Scam/Fake? Unsure if this is a real Selmer Super Action 80 Serie II

Abdiel_fl

Member
Messages
11
Location
California
My friend showed me this saxophone he bought from our old band leader almost a decade ago and I was originally surprised he told me he bought it for 200 bucks (keep in mind he plays bass so he knows nothing about saxophones) So he is interested in selling it to me for 500 bucks and I have never owned a Selmer so I have no idea if it's real but I'm leaning towards it being fake. Here are some pictures I took of it a few months ago and didn't look back at until today.
Screenshot 2024-01-06 at 12.02.33 AM.webp
Screenshot 2024-01-06 at 12.05.38 AM.webp
Screenshot 2024-01-06 at 12.06.55 AM.webp
Screenshot 2024-01-06 at 12.07.23 AM.webp


now that I look back at it the neck printing is so bad that its inverse with flash

but anyways im still in the situation so please any thoughts?
 
Hi. First of all, I’m no top expert, just a longtime SA-II alto and baritone owner.
It seems rather well made if it is a fake. Still, some serious doubts.
Selmer horns are lacquered after the logo is embossed on the bell. This gives the logo a nice 3D effect. On the pictures above, the logo looks like (laser ?) engraved after lacquering.
SA-II altos have a small medallion above the tenon on the neck (stamped "80 Super Action"), and the embossed Β« S Β» on the octave key is surrounded by blue paint.
The bell keyguards are slimmer on the real horn. And the Β« SERIE II Β» text comes closer to the keyguard post.
Other detail, Selmer uses green (or black) and not red felt.
I’m not familiar with later engravings, but I’ve never seen such a flower on an SA-II alto.
Serial number ?
 
Last edited:
I am no expert, but I think its a fake, engraving looks wrong and seems laser and not embossed and the neck is not right, just as dexdex has said.
I wouldn't touch it even at $500 and if it is a fake he is committing a crime in trying to sell it to you.
 
100% fake.

Selmer logo on the side of the bell should be stamped. This one looks laser etched or sandblasted, plus the fonts look wonky -look at the N in the word Henri.

Also neck completely wrong -should be a plate on the front, and the logo on the crook should be three dimensional as these are usually filled with blue enamel surrounding the S.

Many other details wrong I'm sure but not much point in discussing.
 
Definitely a fake, not even a very good one. I wouldn't even think of a purchase. I don't know about in California, but in the UK it's a criminal offence to sell a counterfeit item, even if you openly say it's a counterfeit.
 
and I was originally surprised he told me he bought it for 200 bucks (keep in mind he plays bass so he knows nothing about saxophones) So he is interested in selling it to me for 500 bucks
I would advise him to go to the bandleader and ask for his money back, as it was illegal for the bandleader to sell it. The saxophone has no legal value.
 
I would say especially if you openly say it's a counterfeit because it means you know you are selling a fake. No excuse.
I take your point. What I was getting at was the preconception some sellers have that it's OK to sell a fake as long as you explain it's a fake. You know, that delusion that it's all OK as long as you're not trying to tell anyone that the item is genuine. This is, of course, nonsense, and has no bearing in the legality of the matter, but I see sellers trying to defend themselves this way several times each year.
 
It could be argued that (unless a patent is infringed) the issue of illegality lies only in the copying of or passing off of the trademark.

Hence totally removing the trademark means the saxophone may now at least be legal, and at least have some value.
 
Patent and trademarks are important. I don't know but are there any patent on a Selmer SA II? The trademark (logo is protected. Selmer (Paris) use to be stamped not engraved? A protected logo.

I think to call a saxophone "King Super 21" was ok as long as it had it's own design of the logo/trademark. Two families with the names, Selmer and Yanagisawa, lived closed to my parents in laws house. If they wanted to buy legal blanks from PRC and engrave the saxes with their names with it's own design .... was that against the law? GM had to pay to SAAB for every badge they put on the front of their cars which had less with real SAAB. It's all about money?
 
The more fakes we buy, the bigger the market for fakes. The bigger the market, the more fakes are produced.

If we stop considering to buy fakes, the less incentive to make them?
Yes, that's the only way to go. And also to take back production to ..... UK, EU, USA ..... the world is not what it used to be ..... and definitely not what we want it to be. Selmer MK VI was a frequently copied sax back in the 60's. Some of these saxes are in heavy demand today. The only way to go is to stay out from these saxes? And some Italian saxes were close to Conn saxes ...... The ultra cheap RPC tenor was a copy of a Yanigisawa. How many saxes were sold just because of the rumor that it was a Yani copy? It would be ideal if we could buy our saxes from our local saxophone maker. A metal sax or a 3-D printed "plastic sax". You buy a license to write out one tenor. Like buying sheet music over internet.
 
I would say especially if you openly say it's a counterfeit because it means you know you are selling a fake. No excuse.
I'm no lawyer but it says here

A person is guilty of forgery if he makes a false instrument, with the intention that he or another shall use it to induce somebody to accept it as genuine,,

But that is separate and different to Intellectual Property use violations.
The manufacturer is, probably, in violation of Selmar's trademark protections and, probably, patent protections. But I'm not sure someone selling a counterfeit is culpable for those crimes. That would be weird.

Same as selling fake pound coins. Counterfeit is counterfeit.
Apparently, from the above, there is a difference. It's a crime to knowingly be in position of counterfeit money - hence a bank teller (remember those!) Must confiscate fake notes once identified. That doesn't seem to apply to other things...
 
Last edited:
But I'm not sure someone selling a counterfeit is culpable for those crimes. That would be weird.
Makes total sense that it is illegal to sell a counterfeit. A court may or may not have a different view on (1) selling it as genuine (ie misrepresenting it to the customer) or (2) selling it as a known fake.


It may be like the difference between somebody stealing a shed and saying either:

Do you want to buy this shed? and

Do you want to buy this stolen shed?

Both are far from legal but in the second case the purchaser obviously would also be guilty of handling stolen goods. Whether buying counterfeit is legal or not will be down to individual jurisdictions. How that law is applied may also be based on the scale of the operation so even if it is legal to buy a fake Gucci bag, it would probably be ver illegal to buy 500 because you are involved in the selling chain.
 
The difference I was after in that remark was between selling a counterfeit object - like a Selmer sax that isn't; and selling something like a no-name sax which uses Selmar patent designs without licence.
The latter is using theved bits; but it's a different issue. And it's would be unusual for the patent holder or police to go after owners of no-name sax - although Selmer might go after the manufacturer.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,258
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom