Reeds What a difference a brand of reed makes

Tenors are generally easier to 'blow' than altos.
Everyone's embouchure is different. I love them all, but have a preference for alto, because its range lends itself to soloing, although I love the bari for its gritty sound and fantastic voicing range, sounds great through out. But on some songs, the haunting sound of the soprano just lends a smiling to listeners, also a great instrument.

(But prior to Covid, at a Salvation Army Divisional retreat at Glorietta, New Mexico (near Santa Fe), I was tasked with providing the offeratory music solo on the tenor sax. There was maybe a crowd of 500 in their auditorium. I let my Venus Tenor sing playing the song, Change My Heart O, God, a lovely ballad. Because the audience loved it, they allowed me to play a few extra stanzas of it. There was a small backing band of trap set, bass and rhythm guitars, keyboard, singers and a few instrumentalists. The crowd loved it.)
Reeds vary enormously. I had a wind band rehearsal some years ago and the reed failed. So I got the next new one out of the box and it was unplayable - it was as stiff as a plank. Got another new one out and it was OK.
In general and this goes back to the early 1970's when I had bulk boxes of 8 and up. Even among the purple box Van Durens in both clarinet and sax, would find a few in each box that either needed further work or just had to bin, ditto with Rico, La Voz, etc.

Even though they are not as fancy cut as some other reeds like Van Duren, I've found them totally satisfactory for my playing. I view more in the quality of the reed wood along with how well the face is cut.

In general I am using softer cuts, will sometimes opt for the 1.5's, because interestingly I have found them more frequently on sale, plus I have decent SATB reed trimmers to increase their strength to my satisfaction, plus using wider tipped mouthpieces require softer grades to be able to flex that wider gap.

The softer means they wear out more quickly. Back then when I was practising roughly 4 hours a day, I'd wear reeds about every 2.5 weeks. I rotated them (well, sort of) :w00t:, got out a new one in that time frame. 😉
 
I keep a couple of Hemke in the ato case, for emergencies. They're very consistent. Never great. Never bad. Just consistently and reliably mediocre. But they always blow.
Sounds like the brand, Lade. I bought two boxes of 10, 2.5's for alto around $12 maybe 5 years ago. They aren't the greatest reeds. Some don't play. Those that do, they do OK. They are more like an emergency reed.
 
Reeds really do make a huge difference. Strength, cut, tip thickness, the lot. And the only way to work out what works for you is to try loads, which is an expensive proposition.

I tend to think that most folk who go to synthetics do that too quickly without trying a whole bunch of other cane reeds, brands, cuts and strengths first.

I generally hate Rico/D'Addario reeds. They just don't work for me. Neither do Vandoren. Rigotti (also make BSS which I now use), Marca (who make Alexander and Pisoni I think) and Gonzalez are all more consistent and more responsive, and then it's just a case of dialling in the strength.

As I've been playing more the last few years that strength has increased: and I've tweaked the cuts as I want to mould my sound differently.
 
Today I tried a Vandoren Blue 2, a Rico Royal 2.5 and the AlexDC 2.

The VB2 was quite 'classical', the RR less so but the RR sounded duller* to me, but I am used to them so no surprises. * I think that particular RR reed is tired, usually they are quite nice.

The DC was easier to blow and more 'jazzy', hard to describe...almost slightly metallic/buzzy and had nice round low notes, and the D wasn't dull. I had to take care not to go wild and change pitch so some embouchure and voicing adjustment needed.

Just my take, different sax, mpcs and mouths might not agree.
So many brands and types to try, another variable in the quest to get that sound.
 
It has been a real effort for me not to try different reeds, as I feel at this point I have other things to occupy myself with (to each their own of course). However I did a few months ago go down a half step in reed strength, from Vandoren blue 2.5 to 2, and that was a big improvement as far as making it easier to break new reeds in and not struggle against too hard reeds.
 
In the other hand, last September I switched to legere.. actually I got two noticably different cuts... I noticed the other day that I'm now equally comfortable on both and as comfortable as all but the stiffest reeds I've used. Took a while (I'm not sure how long). Maybe I'm not that discerning
 
Today I tried a Vandoren Blue 2, a Rico Royal 2.5 and the AlexDC 2.

The VB2 was quite 'classical', the RR less so but the RR sounded duller* to me, but I am used to them so no surprises. * I think that particular RR reed is tired, usually they are quite nice.

The DC was easier to blow and more 'jazzy', hard to describe...almost slightly metallic/buzzy and had nice round low notes, and the D wasn't dull. I had to take care not to go wild and change pitch so some embouchure and voicing adjustment needed.

Just my take, different sax, mpcs and mouths might not agree.
So many brands and types to try, another variable in the quest to get that sound.
That DC2 is less stiff than either the Blue or RR, so it’s no surprise that it was an easier blow. I like the buzz of that style of cut.

Enjoy the path.
 
@cappers I am following your posts (and replying to some) with great interest. You are a true seeker and that’s inspiring to me!

Regarding reeds, once you settle on a brand and strength you want to stay with for a while, you will certainly find that not every reed in a box is the same. At that point you may want to learn to adjust reeds to suit your preferred sound and response. When you get to that point, don’t stress too much, there are at least 4 times as many ways to “fix up” reeds as there are saxophonists, so try to keep it simple.

Me, I like D’Addario Select Jazz and Rigotti Jazz (The Blue One) and if I had to pick a reed to stay with forever at this point it would probably be one of those. I really like the old pre-D’Addario Ricos, and while I have many of those in my stash, I can’t recommend them because the new Ricos aren’t cut the same and there is no guaranteed supply of the old ones.
 
@skeller047 Thank you for your kind words.

I can't think of anything I've done in my life (from travelling overland to India in the early 70s, getting my Doctorate, black belts in jujitsu, fossil collecting, photography, and a great career as a scientist and lecturer *) that has given me as much pleasure as learning to play the saxophone!

I have always loved listening to music and envied those who can make it, so it is great that I can aspire to join the band as it were. I have the time, the commitment and the enthusiasm, and I appear to be making some progress. We are going to fortnightly lessons now and I will be having an extra couple of hours a week practice with the community band.


Finally (sorry for the long rambling post) regarding reeds, I'll stick to the DCs for now, my teacher said I sounded good on them and my last D'Addario/Rico Royals have been a bit variable, a couple sounded 'flabby. I might check out the D’Addario Select Jazz and Rigotti Jazz reeds in the future.
Thanks for your encouragement!

*Edited to include in my list of greatest of life's pleasures, my wife, children and grandchildren!
 
Last edited:
I vaguely remember in the early 1970's, discussion with my woodwind musician friends about a few years that the "reed crop" suffered, so manufacturers were using what they had to work with, reed quality suffered. On the other side of the pond, are there any here who played sax or clarinet around that time, could shed more light?

Then it just seemed that there were more bad reeds in a box than at other times.

Had an interesting experience with the latest D'Addario Rico orange box reeds. New reed after being wet and settled in played fine initially at start of community band practise, but then after about 25 minutes playing, went sour on me like it was water logged mush for the last half hour.

I've had this happen to a few before, more the exception than the rule. (With one no longer available Oriental brand, it was more the rule than the exception, paid under $10 US for a box of 10.) Most settle in and play well.

I'll keep on eye on them, @Colin the Bear . For a while prior to Covid, I was buying NOS (new old stock) orange box reeds, they were definitely well cured, a high percentage were players, was for a while buying them on E-Bay for a reasonable price, but of course over time the sources dried up.

I have noticed price creep on reeds. 40-50 years ago, was buying alto sax and clarinet reeds from local music stores like Harry's Music Store in the Kaimuki District of Honolulu back in high school and in college. AFAIK, they were like 25¢, 35¢ US each, a little more in college.
 
Thank you! Personally I feel I should be doing better but I am very self critical.
I find the tenor mpc more manageable then the alto one, just put it in and blow...big mouth? :rofl:
Maybe that's why I've always played just tenor sax :rofl:.

More seriously (without yet having read the thread!), 5 months into learning to play (tenor) sax, I couldn't imagine wanting to learn to play a different sax at that time. Mainly because I quickly realised how much more I still had to learn about playing (tenor) sax. So I just wonder whether learning to play both tenor and alto saxes together helps or hinders your sax learning.
 
Maybe that's why I've always played just tenor sax :rofl:.

More seriously (without yet having read the thread!), 5 months into learning to play (tenor) sax, I couldn't imagine wanting to learn to play a different sax at that time. Mainly because I quickly realised how much more I still had to learn about playing (tenor) sax. So I just wonder whether learning to play both tenor and alto saxes together helps or hinders your sax learning.
Good question! I have had different opinions from different people :rolleyes: Some say 'master' one before the other, some say playing each will help develop on both. I think that although they are basically the same, the tenor and alto are different in respect to embouchure, breath control, ergonomics and voicing.

I wanted a tenor in the first place and now I have one I haven't really played the alto. I'm now 71 and it'll take several years to reach my goal of playing well or at least adequately so I feel that I would rather spend my time and effort getting 'good' on the tenor, as it is the sound I prefer and somehow I find it easier than the alto.
 
Back to reeds.........I have used and rotated all 5 Alexander Superial DC 2 reeds this week (Yamaha 5C mpc).

Although I like their ease of blow and their sound I noticed last night at band practice and today at home that they were sounding a bit flabby and closed up occasionally. I tried adjusting my embouchure, mouthpiece angle and the amount in my mouth but still wasn't happy with the sound or behaviour.

I don't think it is my embouchure (?!) and wonder if I should go up to DC 2.5? I am used to Vandoren Blue 2 and Rico Royal 2.5.

Thank you in advance.
 
Still on the Yamaha 5C?

Yes, a DC 2.5 is a reasonable step for now. I wouldn’t be surprised if you go to a 3.0 in the next few months on that tip opening. You’ll eventually find your balance point (embouchure, air support, mouthpiece chamber/tip). For what it’s worth, a very common setup for tenor is a medium chamber, medium tip (0.105”), and a medium (2.5/3.0) reed.

You may prefer a slightly smaller tip with a stiffer reed for similar perceived resistance. Others like larger tip openings for enhanced flexibility in tone and pitch, and may offset that with a less stiff reed.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,382
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom