Playing the saxophone Tonguing and vibrato

I've been doing it wrong all these years!!

Certainly a difference in tone.

Jx
Looks like most of us have been doing it wrong.

But seriously, anchor tonging is very rare among sax players and teachers. Scott just happens to be one of the few somewhat high profile YouTubers who does it. I guess it’s worth a try if traditional techniques aren’t working for you, but be aware that most people don’t play that way.
 
I couldn't and wouldn't play any other way.
Apart from various tricks and effects, Slap tongue etc.
I don't seem to have a "bump" but touching the tip of the reed with the area of the tongue behind the tip with a forward and back motion seems the most efficient and affective way to do it.
 
I couldn't and wouldn't play any other way.
Apart from various tricks and effects, Slap tongue etc.
I don't seem to have a "bump" but touching the tip of the reed with the area of the tongue behind the tip with a forward and back motion seems the most efficient and affective way to do it.
Ok, Scott and Colin. To me, immobilizing the most articulate part of the tongue is like tying one hand behind your back. You wouldn’t try to speak with the tip of your tongue immobilized, firmly planted behind your teeth, why play that way. It’s like typing with your fist instead of fingers. Very inefficient.

In any case, the one person I know who learned anchor tonguing spent months unlearning it and is glad that they did.

EDIT: Here's a good tonguing lesson from Bergonzi who also uses the speaking analogy.
View: https://youtu.be/imkfV9sqdfQ
 
Last edited:
@Ves thank you for the vids-I've definitely come across that Scott guy before-but hadn't seen those particular vids. Will try and emulate what he's doing next time I play.

I think I've got vibrato down although I could be using totally wrong technique-I know what to do but it's hard to tell what my mouth is doing. Especially hard for me to do a wah wah or some variation into the mouthpiece and blow at the same time (I dunno if it's just me that finds this hard!) I think I have basic tonguing down but again could be wrong.

As soon as I get my sax repaired I'll put up a vid on here and see what you guys think.
 
As folks above say, there are all kinds of problems that can crop up which are easy to learn to diagnose and fix. Takes time to learn.

One of which, I found


Sometimes the 4C needs a good face wash. Teppid water and soap and such. I went through a few "no reeds work" periods that where resolved just by this.
I rinse my mouthpiece out with cold water and carefully dry after every time I play. It prevents the build-up of any kind of gunk and the growth of mold. It doesn't take long.
 
I rinse my mouthpiece out with cold water and carefully dry after every time I play. It prevents the build-up of any kind of gunk and the growth of mold. It doesn't take long.
Yeh. My issues, in this context, wasn't inside but the face / rails. There seemed to some buildup that affected playability. I don't know what it was - cellulose? lignin? - and I don't have the experience of many MP to know if it was a specific problem for the plastic Yamaha pieces.

But, for the OPs issues.... It's a possible.
 
In "The Art of Saxophone Playing" Larry Teal writes:

"These [styles of tonguing] may be divided into three general types:
  1. Tip of tongue to tip of reed.
  2. Slightly back of tip of tongue to tip of reed.
  3. Anchoring the tip of tongue on lower teeth and bending the tongue to the tip of the reed.
The method used should be determined by the shape and size of the player's tongue and oral cavity. The important consideration in the use of the tongue is that the point of the reed be contacted, regardless of the portion of the tongue used. Persons with a large oral cavity and short tongue will find that tip-to-tip tonguing is advantageous, while if the cavity is small and the tongue long, the third method works best. The great majority of players find that the rest results are produced by touching the tip of the reed with the top part of the tongue at a point slightly back from its tip."

He goes on to say that the best choice is the one where the tongue is in the most relaxed position.
 
@jbtsax very informative thanks. I didn't really take into account anatomical differences-makes sense though. It's looking more and more like I need a teacher at this point. I'll see how I improve in a couple months then decide, don't need anymore bad habits to get into and it's hard when you are learning just yourself. Although you guys have been so awesome and as helpful as is possible over the net, thanks!
 
Sax is sorted now-I wasn't being as careful with the reeds as I should've been when I wet them and put them on the mouthpiece. Think I've been accidentally brushing them and damaging them right out the packet half the time. At least I think that's it since sax plays ok now and nothing else has changed. I never had this problem with my old sax, must be getting more clumsy in my old age! Glad I didn't send sax to be fixed would've looked a right wally-nothing wrong with it!
 
In "The Art of Saxophone Playing" Larry Teal writes:



He goes on to say that the best choice is the one where the tongue is in the most relaxed position.
I'm finding that that's been one of my greatest challenges from day one... RELAXING! Initially my embouchure was way too tight, hands too tight on the instrument (sometimes still are if I'm working on something difficult and not paying attention, which just makes it more difficult), only makes sense that it's good advice even for the tongue.

After this discussion I've been paying more attention to what I'm actually currently doing with my tongue while playing. So, ha!, although I learned to use the tongue anchored near the bottom teeth, I'm finding that most of the time, like ALL the time now, it's not really anchored! It's in the vicinity but I'm not really thinking about "anchor" and it's just laying there until needed.

Regarding relaxing. One day I took a look at my face, in the mirror, while playing. That was an eye opener for me. If I had been any tighter I would have snapped something. It definitely didn't look effortless, and I fatigued faster.

So :thumb: on the Relaxing... and self awareness while playing.
 
This thread took a sudden shift from "tonguing and articulation" to "bright and dark tone".
Moved here:

 
The term legato does not in itself mean don’t tongue or articulate, because on many instruments of course the tongue is not used. It basically means connected and fluid, and the best way on a wind instrument is to slur and I’d say in most cases (again especially in an ensemble) that is how it is best interpreted.

Getting it 100% correct only really only matters hugely if you are playing in an ansemble where everyone needs to be tight and together, or else if you are playing solo and being examined on how technically correct you are. If you are playing solo there can always be freedom of expression as @lydian says. But still it’s important to learn the terminology and technique.

However if I do want to be technically correct I view a slur mark across several notes as meaning the first note is tongued and the others not, apart from to close off the last one.

This is my definition of legato when the term is used by itself, although there are types of legato where you can tongue very lightly (soft tonguing) but still so as not to make any kind of break between notes. You might see this notated with tenuto marks with or without the slur marking.

However if I am writing something for saxophone and notate a slur and no other marking I mean it to be not tongued. If I don’t want it slurred, or if the notes are all full length but lightly tongued, I would usually mark tenuto without a slur line. That avoids any confusion.

It gets confusing when you see staccato dots or tenuto lines along with a slur. To me dots and slur is meaningless, the tenuto lines and slur means soft tonguing and absolutely no break between notes, but really the slur is superfluous but maybe useful to help indicate a phrase, and I think I did that on the articulation page ad it is helpful but strictly necessary IMO (need to check that)
I find your explanation over this topic very helpful
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom