Saxophones Vintage sax as your main instrument?

Thanks. One more question, maybe for @fabriziodalisera or @turf3 or anyone who plays a Conn 12M. View attachment 25452One key I had real problems with was the left-hand pinky G# key - I found it really heavy and almost impossible play without re-adjusting the angle of my whole hand. My tech 'unattached' the key from the B/Bb cluster by bending back the little piece of of metal under the key so it plays independently. It's now very free and easy to play, but of course I've lost the convenience of holding down the key when playing from G# to B/Bb. Is it just a case of doing some weight-lifting with my LH pinky until it's Schwarzenegger-like? Or can that cluster be made light(ish) and responsive?
I have two almost identical 1945-46 silver-plated 12Ms. One of them has a modification on it with a plate to attach the G# to the C# and B. I recently went back to this baritone from the other (which is currently having the neck loop braces resoldered because they came loose). I find the C# and B extremely heavy because of the extra spring from the G#, but the G# *on its own* should not be too heavy.. You could have the two opposing springs on the G# mechanism adjusted but that's probably looking for trouble if it's done badly.

You can also lighten the spring on the C# (I did that on the other baritone without the extra link, as the C# was just a bit heavy anyway) if you want to restore the linkage to the G'.

But I'm just thinking of unsoldering the plate - it's a bit of a pain having a heavy C#/B/Bb.

Michael
 
Actually, what would be most interesting would be to have someone remove the G# spatula entirely and extend the C# spatula upwards and modify with an arm to link directly to the G# pad, thus having a single key that operates both the G# and C# (the G# tone hole is of coursed closed when you put any fingers of the right hand down).

If you think about the possibilities of note transitions that are awkward *without* the modified link between G# and C#/B, it wouldn't be a step backwards to have only three spatulas for the little finger rather than four. I'm actually thinking of having my clarinet modified (it already has an articulated G# mechanism as its a Conn 446N) in the way I've described because I have some awkwardness in my little finger there, and fewer keys would be nice!
 
Please see my post above about how to effect the linkage to low B, C# keys, with friction reduction. Proper attention to this will make huge improvements.

I have a Holton/Couturier soprano with the combined G#/C# key and it renders a couple arpeggios very difficult to play (can't remember which).
 
I have a 12M and I love it. It's beat up and banana-shaped from the abuse by previous owners but that horn can sing. You are not trying to be "cute" with a lot of bling, the 12M is one of the archetypical baris out there and all you need to do is pay attention to where you run into problems. Adjusting your hand position may have been a good thing because now you are using your hand the way it was supposed to be used. But still pay attention to potential points of malfunction which includes the way you hold the instrument because gravity becomes another factor in the way the keys behave.
 
I play exclusively tenor sax in a Big Band. I had a few 'try-outs' on a bari and I loved them! My only (tenor) sax is a 'vintage' from 1961 but it's always played well. I can't really comment on the importance of a 'low A' on a bari except to say that I sometimes get sheet music for a tenor that also goes down to a 'low A' which is impossible to play on Tenor Sax (which goes down to low B-flat). So in these cases, I have to work out an alternative. Usually not an octave higher but some 'low note' in the same key/chord.

From my very limited experience, 'unplayable' low A notes tend to be relatively short (1-2 beats) rather being extended over 4 beats or more. So if you play an 'alternative note' in the same key/chord, most people won't notice. Unless it's the 'root note' of a chord played on the 1st beat. Then you might need to play the octaviated A and work your way down to the notes as written.

I bow to the previous advice of bari players. I'm just sharing the fact that 'unplayable' low A notes are not limited to bari players.
 
I have to say that I never saw a written low A for tenor sax in a big band chart that was actually written for the big band. Maybe in charts that were pieced together from lead sheets, piano scores, etc. I will admit that I haven't played as many years on tenor as on baritone, so I've probably missed something.

As a bari player, who's never had a low-A horn, I do occasionally have to make on the spot edits when the written low A comes up. There are a lot of different ways to address the low A - up an octave for the one note; up an octave for the phrase; change the A to another note that fits.

I have NOT had the experience of playing in a professional big-band playing only modern charts, where the low A might be constantly called for. The pro big-bands I've been in have usually had books primarily made up of older charts, for dancing, and the low A has not been an issue.
 
They gave me baritone charts with several low A tones to play on my bari to low Bb. And also on tenor. It's tricky when bandleaders don't know so much horns. I think we should blame some of the mistakes to computers and synths.
 
They gave me baritone charts with several low A tones to play on my bari to low Bb. And also on tenor. It's tricky when bandleaders don't know so much horns. I think we should blame some of the mistakes to computers and synths.

It's not always a mistake.

Low A on baritone parts for big band, horn sections and saxophone ensembles are common for music in the last 60 years and more.

Low A on tenor parts often arises because it is playable on the Bb trumpet which would sometimes share a part with Bb saxes and wouldn't have as high a written range.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
Well, a baritone chart with written low A is standard these days. Arrangers expect the low A will be available.

Written low A for tenor is a mistake.

Computer manuscript programs often botch transposition and the wise arranger will read through each part to make sure accidentals, key signature, and instrument range are all correct.
 
Maybe it's mistakes. Or is it just exposing that the horns on the recordings are not played with real horns?

The guy that used to write my horn arrangements never wrote low A note on the tenor part or bari part.
 
Please see my post above about how to effect the linkage to low B, C# keys, with friction reduction. Proper attention to this will make huge improvements.

I have a Holton/Couturier soprano with the combined G#/C# key and it renders a couple arpeggios very difficult to play (can't remember which).

Where does one buy Delrin or UHMW-PE in a form useful for saxophones?

One of the popular UK suppliers of bits and bobs for repairs and maintenance, for example, lists lots of corks and synthetic corks, but only lists PTFE, not Delrin or UHMW-PE on their website.
 
In the US the big three industrial suppliers I use for pretty much everything are McMaster-Carr (pretty much everything), MSC Supply (tools for machining and measuring) and W W Grainger (shop equipment, electrical equipment, motors). McMaster-Carr sells small quantities of plastics of all types in a variety of sheet thicknesses.

(for electronics the big three are Digi-Key, Allied, and Newark)

I'm pretty sure Music Medic or Ferree's also sells sheet materials good for this application.

The reason I don't like sheet PTFE so much isn't because it's not a good material (it's a great material) but because it's damn hard to adhere it to anything. The low surface energy makes it hard to stick adhesives to PTFE. Acetal and UHMW-PE are more readily attached with adhesives while still having low coefficient of friction.

If you can obtain some Rulon J that's real good too - I didn't know about it when I redid my old Conn. It's PTFE with a polyimide filler and it CAN be used with adhesives - I guess the PI filler is what the adhesives adhere to.

I have no idea what UK suppliers fill the roles of the above US vendors, but I'm sure that Britain, the birthplace of the Industrial Revolution, has such companies supporting manufacturers. If you know a machinist or manufacturing engineer, that person will know the names of your local vendors.
 
I started playing baritone sax just over a year ago, after a few decades playing clarinet and bass clarinet. I'd always had a 'thing' for the beautiful sound of the bari, and, along with turning 50, I finally made the leap because I met someone selling a 1936 Conn 12M that had belonged to a recently departed local jazz great (Gijs Hendriks, in case anyone's interested in Dutch jazz...)
At the time, I also watched some videos by Cafe Saxophone member (legend!) @fabriziodalisera and thought - Wow! That's the instrument for me!

Fast forward a year, and after some mouthpiece and reed fiddling, I've found a set-up that works for me (Aizen LS 7 and Alexander DC 2.5) and is responsive and in tune. Apart from some discomfort in my right wrist (I think because of where the thumb rest is placed), I find it pretty comfortable overall.
And I've totally fallen for bari playing... the bass clarinet is gathering dust, and I'm working on the chops necessary to get a big band spot (much harder than I naively/arrogantly thought...)

Anyway, my question is it realistic/sensible to use this as my main/only instrument? If I'd known I was going to fall so hard for bari playing, I might have thought a bit more carefully about practicalities (like Low A or no, and whether a vintage beauty like this is more suited to, well, a jazz legend, with mere mortals better sticking to a modern Yamaha, Yanagisawa etc.)
Any thoughts/advice/experience welcome. (The sound is beautiful, of course...!)
View attachment 25428
Let's not forget Harry Carney, probably the most influential and possibly the best big band bari player ever! He may have played a little 11M towards the end (that's the low A adaptation of the 12M, but don't get any ideas!), but he was a 12M man from the time they came out.
A '36 is a great horn, with two caveats: one, it will have gone on and out of adjustment a hundred times in 88 years, and through the hands of many techs, and it's a challenging model to work on, so if you haven't already, have a trusted tech go through it meticulously. Baris are more forgiving of leaks than smaller saxes, but they're also easier to knock into things, so you could be surprised at how much a servicing will improve it. Second caveat, and a small one for most players, is that a '36 will probably not have a front high F lever. The high notes are not really the point of the bari, but if you find you miss it, there are easy (Yamaha style lever) and hard (later Conn) ways to add one. If you find yourself almost getting gigs, but losing them because you can't get down to A, there are a surprising number of cheap but solid horns from both sides of the Taiwan Strait that will do the job, at a price that will let you keep the Conn--provided you have room for two baris, of course.
 
Let's not forget Harry Carney, probably the most influential and possibly the best big band bari player ever! He may have played a little 11M towards the end (that's the low A adaptation of the 12M, but don't get any ideas!), but he was a 12M man from the time they came out.
A '36 is a great horn, with two caveats: one, it will have gone on and out of adjustment a hundred times in 88 years, and through the hands of many techs, and it's a challenging model to work on, so if you haven't already, have a trusted tech go through it meticulously. Baris are more forgiving of leaks than smaller saxes, but they're also easier to knock into things, so you could be surprised at how much a servicing will improve it. Second caveat, and a small one for most players, is that a '36 will probably not have a front high F lever. The high notes are not really the point of the bari, but if you find you miss it, there are easy (Yamaha style lever) and hard (later Conn) ways to add one. If you find yourself almost getting gigs, but losing them because you can't get down to A, there are a surprising number of cheap but solid horns from both sides of the Taiwan Strait that will do the job, at a price that will let you keep the Conn--provided you have room for two baris, of course.
Agreed with everything except the hard to work on. The one thing that can be a bit iffy is the correct spring tension, too little and the keys won't open correctly and you'll have more than one flat note. Too much and it'll turn into an exercise machine.

But the 12M sound is the best, next to a King Zephyr
 
Where does one buy Delrin or UHMW-PE in a form useful for saxophones?

One of the popular UK suppliers of bits and bobs for repairs and maintenance, for example, lists lots of corks and synthetic corks, but only lists PTFE, not Delrin or UHMW-PE on their website.
Here's a little trick that might help.
Get a sheet of PTFE, some very thin synthetic cork and a pack of Araldite Rapid (not the standard stuff).
Scour one side of the PTFE with medium grit sandpaper and degrease with cigarette lighter fluid. Mix up enough Araldite to coat the scoured surface of the PFTE, heat it gently and apply it to the PTFE then place it on a similarly-sized piece of the cork. Clamp it up tight and leave it for a day or so - then cut and use in the usual fashion.

It's not a 100% reliable solution but I find it tends to last at least as long as the time it takes for the PTFE to wear before it delaminates.
I much prefer a 'mechanical' solution, so tend to opt for using clear heat-shrink tubing wherever possible in such situations.
 
Agreed with everything except the hard to work on. The one thing that can be a bit iffy is the correct spring tension, too little and the keys won't open correctly and you'll have more than one flat note. Too much and it'll turn into an exercise machine.

But the 12M sound is the best, next to a King Zephyr
But a Martin shows them the door 🙂
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom