well you could start to do the reed work.
 
Last edited:
Back in the day, we used to look at reeds and select or reject on appearance.I've seen reeds that were unevenly cut, with a skew whiff stock and uneven rays along the vamp and discoloured bark that play great.

You really can't tell anything about the playability of a new reed by looking.
Yeah me too - some look imbalanced and darker on one side. Can’t recall it being a predictor for reed performance.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom