Playing the saxophone Turning the notes on the page into music

jbtsax

R.I.P. in memoriam 1947 - 2023
Messages
8,985
Location
Beautiful Springville, Utah USA
A recent thread with a similar title made me think of this topic. This was something my mentor in college used to stress in all my lessons and in rehearsals he was conducting. For those who are not sure what it means. The "music" is what we perceive through our sense of hearing and when well played it impacts our mood or our feelings. It is not what we see on the page which at best is a rough outline of the elements of music contained in the piece we are playing.

A few ideas I have learned along the way are:
  • Think of the music in terms of phrases, not notes or measures.
  • Don't let the listener hear the "bar lines".
  • If the performer doesn't "feel" the music being played the audience won't feel it either.
  • A single tone can contain as much "expression" as an entire phrase or melody.
  • It takes a mastery of the fundamentals of playing each instrument to begin to "really" play the "music".

There are many fine players and musicians who are members at the Cafe who can certainly add to the ideas presented.
 
Thanks to jbtsax for succinctly making up this list. Feeling the music and making others feel it is definitely where it's at.

I've always had an admiration for great musicians who can read music many bars ahead of where they are playing. I used to turn pages for concert pianists and was amazed that they wanted me to turn the page many measures before required. They were able to internalize the music then "sing" through their hands giving weight and meaning to what were otherwise just notes.

Playing the sax is so much more like singing in that we can give heaps of inflection to what we play. Once again, I greatly admire those who can read far enough ahead to "hear" what they are going to play and give it appropriate feeling.

Unfortunately for 99.9% of us we will never have that ability, and it's not because some people can't read and play that fast, it's because they don't necessarily hear what they are about to play, so it comes out "mechanical". It's simply eye to hand coordination without hearing (in advance) what it will sound like. Most of us who can read, and are practicing a piece/score, will practice it until we can hear all of it with the notes on paper just becoming a reminder...we do eventually hear it first!

This then brings us around to improvisation. Can you hear what you are about to play? Is it true composition on the fly or practiced finger memory patterns fitted into the visual of a chord chart? It's the same thing...how do you give meaning and expression to something you can't hear before playing it? This is what separates many of the great players of the past from those who have only learned by prescription. The academic process sought to formulate what was a creative process by analysis of specific progressions that were commonly used, but has never been able to teach the creative side of this. Thus the plethora of jazz players who sound the same and have little to say to their audience.

Hopefully players will take jbtsax's information to heart and recognize that all of us need to be concious of what we are playing and as Nikki says singing though our instruments.
 
A fascinating topic, one we have ruminated over here in so many discussions. When you listen to John Lee Hooker, he's saying what comes from the "heart", not the mind. As one who fights daily with the acquisition of sufficient technique to play what I already hear, I understand why people chase after technical facility on an instrument. The thing is, highly developed technique can't replace John Lee Hooker. Nor can amount of reading or memorisation skills alone make music. Alone, they will make music as compelling as a computer. In that case, the music is in the ear and mind of the listener. There are in real life, free programs that create compelling ambient music. Ambient music doesn't usually tell a story, but it can create a feeling, and feelings are a big part of hearing music.

There will be listeners who "hear" music that others think is noise. We have an agreed-upon scale of music here in the café that is mostly homogeneous. On other words, we mostly agree that there was a force behind Charlie Parker, Billy Holiday, Coltrane and is still one behind Esperanza Spalding, that goes beyond the ability to play the notes, and play them well and in time. (Ms. Spalding can play in one time and sing in another.) This force seems to go beyond the personality of the player in that it demonstrates a generosity some didn't historically have in their day to day existence. In this sense, music is almost a different plane of human existence. Where does it originate? Certainly not on paper, not in scales, not from muscle memory.

The question is, can it be taught?
 
It's an interesting and an important topic.

The bar line is a relatively 'modern' invention of the last 400 years or so... (you can tell I'm an early music enthusiast... :mrcool ). There are certain styles of music (waltzes are a case) where the bar and the different emphasis on each beat within the bar is important. However, in many styles of music this is much less relevant and the 'line' of the melody is much more important and it may well ignore the bar line and start mid bar and finish mid bar some time later.

in the early music world, particularly with renaissance polyphony, this is important and various methods have been tried to try to mitigate the interruption of flow caused by bar lines.

The 'original' manuscripts of music from C16th and earlier had no bar lines. At a choral workshop we were given our parts (i.e. SATB) but they had no bar lines. It was VERY hard to keep time and be in the right place, but when it worked, the flow of the line was much improved.

For modern musicians, that is an unnecessary level of complication. An alternative method, which does work and it is easier to follow is to not have full bar lines within the staff, but to put short bar lines in instead. This makes it much easier to 'read' but removes that 'barrier' to the flow.

I have some facsimile editions of Tudor music I will see if I can find a suitable example and post a pic later.
 
I don't think great communicative musicianship can be taught academically. The academic process is one of deduction and applying principles in a scientific way with the notion that mechanical principles always render a predictable/successful result. Unfortunately those are not hallmarks of creativity in the arts. If the academic approach was the best, then the graduate level would represent the pinnacle of that system. The fact is that almost none of the great musicians, composers, authors, painters, sculptors, etc. had a PhD.

Hopefully it's possible to encourage creativity, to mentor talent, and present opportunities for those rare people. We also have to accept that people like Esperanza Spalding are indeed rare and most of us don't possess that level of talent. For most, music is a dream not to be realized, but hopefully can become a joy and pastime.

So how do we learn? At what point do we recognize the "Peter Principle"? Is it best to learn an instrument "mechanistically" until we can use the tool, or through some other system?

I'm rather fond of the Suzuki method which encourages players of any instrument to first play by ear, then learn to read. Is it perfect? Probably not, but it certainly encourages training the ear first to make connections to the instrument. That, to me, seems much more sensible than training the eyes to connect to the hands without considering the musical consequence. When the music is ancillary to the process rather than the conscious intent how is that musical?

Hearing the music you are playing and making it communicate is the core principle of good/great musicianship. How you get there is (IMHO) still a work in progress. We all learn differently with the majority being "visual" learners. Needless to say music isn't a visual art form...part of the problem? Are there visual means to learn music, understand principles, become aware of the underling principles? Yes of course, yet most of that knowledge doesn't make one a great player. There is also the mechanical practice that enables us to manipulate the instrument of our choice so that it's a facilitator rather than an impediment.

Again...no precise "one size fits all" solution. However maybe if the goal is kept clearly in view, and not clouded by formulaic teaching there is hope.
 
Needless to say music isn't a visual art form...part of the problem?
It is now, and this is a problem for some of us, compared to some of the nicer, or more striking visual examples like Esperanza or Grace Kelly or Mindy or Candy or the "saxy beach" guys, to be fair.
But I agree, as you knew in advance, with your main points. I know some people who just simply can not pick up a spoken language, no matter how immersed in it they are, but they can probably read it fairly well. Also, was this already said here, "theory follows practice". We can study Coltrane or Bird -- harder to study Sonny -- and construct the ways they sound. That guy who has a lot of videos about how to play outside really fast has done that and offers a guide. But from there, you will not necessarily communicate.
 
It's worth pointing out something else about visual vs aural: Music doesn't exist without time. It can not be taken in all at once, like a painting or sculpture. Although there are nuances for painting and 3D art like sculpture or architecture, one glimpse gives an immediate impression. One sample of music, will not. This is why it's often compared to story telling. Short phrases can do this, but they are parts of a whole. A long novel might start

"Rainy night. Rooftops glistening, their gutters droop in near silence."

And so a brilliant piece of music might start with a note, like, say "Naima" does, and that evokes an immediate emotion. Now, anyone can play a note. Can you play the first note of Naima?
 
The brain has many secrets that are yet to be unlocked.
Perfect pitch ... is quite rare in the U.S. and Europe, where only about one person in 10,000 is thought to have it.
...
musicians who speak an East Asian tone language fluently are much more likely to have perfect pitch.
...
students at the Central Conservatory of Music in Beijing, China, all of whom spoke Mandarin, were almost nine times more likely to have perfect pitch than students at the Eastman School of Music in New York.

 
We all learn differently with the majority being "visual" learners. Needless to say music isn't a visual art form...part of the problem? Are there visual means to learn music, understand principles, become aware of the underling principles?

“Some types of content really lend themselves to visual presentation … if you’re teaching maps, that’s got to be visual. If you’re teaching music, those are [the] types of things that need to be auditory.

“But if your goal is to get a multifaceted exposure to certain content, it can be helpful to weave in all different types of modalities.”

 
Just want to add to this thread (from my amateur experience):

Most amateur players (IHMO) don't play a prima vista (on first reading). They read through the sheet music, practice, and rehearse before performing. So even if they can't yet 'master the fundamentals of the instrument', there's still a lot they can do to discover and express the 'musicality' written in notes/bars. To (hopefully) paraphrase some of @jbtsax's excellent advice:

  • read through the sheet music to find the 'musical phrases'; sometimes these are indicated, sometimes not. Sometimes they correspond with the beginning and end of bars, but more often not. So it's worthwhile practicing where to spot the beginning and end of a phrase. Either a melody or a phrase from a supporting instrument. A phrase is an overarching 'statement' with (often) a beginning, middle and end. It has little to do with the bars.
  • musical phrases played without any expression often sound 'mechanical' and a bit boring to the audience. So look at how you could express phrases through volume, holding notes slightly longer/shorter than indicated, with more vibrato, etc (@jbtsax's single notes)
  • Learn to express 'phrases' (as opposed to just playing the notes) during practice and during rehearsals
  • Listen to music (of whatever genre, but jazz, classical music and vocalists spring to mind) in which musicians don't just play 'the notes' but express themselves.

I personally have a hard time believing that anyone who deliberately chooses to learn an instrument doesn't have some innate musicality that they can develop.

@jbtsax please correct me if I'm wrong about this
 
@jbtsax please correct me if I'm wrong about this
On the contrary. All of your comments are valid and contribute much to the discussion. A point I should have made more clear in my post is that playing musically and with expression is a journey for all of us---not a destination.

The greater one masters the fundamentals of playing one's instrument the higher the level of musical expression is possible. Those learning to play an instrument can certainly improve in the area of expressive playing as they go along. It is not an "all or nothing" proposition as comments in my initial post might have lead some to believe.
 
The brain has many secrets that are yet to be unlocked.



Perfect pitch sounds like something we all wish we had. A player in our orchestra (out of interest she's Korean) does, and she admits it is quite stressful to play with others who don't.
 
Just one more thought for amateurs (like me): having discovered the 'phrasing' (across multiple bars and starting somewhere in the bar), pencil in notes on the sheet music to remind yourself.

BTW I've also found 'penciling in notes' useful for many other things:
  • marking asynchronous rhythmic (jazz) patterns that stretch across a couple of bars and don't start/end where I normally expect them.
  • the 'style' in which a piece is to be played ('laid back', 'expressive like a movie track', '3rd solo on page 2' etc)
  • 'what's coming up' (e.g a solo/challenging section starting top-left on the next page, notes on extended rests (trombone solo 16 bars, drum solo 8 bars))
  • best key-fingering combinations for 'fast/challenging' sections': which optional key fingerings give the easiest transition between the previous and next notes?
  • places where I consciously need to take a deep breath for what's to come and places where I can take a 'sip' of breath to top up during an otherwise 'breathless' section
etc.

So I would encourage amateurs to take their own personal notes. Both from 'reading through' the sheet music (phrasing, breathing) and from your personal playing experience. Knowing in advance where phrases start and end helps enormously! Whenever you find yourself somewhat out of air or are in doubt of which key-fingering to use, figure it out and make notes. If they become redundant, you can always rub them out!

Mike
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,177
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom