Theory & Impro transposition - please do justify it (once and for all)

Close the thread?

  • Close the thread

    Votes: 9 75.0%
  • Keep it open

    Votes: 3 25.0%

  • Total voters
    12
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.
Would you start considering de-transposing if a reputable source can demonstrate that transposition is hampering your perfect pitch and capacity to recognize intervals and scales?

I don't have perfect pitch and it's not hampering anything. It's merely a method of playing music with different pitched instruments easier.

I don't enjoy reading music much (try to avoid it anyhow).

Probably explains why you think like you do, then.
 
I don't have perfect pitch and it's not hampering anything. It's merely a method of playing music with different pitched instruments easier.



Probably explains why you think like you do, then.

Indeed, it seems that those who read music or depend more on the written score have more difficulties than I thought in thinking in a de transposed way.
To understand your perspective I'll have to start reading a lot more and depending on a score - not something I'm looking for.
Surely I've seen both ways somehow - as my first 3 years of sax were transposed and the following 3 de-transposed (there was a long gap in the middle) - during the last 3 years (de-transposed ones) I've seen some remarkable improvements in my ability to recognize intervals and scales by ear - though I believe this has to be as a result of the introduction of my own solfege (a peculiar one where each of the 12 tones has a specific name)....this solfege is not a relative one with movable DOs - I'm after absolute consistency (and absolute pitch if possible). Still the improvements are there and it would have not be possible if I was still transposing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well probably you got a good point here....I don't enjoy reading music much (try to avoid it anyhow).

I don't enjoy it but do do it as I'm working my way up my grades, but I don't find transposing a problem at all, when I'm playing in the band, it's all ear playing anyway, and I know what key I need to be playing in to match theirs, as long as I know my scales and arpeggios in all keys I'm fine. :thumb:

Indeed, it seems that those who read music or depend more on the written score have more difficulties than I thought in thinking in a de transposed way.
To understand your perspective I'll have to start reading a lot more and depending on a score - not something I'm looking for.
Surely I've seen both ways somehow - as my first 3 years of sax were transposed and the following 3 de-transposed (there was a long gap in the middle) - during the last 3 years (de-transposed ones) I've seen some remarkable improvements in my ability to recognize intervals and scales by ear - though I believe this has to be as a result of the introduction of my own solfege (a peculiar one where each of the 12 tones has a specific name)....this solfege is not a relative one with movable DOs - I'm after absolute consistency (and absolute pitch if possible). Still the improvements are there and it would have not be possible if I was still transposing.

Do you not think this may be because you've developed your musical abilities in that time?

I can't imagine anything worse than picking up my flute or alto and having to think that what is D on tenor now becomes A or whatever!.......the work needed for that would drive me to tears! :shocked:

In regards to perfect pitch - why does anyone really need it? I don't have it but once I'm playing my ear "tunes in" and I can find a new key straight away. Provided you know what interval your aiming to find you'll generally find it...and if you've tuned to concert A and you have a reasonable ear to finely tune any notes that are slightly out with your breath control and embouchure, then I can't see a problem? :confused:
 
How can you possibly know this?

I'm tempted to go all the way in trying to demonstrate it - but it's a tough challenge - this message on this forum (and others) is a starting point...then I'll check if there are other musicians out there who have de-transposed their instrument.
Statistics in colleges/universities...probably there is already a database where skills and abilities of musicians are being measured - if piano and guitar players have a better ear than sax and trumpet players then there might be a clue that transposition or exposure to it is interfering negatively with audio perception/recollection.
Above all, it's a strong belief of mine - I know about my progress - that's why I'm so convinced and motivated about it.
Solfege is grossly underrated it helps memorizing tricky passages by ear - consistent solfege (not movable DO) can't work with the transposition system...hence my conclusion that transposition is hampering auditory skills (apart from being unnatural, illogical and anachronistic).
 
All of music notation is "unnatural".

Transposition seems perfectly logical to me.

I don't really get the "anachronistic" bit. Why? I play saxes designed in about 1840 - is that anachronistic?

So we're back to, "I hate it, so it's wrong".
 
to ArtyLady,

I've never really had any issue myself with transposition - I remember only that I did questioned my tutors (a lot) about it because I felt there was something not quite right with it and let's face it - the answers I was given were very poor and embarrassing sometimes.
Regarding developing my skills later on...in general we learn better when we are young - and my 3 years were very intense - I would say I kept practicing on average about 6 hours per day for at least 2 full years.
My training style now is similar (just a bit less technical) and I only practice 2 hours per day and the only relevant change is the introduction of my solfege - the idea of this solfege started many years ago but I'd only implemented when I restarted playing sax (in 2008).
I've been interested in music all of my life - if I wasn't playing the sax I was producing music with electronic gear, Midi, audio plugins etc. a bit of guitar and piano too...yet, the improvements in my auditory skills are quite recent...

The most difficult step is to have a go - it was a bit traumatic to start with and quite irrational too - once you pass that weird phase it's easy - of course you are bound to hit and miss again but there are so many advantages you just don't want to go back - after all a tenor is a tenor and an alto is an alto why getting fixated with the fingers? The ear should be given the priority and the fingers will follow (not the other way round). Give it a couple of days and keep the tuner handy.

You are right...perfect pitch isn't that important - the idea of using solfege was to help me gaining it...still my improvements came somewhere else: I recognize so many more scales now (all modes from the major, melodic minor and the harmonic minor for example) while in my transposing era I was only able to distinguish a major from a minor (as generic as that) and a blues from a chromatic - my perfect pitch is as elusive as ever although occasionally a LA pops instantly (there is no mistake).
 
All of music notation is "unnatural".

Transposition seems perfectly logical to me.

I don't really get the "anachronistic" bit. Why? I play saxes designed in about 1840 - is that anachronistic?

So we're back to, "I hate it, so it's wrong".

It's anachronistic because it doesn't play the same role it played centuries ago...
In the past there were instruments which couldn't play in any key - the introduction of valves in trumpets and technology advancements in general meant any instrument (most) nowadays can play in any key.
Then we have to analyze musical contents...the musical restraints of baroque music belong to that era - who's nowadays composing baroque music? Voicing was very strict and adherent to certain musical ideas which aren't that relevant anymore - the more the music evolves the more wider the approaches.
Transposition is no use to Jazz, Rock, Pop players - it belong to the past and is a legacy.
 
zannad, I am baffled as to why you started this thread. Your mind is so clearly made up, and good luck to you.

I am sure all of us can point to aspects of our lives that don't quite work the way we would wish them to ....
 
to ArtyLady,

..........................
The most difficult step is to have a go............Give it a couple of days and keep the tuner handy.

You are right...perfect pitch isn't that important - the idea of using solfege was to help me gaining it...still my improvements came somewhere else: I recognize so many more scales now (all modes from the major, melodic minor and the harmonic minor for example) while in my transposing era I was only able to distinguish a major from a minor (as generic as that) and a blues from a chromatic - my perfect pitch is as elusive as ever although occasionally a LA pops instantly (there is no mistake).

I'll give it a miss thank you, I really can't see any point at all......:confused:

If you couldn't recognise your modes but you can now, that would probably be because you just hadn't learned the sound of them. :confused: I have had no problem learning them all in 4 years - in all keys - and I don't have perfect pitch - before that I only knew major, harmonic and melodic minor). 🙂
 
Transposition is no use to Jazz, Rock, Pop players - it belong to the past and is a legacy

You are having a laugh, n'est-ce-pas? Hey, you may struggle to understand the logic of it, and indeed if music was to be re-invented tomorrow, undoubtedly it would not exist, but transposition works for millions of musicians and being part of its legacy is a good thing as far as I am concerned.
 
zannad, I am baffled as to why you started this thread. Your mind is so clearly made up, and good luck to you.

I am sure all of us can point to aspects of our lives that don't quite work the way we would wish them to ....

testing the waters? Researching a bit more? Maybe I've missed something and some other reasons behind transposition that it is worth to know...
Some accept the things as they are...others like trying something new ;}
 
I'll give it a miss thank you, I really can't see any point at all......:confused:

If you couldn't recognise your modes but you can now, that would probably be because you just hadn't learned the sound of them. :confused: I have had no problem learning them all in 4 years - in all keys - and I don't have perfect pitch - before that I only knew major, harmonic and melodic minor). 🙂

what you have learned and your abilities are subjective - i.e. you can't measure how effective a method/technique is by comparing my results with yours - in that case you'd rather be waiting to hear the same story from a great sax player - this is a great mistake....still I fully understand your point.
The principle behind a concept is what really matters - above all, one has to truly believe it...if in doubt just leave it.
 
You are having a laugh, n'est-ce-pas? Hey, you may struggle to understand the logic of it, and indeed if music was to be re-invented tomorrow, undoubtedly it would not exist, but transposition works for millions of musicians and being part of its legacy is a good thing as far as I am concerned.

What's the use of transposition for a Jazz player? Apart from the fact that was already there and has been taken for all the wrong reasons? In fact all the formal approach behind the origins of transposition go against the freedom of Jazz.
2+2=4 but you call that 4 a 3 this is the logic behind transposition
2+2=4 and you call that 4 a 4 that is the logic behind de-transposition
Now can you explain which is more logical and natural?
All the messages I'm getting recently are practically the same - why bother? We make music anyway - everyone does it - I'm happy because so and so....yet, there is not a real explanation and truly understanding apart from the awful idea of having to cope without it.
 
Zannad,
You mention that brass instruments were not able to play in all keys but they coped by using different crooks, read Mozart's taunts to his favourite horn player.

Woodwinds were also playable in all keys either by only partially covering holes or fork fingering.

Why not be really radical? Throw out equal temperament and have different instruments for each major/related minor key, as that would give perfect pitch. Amidst all the kerfuffle caused by that re-organisation, your de-transposition would not be noticed and music would be purer.

Apologies for being serious.
 
There are two sides to this - historical reasons for transposition and usefulness today.

The history's a given, even if there's some uncertainty in places. No point in arguing about it, unless it's to clear up uncertainties.

Relevance today? For me and many others act is that it is relevant, for many of us challenged mortals who like to make music, but aren't willing (or able) to learn different fingerings for each written note. I'll never play the clarinet - not because it's different to blow, but because there are different fingerings for each ntoe, depending on which register you're playing in.

Even a system that's clearly superior - such as Boehm's flute - takes a long time to gain acceptance as existing skills have to be unlearnt and replaced with new ones. It was ease of playing - and superior tone in all registers that eventually caused Boehm's system to be adopted almost universally.

Another issue is that the different members of a transposing family have different sounds - and the C Melody sax is an example here. It doesn't have the guts of the Bb tenor (even though it's only a tone deeper) and doesn't have the sweetness of a good alto. We need those different voices. Just as the classical composers scored separately for oboe/cor anglais for example - it wasn't just the pitch....

It's like many other things - you feel that you can improve things because your way works better for you. But if it doesn't offer a clear advantage that'll cause the majority to say yes it's worth the effort to change, it'll never take off. Personally I see few benefits, only drawbacks.
 
Kev,
Welcome back. Good Holiday?

Pleasantries over, the reason for the Böhm's flute success was the tone holes are consistently large, excepting the two at the top, which made it louder.

The other point missed by my declining mental powers, where am I, Nurse etc, is that written music was solely concerned with intervals as it was used to spread early Church music, all choral around. What pitch you started on was dependent on whether your choir was full of hairy rugby playing basses, trebles or anything in between.

Therefore written music was transposing from the beginning. QED.
 
Zannad,
You mention that brass instruments were not able to play in all keys but they coped by using different crooks, read Mozart's taunts to his favourite horn player.

Woodwinds were also playable in all keys either by only partially covering holes or fork fingering.

Why not be really radical? Throw out equal temperament and have different instruments for each major/related minor key, as that would give perfect pitch. Amidst all the kerfuffle caused by that re-organisation, your de-transposition would not be noticed and music would be purer.

Apologies for being serious.

Forget about me and my system...let's keep the focus on transposition (this is what this thread is about).
Yourself brought the examples of valves in brass instruments....and this is one of the reasons for the need of transposing (crooks and bits weren't really practical were they?) - do you agree/disagree?
Let's face it...there are musicians with 30-40 years of experience who can't pin down exactly about the origin of transposition let alone explaining why is still here.
Perfect pitch has nothing to do with equal temperament nor just intonation pitches - if one is able to recognize any frequency by ear thats perfect pitch - i.e. 441.2Hz (just a random one close to 440Hz infact any frequency would do)...you are mislead.
 
There are two sides to this - historical reasons for transposition and usefulness today.

The history's a given, even if there's some uncertainty in places. No point in arguing about it, unless it's to clear up uncertainties.

Relevance today? For me and many others act is that it is relevant, for many of us challenged mortals who like to make music, but aren't willing (or able) to learn different fingerings for each written note. I'll never play the clarinet - not because it's different to blow, but because there are different fingerings for each ntoe, depending on which register you're playing in.

Even a system that's clearly superior - such as Boehm's flute - takes a long time to gain acceptance as existing skills have to be unlearnt and replaced with new ones. It was ease of playing - and superior tone in all registers that eventually caused Boehm's system to be adopted almost universally.

Another issue is that the different members of a transposing family have different sounds - and the C Melody sax is an example here. It doesn't have the guts of the Bb tenor (even though it's only a tone deeper) and doesn't have the sweetness of a good alto. We need those different voices. Just as the classical composers scored separately for oboe/cor anglais for example - it wasn't just the pitch....

It's like many other things - you feel that you can improve things because your way works better for you. But if it doesn't offer a clear advantage that'll cause the majority to say yes it's worth the effort to change, it'll never take off. Personally I see few benefits, only drawbacks.

So, your views aren't that different from mine - this is just a case of accepting a dated convention because it would be too much troubles to try and update it.
There are similarities between certain instruments like clarinet, sax alto, sax tenor etc. but surely one shouldn't be put off by the fact that the fingering aren't exactly the same - this is probably because there is too much emphasis on the fingers rather than the ears - this is another area were DE-transposing can be beneficial...just a though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. This may be temporary.

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,598
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom